3 ms·
I've given it descriptions of non-existent "franken-languages" composed by telling it to imagine taking programming language A and adding various features I wan
by vidarh 3y ago
I've given it descriptions of non-existent "franken-languages" composed by telling it to imagine taking programming language A and adding various features I want to explore to it, and then had it correctly symbolically reason about a program written in this hypothetical language that doesn't exist anywhere, so yeah, the notion it doesn't generalize to at least some degree is nonsense, but note this involved tests on a GPT2 scale model so it's not very surprising they had poor results.
That said, even GPT4 certainly has pretty significant limitations on what it manages to reason about. But without comparing their capabilities in other aspects, arguably so do most humans. We tend to force our way past those limitations by learning incrementally by doing over and over. Current models don't get that luxury without complicated fine-tuning steps, so if anything what should surprise us is how well they do with the limitation of only context to act as short-term memory.
- simbolit 3y agoThe way I understand the paper, his is still a domain-specific tasks, and it is interpolating. What (according to the paper) transformer models are bad at, is out-of-domain extrapolation (which given that modern models are basically trained on all the internet is kinda uncommon).
- vidarh 3y agoIf so, then I'd argue that most of humans' "out of domain extrapolation" is domain-specific interpolation as well, and that most humans would struggle to meet the bar.
- simbolit 3y agoNo disagreement. This is only relevant for the AI-bro fantasy of AI becoming exponentially smarter than humans.
- vidarh 3y agoI don't think it's clear whether or not extrapolation in a sense that'd clear that bar is of much relevance to becoming smart at all.
- simbolit 3y agoThe AI-bro fantasy is of AI building a smarter AI, which then builds an even smarter one. If this isn't extrapolation, does it exist?
- vidarh 3y agoI'm not sure whether that requires extrapolation or not. It depends on what you consider extrapolation. I'd be pretty sceptical of the notion that it requires extrapolation on the basis of a use of the term as extreme as the one above. (And btw., if that is what you consider the "AI-bro fantasy" then I'm firmly in that camp. There is no logical reason to assume that's not possible; short of identifying a non-deterministic, non-materialistic source of intelligence in human brains that violates known physics and that we can't emulate, it's just a question of when, not if, and the reason for not going full tilt on that right now is down to a variant of the Wait Calculation, not a need for intelligence to kick it off - that is, trying to kickstart that now is likely to be more expensive and not be any faster than trying to kickstart it next year, and so on, and the question is guessing at when that stops being true)