3 ms·
> A jury is already allowed to make any inference they want No, they aren't, which is why jury verdicts (except for criminal acquittals, which are Constitution
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> A jury is already allowed to make any inference they want
No, they aren't, which is why jury verdicts (except for criminal acquittals, which are Constitutionally special as a limitation on the ability of the government to impose criminal punishment) can be overturned as a matter of law by the judge (or an appeals court) if they are not supported by non-excluded evidence in the case from which they are legally permitted to fraw the conclusions they have and from which the judge or appeals court finds a reasonable jury could make the inference.
OTOH, juries generally are able to draw negative inferences from destruction of evidence, and even in some situations from failure to preserve it by a party, and more generally from conduct of a witness bearing on their general credibility or their credibility on the specific testimony at issue.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]