6 ms·
Buddhist office turns to Thai cyber police over AI-generated Facebook content
- FrustratedMonky 3y ago? It isn't like a Buddhist to care enough about this to get police involved. I'm Buddhist and think the pics look cool. Not like there hasn't been monks depicted in media like this for 30 years, didn't even Mortal Kombat have a killer monk?
- wccrawford 3y agoThe article says that kind of thing causes probably with community relations, so I can't blame them for wanting to stop it. It's just never going to work, though. Trolls will just do it from further away, out of their control.
- swatcoder 3y agoBuddhism and monasticism are revered social institutions in some places, not just the spiritual hobby of some Western seekers, and societies all over the world and throughout history seem inclined to protect the role and image of revered institutions. In the US, the comparison might be to its Constitution or Founding Fathers. Political free speech is enshrined in the Constitution, and often championed by its Founding Fathers, but plenty of people who are deeply committed to those institutions still get earnestly riled up if you take critical or disrespectful speech and aim it at the Constitution or Founding Fathers themselves. There's an intellectual dissonance to be found there, maybe, but it probably resolves in many people ultimately valuing a common, respected, strong social fabric over ideology and dogma.
- lovich 3y agoThere’s actually a sociological theory that the reverence for the Founding Fathers, Constitution, and related subjects are becoming a religion. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_civil_religion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_civil_religion
- kube-system 3y agoFor when you love separation of church and state so much, you build a church to preach about it.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoIsn't all religion a hobby? Just because a lot of Westerners wouldn't die for their religion, doesn't make religion a hobby. That is where you draw the line isn't it? 'True Believers' do believe in a real hell, and are willing to die for it, whether in a Jihad or a lions den. Anything less is just 'signaling' and a hobby? I was referring more to Buddhist ethics, which do not include getting bent out of shape and calling the cops because they get their feelings hurt over images. Once you go down the path of being 'revered' and a 'social institute' to be defended, then I'd say you are slipping into being just like any of the other religions with calcified hierarchical structures, a 'dogmatic orthodoxy'. And loosing the essence of Buddhism.
- swatcoder 3y agoI’m not sure you read my comment the way I intended it or the way others seem to have. While I must have communicated something poorly, there’s no denigration of individual spiritual seeking intended. I’m one of those people myself. But there’s a whole different experience of “religion” that exists for people whose religion is integrated across generations of family history, centuries old cultural institutions, widespread adoption, etc What might seem calcified and orthodox to you is the lived experience of millions of people, and their ancestors, and their community. Their relationship with that community and heritage is real and meaningful, and while your understanding of Buddhism may not be able to make sense of looking after these monks and the respect they’re seen as due, theirs does. That doesn’t mean that your understanding is lesser, in what it provides for you, or maybe even its attention to the “essence” of Buddhism, but theirs is of a different kind and no less studied.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThank You, yes, of course. You are explaining better than my response did. I wasn't actually trying to take offense. It is true that some 'true believers' really do draw the line at death and killing for religion. And there is a very large sliding scale between someone that just goes to church on Sunday then forgets about it, and someone how lives it so deeply they will become suicide bombers. Lot of gray area in between these worlds. Just I've always held out that Buddhist are different, without a 'god' to become radicalized around. The teachings of Buddha are bit more 'scientific'. It's more about reason, or if reason is still too strong, about how to understand the world. Isn't the heart sutra really about phenomenology. So, it is discouraging when a sect of Buddhist fall prey to the same foibles/downfall as say Catholicism, and become more about the 'image', than the 'understanding'. But, maybe all of this is just human nature. Built into our brains, ala William James. People have a religious experience, form a church, but eventually all religions of all stripes tend to become about a group hierarchy, and control, bureaucratic.
- cultofmetatron 3y ago> Buddhism and monasticism are revered social institutions in some places, Its a stupid and incredibly hypocritical take for this societies. (and I say this as someone who's parents come from such a culture) to become buddha, you must kill the buddha. this may sound offensive to the ignorant but revering buddha to this level is counterproductive to achieving the state of enlightenment.
- micromacrofoot 3y agoIt's a different variety of Buddhism than most are familiar with, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theravada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theravada
- jonathankoren 3y agoThe worst part is that the images were emailed, and Buddhism is about eliminating attachments.
- osjrnngoxifr982 3y agoTop kek
- RobRivera 3y agoGetout.gif
- dataviz1000 3y agoThe picture of the monk vacuuming the stairs created outrage.
- v3ss0n 3y agoi am buddhist and i cant stop laughing
- cwkoss 3y ago* the sound of one hand clapping *
- pj_mukh 3y agoDumb question: how is this handled if they weren’t AI generated images, like an actor/model wearing fake Buddhist garb playing in a rock band? I realize AI allows this to scale, but it seems the legal framework should already have a mechanism to deal with this?
- swatcoder 3y agoFrom the article, it sounds like this is already being handled through an existing legal framework. That it involves AI just reads like headline bait and maybe a dinner table discussion starter for how these could easily ramp up and become harder to trace.
- _trampeltier 3y agoOr somebody goes to a carneval as an monk ..
- noahlt 3y agoNot just headline bait, because the economics have changed: a Midjourney subscription is much cheaper than hiring an actor, costuming him as a monk, and photographing him on a rented motorcycle.
- petesergeant 3y agoSection 208 of Thai criminal code
- CodeWriter23 3y agoI'm surprised any Buddhist is this attached to their public image.
- lovich 3y agoThailand practices Therevadra Buddhism which is markedly different from the philosophical version that is the West’s impression of Buddhism. A decent analogy would be like another culture finding out about Christianity having the Trinity and being surprised because they thought Christians were monotheistic
- obscur 3y agoI don’t know how one would settle the question but I’d venture to say that Theravada is not less close to the Western impression of Buddhism than other parts of Buddhism. Additionally, many people’s ideas of Buddhism is understood through their knowledge of mindfulness which was brought to the West through Theravada to a large part.
- zoeysmithe 3y agoI imagine if you start merchandising with the Dalai Lama's image and you'll soon get sent a C&D. This isn't necessarily a Theravadin thing, imho. I practice Theravada and while it certainly is different than the US-style California Buddhism and the popular Mahayana traditions in the West (often with anything challenging or 'ethnic' or 'traditional' whitewashed for Westerners), the monks there are acting like I imagine monks near anywhere would. Its really offensive to portray monks as thrill-sensory seekers. In the West, if some church was suing because someone was photoshopping their congregation into sinful acts everyone here probably agree, "Yep, slander and libel is actionable. Speech sometimes has consequences." But if Buddhists do it, somehow its an issue. I think there's a bit of ugly Orientalism at play here. Westerners can sue and use the police, but "mysterious" and "stoic" Asian monks must, of course, be above that.
- graemep 3y ago> In the West, if some church was suing because someone was photoshopping their congregation into sinful acts everyone here probably agree, "Yep, slander and libel is actionable. Speech sometimes has consequences." It it was clearly humorous it would not be defamatory. It could only be defamatory if it made a real person actually look like they were doing something bad. If it was all a fake, or an actor, or with completely generated faces, then no. Western countries do not have blasphemy laws, a lot of Asian countries do e.g. Theravadan Buddhist Sri Lanka: https://end-blasphemy-laws.org/2020/07/sri-lankan-writer-faces-up-to-10-years-in-prison-for-hurting-religious-sentiments/ https://end-blasphemy-laws.org/2020/07/sri-lankan-writer-fac... There is a genuine legal and cultural difference here.
- neilv 3y agoAs a non-lawyer, I see two ways to look at this: 1. It's possibly defamatory. There is a public image of behavior of that order, and someone is falsifying images that contradict that. I don't know about Thai law, but my layperson understanding is that the US, for example, has some laws and precedents that might apply. 2. It's disrespectful/rude. Apparently this is something important to the monks, and people don't realize that, however cool/amusing-looking the art might seem, it bothers the people featured. So maybe focus on other ways, rather than picking on someone (especially not picking on a group that seems so inoffensive).
- pixl97 3y agoNumber two is the 'is-ought' problem. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem If I Buddhists offensive "You ought not" is not a compelling argument. For example I find fascists highly offensive and would continue picking on them even at the risk of peril. Now, you can attempt to deal with the issue socially, "It's not cool to insult Buddhists" media splurge, for example. But the success of this can very greatly depending on the motivation of the attacking group.
- neilv 3y agoTreating this as an example of a question we'll have to deal with more... In this example, I initially thought that the 2 fake images of monks I saw were cool and humorous. But then I learned that the portrayal actually bothered those people, which took much of the fun out of it. So probably I either wouldn't make images like those of monks, or if I did for some private amusement, I wouldn't distribute them. Other people, once they're aware that it's upsetting, might also decide not to do it. We collectively already have various values about rudeness and being considerate. These values will come into play more with AI-generated fake images/videos/audio/etc. and with the Internet to distribute them globally. What I think is going to complicate this is both: 1. Being widely connected by Internet, across many cultural groups, means that behaving with goodwill is harder, because there's a lot more things to know about, than just the conventions of our city. 2. Recent "Internet culture" has had a lot of sociopathic behavior in general (e.g., many Twitter behaviors), plus the relative minority of influencers often get status through sociopathic behavior. So we aren't surrounded by conspicuous examples of good behavior that would help intuition for what's good and bad. Relative to how we see ourselves, or how we aspire to be. (Though we do have fashionable mimicking and posturing, which right now is used as weapons in toxic behavior, and often without much apparent thinking. So, for example, we might see ourselves as helping those in need of help, which I think is very admirable. But the Twitter behavior we see as examples is mostly about scorched-earth attacking any peep from anyone that sounds like an idea we've been told is one of the officially bad talking points. Without individually thinking about it beyond that -- neither about what is good or bad, nor about how we respond to it, mostly just mimicking fashion we observe. This not only makes for a toxic environment that's vulnerable to manipulation/co-opting, but can make it harder to respond according to our believed values when presented with a new situation. Like the many implications of what will happen when every schoolchild can make and distribute deepfakes of anyone.)
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoGood luck with that. It sounds like any standard "fun with memes" content. I remember talking to a surrealist artist, once, about how he came up with ideas. He said that he basically used a "popsicle stick" method, where he wrote nouns, verbs, and modifiers on popsicle sticks, and then tossed them into cigar boxes. He'd shake them up, then would draw random sticks, and create an illustration, based on that. An example he gave, was "Nuns Riding Blue Bicycles."
- Devasta 3y agoIts all funny when its stuff like this, but we are definitely only a few years away from corporations using this for nefarious purposes. Someone looking to organize a trade union in her workplace? Anonymously load AI videos of that person jerking off in public or some other thing that would shatter their reputation, or worse have them confessing to crimes. Its honestly worrying.
- rattlesnakedave 3y agoWe already have state level actors laundering false information through global news outlets. What you describe is really only a continuation of that. Better processes for vetting information (be it through classical "is this source trustworthy" markers or pgp keys on the high agency end) is the only way out.
- rnk 3y agoJust look at news.google.com, at the end there's always a list of recent possible fake videos and photos that were investigated. There's usually a mix of results T/F.
- ben_w 3y agoState level actors could always do that, not only before widespread literacy ramped up between 1 and 2 centuries ago, not only before the printing press several centuries before that, but for basically all of recorded history — the etymology for "barbarian" goes back at least to Ancient Greek βάρβαρος ("foreign, non-Greek, strange"), which might be onomatopoeic mimicry of languages-foreign-to-the-Greeks, like going "blah blah" in English. And they (specifically the Athenians) rather famously had Socrates put to death for saying the wrong things. I think both show different aspects of what real (rather than the mere thought terminating cliché of the same name) "political correctness" looked like at the time. Cryptographically signing the news might be necessary, but it sure won't be sufficient, as your local government can pretty directly tell people who the trustworthy news sources are/which signatures they should trust. You need more than just the technology to solve problems like this.
- spacebacon 3y ago
- _trampeltier 3y agoIn europe it is legal to make such jokes. But in the end the price is sometimes high .. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlie_Hebdo_shooting https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlie_Hebdo_shooting
- vasdae 3y agoNot really. https://www.wsj.com/articles/europe-court-upholds-ruling-against-women-who-insulted-islam-1540580231 https://www.wsj.com/articles/europe-court-upholds-ruling-aga...
- cultofmetatron 3y agoanyone else fine it ironic that buddhist monks are letting AI generated content live rent free in their heads?
- mistrial9 3y ago.. because it is not. Social groups agitating in the public sphere, with real life consequences involving real people, real places and real things.
- supertofu 3y agoI doubt any monk allows these images to affect their practice, but the sangha (community of ordained monastics) as a whole abides by hundreds of extremely strict rules which are designed to signal to the laity their virtue and comittment to practice. It is absolutely in the interest of the sangha to ensure that the reputation of monastics is protected. That reputation has been building for thousands of years, and upholding that reputation -- carrying the very sacred teachings of the Buddha in a particularly strict and graceful way -- is very much part of the religious teachings. Images like these certainly threaten to damage that reputation among less educated laity. I myself, a convert western Buddhist no less, was surprised and a little disturbed to see these images. I imagine the shock that these images might generate for born-Buddhists and cultural Buddhists would be far stronger, and far more harmful. Don't forget that monastics depend on the laity for alms -- their literal food, medicine, the material for their dwellings, and the cloth for their robes. The sangha was designed by the Buddha to remain interdependent with the laity. The sangha could literally die out if the laity developed distrust in it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Toutouxc 3y agoHonestly I'd be much more worried about Streisand effect than the original images. Nowadays what began as a joke on some Thai Facebook group could easily become a globally recognized meme overnight. Imagine the t-shirts.