12 ms·
Google ends deal to build 15,000 Bay Area homes due to "market conditions"
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoThis is why the current high-interest-rate approach worries me. Inflation is high in part because capacity is low. Yet, due to short term demand destruction (meant to "get supply and demand in balance"), long term supply will also not be created, and productive capacity will be permanently diminished. Like in this case, for short term reasons related to "market conditions", Google is canceling construction of 15k homes. It's actually absurd and obscene when you stop to think about it.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>the current high-interest-rate This current level of interest rates was the norm before the money printing bonanza of 2010-2022. Only that ~decade of ultra low rates was the exception not the norm. And yet housing was still being built back then. So what gives? From what I saw from that last decade, ultra cheap rates for too long just leads to a bunch of speculation bubbles as everyone and his dog goes into debt as much as they can and inflating everything.
- cj 3y agoIn my area of the US, you have to move mountains in order to get a plumber, electrician, carpenter, etc to show up. To get work done on my house, it involves leaving messages with at least 10 people, getting callbacks from maybe 1-2, and hoping to god the person actually shows up (when they do show up, it's probably a month after the first call). (Private equity is capitalizing on this by buying out local plumbing/electrician/hvac companies to merge them into full service companies with a call center, CRM for customers, tech-enabled scheduling and dispatch systems... which is all good, except they charge 2-3x higher rates compared to your local plumber... so the option is <call PE-owned plumbing company and pay 2-3x the price to have someone show up tomorrow> or <call 10 local plumbers and pray that 1 of them calls you back and actually shows up>) I imagine house builders and contractors have more reliable networks of workers to draw on compared to the average homeowner. But maybe the availability of workers to build a house isn't what it used to be?
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>you have to move mountains in order to get a plumber, electrician, carpenter, etc to show up. Watch the latest South Park episode: https://youtu.be/RcoGzT9QrTI?si=m95_pQ9H203hcfuW https://youtu.be/RcoGzT9QrTI?si=m95_pQ9H203hcfuW
- anon84873628 3y agoThis seems to be the real bottle neck in the housing supply chain, and why prices are so high. Simple fact is that there aren't enough skilled people to actually build the houses.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoPossibly partially because they can't afford to live near where people most desperately want houses built.
- SoftTalker 3y agoAnd why do rates matter to Google, they can pay cash.
- greenie_beans 3y agowe didn't build enough housing during zero interest rates, why do you think we'll make up the deficit with higher interest rates?
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoWhere did I claim that? I only asked how come we managed to build housing before the 2008 crash when the interest rates where like today.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gottorf 3y agoHas there been any evidence that the long period of ultra-low interest rates we enjoyed resulted in additional productive capacity? It sounds like a lot of it just went to unprofitable SaaS companies and other virtual endeavors, and not so much to things that exist in the physical world.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dopamean 3y ago> the long period of ultra-low interest rates we enjoyed resulted in additional productive capacity If there is evidence of that I'd love to see it. If this was true then we'd have a huge supply of homes all over America now which I think is not the case is it? All I hear about is undersupply driving up home prices despite demand being low. I live in Austin where this is very true so maybe I'm in a bit of a bubble?
- notaustinpowers 3y agoEven with the ultra-low interest rates, supply was kept low due to nervousness from home builders. Builders were decimated in the housing crisis and, honestly, never recovered. To them, the collapse came sudden and quick, and many housing projects and developments just sit half-finished even to this day. The focus was turned from single-family housing to apartments, specifically luxury apartments as the luxury housing sector picked up steam quickly as developers and investors jumped on those properties when they were at their lowest prices. So "luxury" apartments were built at low-costs and purchased by investment firms. The main focus was for the builder to get their money back and more as quickly as possible, minimizing their risk, and the investors in the new complex got a bargain "luxury" property that they can increase rents quickly on, while ensuring demand since fewer and fewer single-family homes were being built. The current issue of supply and demand for housing is, largely, artificially created, possibly accidentally. Single-family housing is just risky now, apartments are less risky. But as people are desiring yards and space again (due to COVID and WFH), we are now seeing the rental model extend to "build-to-rent" single-family communities.
- 3y ago
- brvsft 3y agoGoogle would not have considered constructing 15k homes had interest rates not been at historic lows. They're not in the construction or real estate business. And I fail to see what is absurd and obscene, except perhaps the inverse, that low interest rates caused such extreme market distortions that you have a massive company outside of the real estate industry looking into creating 15,000 homes. What is not absurd or obscene about that to you? We don't live in the company-town days any more (not that Google was trying to create a company-town, but they are, again, not in the real estate business).
- anon84873628 3y agoPrior to the pandemic, Google needed more office space, and it needed workers in the Bay Area. I don't view this plan as ever being about "getting into real estate". It was just a way to get cities to agree to office construction, and also ensure that workers were willing/able to live nearby. Anyway, given the amount of office space Google still owns and manages, they are very much "in real estate" in that regard...
- wwweston 3y agoAs far as I can tell it's a bit of a "these are the tools we have" kind of thing. The institutions that could do effective targeted supply-stimulating policymaking are hobbled if not hamstrung right now, while central banks are less so but only have blunt macro tools to work with. There's not really much solution other than "people have to care about concrete policy, or at least specifically supply."
- dehrmann 3y ago> high-interest-rate approach These are historically normal interest rates.
- tacocataco 3y agoThe for-profit home building industry created this problem, and I feel they shouldn't be involved in its solution.
- simlevesque 3y agoGoogle cancels yet another project.
- we_love_idf 3y agoThis time it is worse. Real people and their lives are affected.
- baz00 3y agoHey I was one of the three Google Wave users.
- Nifty3929 3y agoI wonder who the third one is.
- wholinator2 3y agoThe QA engineer at Google
- baz00 3y agoQA at Google is a lie. Just like the cake!
- ar_lan 3y agoMe too. I wonder who the third is.
- antisthenes 3y agoIt was me. I used it to collaborate with someone on a pointless college project about 14 years ago. I think we even uploaded a few files and sent a few messages.
- dylan604 3y ago
- brink 3y agoGoogle is like the CCP in the respect of consistency. They say they'll something, but history shows that they're erratic and unreliable and change their mind on a whim. Saying one thing and doing another. It's the reason why so many companies are pulling out of China, and it's the same reason why Google is floundering.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoThat's why you don't leave stuff as important to the people as housing, to a for profit corporation who's accountable to it's shareholders not to the taxpayers. This scenario feels more like the fictional OCP in Robocop.
- loeg 3y agoDid we read the same comment? The GP is criticizing Google and a government. It may or may not be ideal to "leave" housing to private developers, but "that's" not why.
- tomjakubowski 3y agoI think the comparison demonstrates that big corporate bureaucracies are about as unaccountable as big government bureaucracies.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoCentralized planning is hard, in that changing the plan even close to optimally is hard. Changing the plan costs trust and resources. Not changing the plan also costs trust and resources. Can't win, the game is to lose the least.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- josefresco 3y agoDisclaimer: I know nothing about this sort of thing, just doing some napkin math. $15 billion for 15,000 homes is about a million dollars a home? Sounds... high. Especially when you're talking about multi-unit, higher density housing.
- riku_iki 3y agoIt's current market price. Land costs money.
- miohtama 3y agoIn San Francisco, a toilet alone may cost $1.7M https://abc7news.com/sf-bathrooms-noe-valley-public-toilet-17-million-restroom-donation/12739362/ https://abc7news.com/sf-bathrooms-noe-valley-public-toilet-1...
- coding123 3y ago> "Put it to better use. It's ridiculous. $1.7 million for a stupid bathroom," that was a resident interviewed in Oct. 2022. Wow Apparently it went down in price. But my only comment for the "put it to better use" would be that if a toilet is 1.7m, then anything else will consume 1.7m for just the meetings on what the alternative would be.
- walr000s 3y agoStill a long way to go to catch up to Geneva.
- mistrial9 3y agomost parties directly involved benefit from higher total sticker prices. See also Former SF building inspector took bribes headline.. as if only one did !
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 3y ago> $15 billion for 15,000 homes is about a million dollars a home? > Sounds... high It would be high for that, but it wasn't $15 billion for 15,000 homes, it was $15 billion for a Google office expansion plus development of “residential, retail, hospitality, and community development space,”, the residential component of which would have included 15,000 homes.
- guardiangod 3y agoI thought the activists are against this because 'Google is building a company town!' Shouldn't they be happy that Google has ended the deal? Now no one gets to live in houses.
- riku_iki 3y agoBut I think they still build bunch of offices which are still in development.
- hashtag-til 3y agoThey forgot to add the safety nets to the buildings! Easy mistake.
- coding123 3y agoThis is my experience with almost every topic on HN...
- unethical_ban 3y agoSocratic discussion, excessive skepticism, or antagonistic metacommentary?
- dpkirchner 3y agoI'd add: Ignorance of the concept of hyperbole.
- harryVic 3y agoLife is too easy in the west and especially in tech. People love to complain about absolutely anything.
- pie420 3y agoSo true. It was such a shock moving here from Chicago. People make 50% more money, work less, have better weather, and spend all day in useless meetings where people take turns going on 10 minute long tangential, corporate buzzword filled monologues. And I'm in an industry that makes essential, life-saving products. Can't imagine what it's like in big tech.
- achenet 3y agookay, this is probably a really stupid question but if you're trying to cut down on real estate cost, why not go full remote and sell all your office space?
- bobthepanda 3y agoSome tax break programs (bring X jobs to an area) have clawback provisions. There’s also the matter of, if everyone is selling, now you have to fire sell into a huge market glut and realize a huge loss.
- strikelaserclaw 3y agoi really believe that 60-70% of back to office is about having fiefdoms for executives
- valianteffort 3y agoThere is some element of that I'm sure but let's not pretend most people don't get less work done at home.
- Arelius 3y agoI think your really going to have to cite your sources here. Based on the studys I've seen the it looks like the Jury is still out. And anecdotally it's been a big boost to most of the places I have direct involvement in.
- valianteffort 3y agoIt's a lazy appeal to authority to immediately say "well where's the study" as though empirical data means nothing. Everyone I know who is WFH admits they get less done. Yes their quality of life is better, and part of that is working less. A study saying the complete opposite means nothing to me because the world that I occupy says otherwise.
- 3y ago
- renewiltord 3y agoMy god. The comments here are like they're generated by an LLM. "Google cancel project. One more to the dead google project lol" Even the slightest awareness of local conditions would have improved these comments. The Google developments suffered from the same opposition any residential developer faces in the Bay Area. https://nextcity.org/features/why-one-silicon-valley-city-said-no-to-google https://nextcity.org/features/why-one-silicon-valley-city-sa... In addition, the towns of the Bay also made a big fuss about "company towns". For those who aren't acquainted with the Bay Area, residents of the region in general strongly oppose any housing. Explanations given range from "The Bay Area is full" to "People shouldn't be living like sardines on top of each other" to "Where will my friends park when they visit". A housing project being cancelled after years of opposition is normal not, out of the ordinary.
- p_j_w 3y ago>The comments here are like they're generated by an LLM. "Google cancel project. One more to the dead google project lol" I understand why people post such low effort trash: "make number bigger". What I don't quite understand is why people upvote the same dorky joke they've seen others post a million times. It's baffling to me.
- pchristensen 3y agoI'm very pro-housing, but one valid concern is that residential real estate generally doesn't pay its way, especially with school-age children, and California's Prop 13 makes this problem worse over time by freezing tax rate growth. So any housing in your municipality is a fiscal negative to start that gets worse over time. Normally I would say that the tax code isn't set in stone, but in California's case, it is in the state constitution.
- seltzered_ 3y ago"Google partnered with the Australian company Lendlease in 2019" Worth noting the original deal announcement was pre-pandemic (June 2019). Lots has changed since then.
- kurthr 3y agoThis started around 2017. There were lots of plans and tours and proposals. I hear a lot about how this is NIMBYs keeping everyone out, but this was a redevelopment project for a lot of commercial property near a bus/train/lightrail/BART(in the next 5-10 years) terminal. The YIMBYs were the ones who slowed it down with endless demands. I'm generally supportive of their goals, but it was pretty clear to me that by delaying it for years they would get a market cycle turn and nothing for their efforts. To be completed by 2025 it should have started a couple of years ago when financing was cheap. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/20/us/california-today-google-san-jose-silicon-valley.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/20/us/california-today-googl... Now it will be partially demolished empty buildings and blight for the next decade. I hope the city/county just start taxing empty lots and buildings for the lost tax revenue rather than letting the owners sit on it for decades like they did with the old malls from the 80s which were empty till the 00s. Not doing anything with prime land in the middle of a city should have a cost too.
- joshuamorton 3y agoDo you have some examples of this? Given that yimbys are usually definitionally the "yes build it, yes at market rate, yes it can skip the environmental impact assessment" folks, what did they do to block this?
- kurthr 3y agoIt's the same thing that just happened in east San Jose using the "builder's remedy" to reduce the number of units by 5x. YIMBY's like to think the builders are on their side, but they aren't. They'll take the low cost property and either sit on it for years or turn it into luxury townhomes and empty commercial space with minimal low cost housing, green space or anything else using public transit as an excuse. Privatize the profits and socialize the loss. https://therealdeal.com/sanfrancisco/2023/11/05/remedy-for-whom-bay-area-developers-use-builders-remedy-loophole-to-downsize-housing-projects/ https://therealdeal.com/sanfrancisco/2023/11/05/remedy-for-w... One development, initially planned near the Berryessa BART station, was intended to accommodate up to nearly 3,500 housing units and vast commercial space. However, the current proposal only includes 451 townhomes, 399 apartments, and 90 condominiums, alongside 45,000 square feet of commercial space. Google was a little different here, but got treated the same. They wanted to build a transit hub complex for their growing and aging employees. YIMBYs saw this as gentrification (yes it was and would be), but the reason housing there is low cost is because of empty commercial and blight (next to the railroad tracks/highway). Adding 10k+ homes/office would have helped revitalize the commercial in the area and probably raised local prices (people from Google move in). So they pushed hard for lots of mitigation for locals and low cost housing, which delayed it for a business cycle so now you have dozens of contemned buildings and no prospect for building. Or you'll get the most profitable disorganized "builders remedy" instead, which will be fewer units, higher priced, and less integrated into the neighborhood. Perfect is the enemy of good.
- orange_county 3y agoThe fact that we need tech companies to build housing on behalf of the city is a huge policy failure. The city should have just rezoned many parts of the city a long time ago for mixed used. But instead the city and its residents has always fought against new housing. It’s only because of new RHNA mandates that they are required to zone for new housing. This is going to be a win for NIMBYs. I hope the cities involved will rezone other areas especially in single family neighborhoods such that we can get more housing when interest rates drop. There is a lot of demand still for housing and there are policy tools that can be leveraged to encourage more housing to be built.
- 4death4 3y ago> But instead the city and its residents has always fought against new housing. Isn’t that how a democracy is supposed to work? If the residents don’t want the changes, where does one derive the (moral) authority to override their desires?
- Clubber 3y ago>If the residents don’t want the changes, where does one derive the (moral) authority to override their desires? This really. My mid sized city has had an influx of covid restriction refugees and it's just too many people. Traffic is awful, everything is super crowded all the time. Inflation is out of wack and higher than other places. People really need to consider both sides of the coin.
- greenie_beans 3y agothe cycles of the free market will never solve our housing problems.
- bobthepanda 3y agoThat assumes the market is free. Zoning in the Bay Area is pretty much the exact opposite.
- greenie_beans 3y agoby definition, the bay area real estate market is a free market. housing is a problem across the entire country because of low supply as a result of underbuilding (among other things). and yes, the underbuilding is even more extreme in places like the bay area due to zoning. i should have been more specific: capitalism will not solve the problem of housing. it had it's chance to build housing to meet demand during the low interest rate environment and yet it didn't provide. this underbuilding happened in places with both lax zoning and prohibitive discretionary zoning. all the while, rents keep raising in the free market due to low supply. capitalism will not build to meet the needs in a high interest rate / high inflation environment because the payoff won't be worth the risk. there needs to be some government intervention on the scale of the new deal if we want to solve our housing crisis. can somebody give a good argument why capitalism will solve our housing problems, with an emphasis on how it will work in a high interest rate inflationary environment? i'm genuinely curious to hear an argument for that. and use examples where it addressed problems in an area with both lax zoning and bay area-like zoning, since imo reforming zoning regulations is only one part of the puzzle.
- bobthepanda 3y agoBanks, developers, and realtors are not a unified cartel, they will totally undercut each other if they can, and they are humans that do not have the power of prediction. Generally speaking, the mechanism by which prices decline is that overzealous building in the boom phase leads to overleveraged people losing their shirts in the bust. The most spectacular example of this is the Japanese asset bubble which has never been returned to; at its peak, the Imperial Palace had a valuation more than the entire state of California. But where I live in Seattle, we are starting to see the effects of the high interest rates; homes are staying available for longer, I am seeing 10-20% valuation drops compared to a year ago and further price cuts in my neighborhood. A particular source of pain this cycle will be people who bought for AirBnB who can’t afford the interest payments anymore. —- Zoning is not free in the Bay Area. One major difference is “by-right” development, where buildings that meet predefined codes are automatically approved without political review. For example, most development in New York is by-right. By-right development is not the norm in California, which leads to an expensive, extractive review where people attempt to get their pound of flesh on every single project.
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoThis gives me very mixed feelings. On one hand I applaud any attempt to build more affordable houses and am sad when those attempts fall apart. The Bay Area especially, but the US in general, needs to take a serious look at how we plan and build cities... and how much they currently suck. These mixed-use communities are a great for creating more walkable, transit friendly, cities. That being said. The entire concept that tech giants being the ones to theoretically create new real estate empires... gives me a lot of Snowcrash vibes. And yes, I know the real estate megacorps of today are probably worse than Google. Really doesn't help.
- hyggetrold 3y ago> gives me a lot of Snowcrash vibes I often feel this way also. Snowcrash seems like the future we are cruising towards.
- rnk 3y agoAnd our world is without reliable 30 minute pizza delivery by mafia owned pizza chains. At least no one gets pooned.
- ShakataGaNai 3y agoSeriously. All of the down sides, none of the delicious pizza loving upsides.
- jmugan 3y agoTo me it is more Oryx and Crake by Margaret Atwood.
- morkalork 3y agoBeen getting that feeling a lot lately with all the news about pig heart transplants and lab grown meat.
- sershe 3y agoAm I the only one who thought the core of the society described in the book was more of an utopia than a dystopia? Then, she added perverted(early on)/misanthropic deviant genius to destroy it, a character that lacked even basic verisimilitude by himself, or in context? While the plot was enjoyable as easy reading, the background to me was like someone took one of those space-age-futuristic (or maybe modern solarpunk) landscapes and wrote "I disapprove" over it in red ink as a form of criticism.
- avelis 3y agoLooks like "market conditions" tell me that RTO (return to office) is not happening either.
- adamsb6 3y agoIf it didn't take years to even get permission to start building something in the Bay Area they could have already built something.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jfim 3y agoThat's unfortunate, the Moffett Park development in Sunnyvale (https://www.moffettparksp.com/ https://www.moffettparksp.com/) looked good, I hope it won't be impacted too much.
- hfjjbf 3y ago[dead]
- flandish 3y agoPromised housing improvements while selling approval for a deal but it turns out you won’t profit after the market changes? Back out and protect your investors - screw housing. Sigh. I hate corporations.