5 ms·
Contraceptive pills might impair fear-regulating regions in women's brains
- spandextwins 3y agoOf course. Why not include that as a feature?
- kaoD 3y agoWho would want to experience more fear in safe situations? > This part of the prefrontal cortex is thought to sustain emotion regulation, such as decreasing fear signals in the context of a safe situation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kroltan 3y ago> Who would want to experience more fear in safe situations? If the current pathological behaviour of content feed algorithms is to be believed, the vast majority of people.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tgtweak 3y agoThey really run a number on your emotions. Not surprised to see this but fairly surprised to see it coming out this long after they've been on the market.
- fallingfrog 3y agoWhat other effects do they have on your emotions? From your perspective?
- williamdclt 3y agoAnecdotally, I’ve heard from women friends about pills having effect on depression, libido and anxiety. Not super surprising given how much it messes up with hormones
- kaoD 3y ago> Their findings showed that ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) thickness of women who were using OCs was reduced compared to men I would expect the study to compare it to other women not using OCs. Does this methodology make some sense that I'm missing?
- goda90 3y agoBad summary. They compared it to women who stopped taking it and women who never took it as well. That's why they think the effect is reversible.
- ickelbawd 3y agoThey did in fact. > Methods: We recruited healthy adults aged 23-35 who identified as women currently using (n = 62) or having used (n = 37) solely combined OCs, women who never used any hormonal contraceptives (n = 40), or men (n = 41). > Results: Compared to men, all three groups of women exhibited a larger GMV of the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex, while only current users showed a thinner ventromedial prefrontal cortex. Irrespective of the menstrual cycle phase, never users exhibited a thicker right anterior insular cortex than past users. (Source: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fendo.2023.1228504/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fendo.2023.1228...) I agree with you it’s somewhat confusing why they use men as their benchmark. But really this isn’t my field of expertise.
- RamblingCTO 3y ago> who identified as women What a weird thing to say if you study the effect of the pill on women.
- jstanley 3y agoIt's not that they "identified as women", it's that they self-identified whether they were using contraceptives or not, i.e. it was not checked.
- locopati 3y agoThey could be making it clear that this does not include trans men, who are still capable of getting pregnant despite being on testosterone.
- Nzen 3y agotl;dr article describing a study [0] by Peyrot,C, Brouillard,A, et al comparing the ventromedial prefrontal cortex volume between the brains of { women using, women abstaining from, women who never used, men } oral contraceptives. They found reduced volume in the brains of women using contraceptives and some amount of recovery in women abstaining. The linked article is ambiguous about whether the effect dampens or increases fear, but the study indicates a correlation between hormonal contraceptives and higher stress. [0] https://www.scopus.com/record/display.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85127745104&origin=inward&txGid=31e4a657f73c585e63276d2a28dc747f https://www.scopus.com/record/display.uri?eid=2-s2.0-8512774... [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0005796720300668?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00057...
- rjsw 3y agoDoes the study control for whether the women have a cat or not?
- zrail 3y agoWhy would it?
- giantg2 3y agoToxoplasmosis maybe?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- achenet 3y agodue to toxoplasmosis?
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoI would assume the parent meant toxo but it's a weird segue. To my knowledge, toxo doesn't distinctly impact what's under study here.
- bertil 3y agoBeing infected with toxoplasmosis could be an interesting thing to control for, for all subjects, but their samples are already relatively small, so I am not sure any observation would be significant…
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Qem 3y agoPotential for correlation here. Just anecdata, but childless people very often have pets instead, at least taking the sample of people I know. So perhaps pet (and so cat) ownership and long term birth control are correlated to some degree.
- devit 3y agoWhy do people use pills rather than copper IUDs? At least based on information on the web, it seems copper IUDs are strictly better: cheap, easy to insert and remove, nothing to do after initial insertion, no side effects other than "increased menstrual flow".
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://cwhccolorado.com/services/birth-control/iud/iud-complications/index.html https://cwhccolorado.com/services/birth-control/iud/iud-comp... Potential complications from use. Have heard some horror stories with regards to IUD failure (and resulting pregnancy) and uterus perforation, so it is not such a small risk as to by hypothetical.
- Someone1234 3y ago> easy to insert and remove Aren't they meant to be extremely painful to insert/remove?
- sjsdaiuasgdia 3y ago> no side effects other than "increased menstrual flow". It's my understanding that with birth control pills, a woman can indefinitely delay her menstrual cycle. I can absolutely see some making a choice to not have periods at all, if the other side effects for them are negligible. An option that not only brings periods back but makes them messier would not look very attractive in comparison. As with most things health and lifestyle, everything involves tradeoffs, and choices are dependent on individual valuation of those tradeoffs.
- b112 3y agoDoes that mean her eggs aren't being used up?
- elil17 3y agoMost doctors won't give patients pain meds beyond NSAIDs, even though the insertion procedure is very painful.
- deleted 3y ago
- Perceval 3y agoFear is central to some of the most important and foundational works of political theory in Western history – Hobbes, Montesquieu, Tocqueville: https://www.amazon.com/Fear-History-Political-Corey-Robin/dp/0195189124/ https://www.amazon.com/Fear-History-Political-Corey-Robin/dp... What are the socio-political effects of mass psychological changes brought about by putting a large chunk of the population on medications without full knowledge of the side effects? Imagine putting an equally large percentage of the population on androgenic medications.
- Eumenes 3y ago> What are the socio-political effects of mass psychological changes brought about by putting a large chunk of the population on medications without full knowledge of the side effects? Not really a question big pharma is interested in discussing ...
- Spivak 3y agoBecause there's no reason to assume that the "default" state of nature is some ideal or good for anything. It could be but what are the odds? We're still apes in a world that changed wildly out of pace with the speed of natural evolution. > equally large percentage of the population on androgenic medications Its funny you say this because doing this would actually put humanity back to the testosterone levels men had for most of human history.
- anon291 3y ago> s funny you say this because doing this would actually put humanity back to the testosterone levels men had for most of human history. Women and men respond differently to testosterone, so this argument does not hold.
- Spivak 3y agoThe equally large population you wanted to give testosterone to wasn't men?
- aaomidi 3y ago
- Eumenes 3y agoA good friend of mine developed a serious case of pcos from birth control medication which started in her teen years. It's impacting her fertility, growing facial hair, pre-diabetes symptoms, and impacting weight gain/loss. Her doctors just "shrug" and suggest to get back on birth control as a solution. Imagine allowing your teenage daughter to be on a semi-permeant dosage of hormone altering poison.
- cfu28 3y agoI didn’t think PCOS could be triggered by birth control - doesn’t seem to be a lot of evidence to support this either. Looking at the mechanism of action of COCs, I can’t think of a mechanism of why COCs would cause PCOS. Oral contraceptives are usually first line in treating PCOS which makes this anecdote even more weird. Can you provide any more information?
- Eumenes 3y agoIts not an officially supported theory, but there's alot of anecdotal evidence out there that going off of BC after many years can cause these symptoms with some women.
- icelight 3y agoIf using OC is a possible treatment, wouldn't the likelier explanation be that using it suppressed the preexisting condition and quitting just revealed the symptoms?
- throw932490 3y agoContraceptive pill simulates pregnancy at hormonal levels. That includes partner selection and preferences. Imagine your partner is on a pill while you date, you get married and try for kids. She stops pill and there is a huge change in her chemistry . It also stops ovulation. It plays a huge role in female sexuality, to the point some people have trouble to orgasm.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Imagine your partner is on a pill while you date, you get married and try for kids. She stops pill and there is a huge change in her chemistry. Why imagine this?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoWe want to believe attraction and desire is more free will then it is (vs hormones and brain chemistry), and there is uncertainty of whether a relationship will persist when birth control use changes. https://behavioralscientist.org/quality-sex-relationships-birth-control-pill-research-effects/ https://behavioralscientist.org/quality-sex-relationships-bi... > But an even bigger positive is what comes when we look at the divorce rate. Despite the whole my-sex-life-is-meh-and-I-am-not-that-attracted-to-my-partner thing, women who chose their partners when they were on the pill were significantly less likely to divorce than women who chose their partners when they were off it (!!!). > This suggests that being on the pill may lead women to choose partners who are good resource providers and willing to stick with them through thick and thin (hence the lower divorce rate and greater satisfaction with resource investment). However, equally as noteworthy, this research found that when these pill-taking women did get divorced, they were overwhelmingly the ones who initiated it (they were the initiators 84.5 percent of the time, compared to being the initiators 73.6 percent of the time among those who chose their partners when not on the pill). This suggests that, in choosing these faithful, resource-investing men as partners (and at the expense of sexiness), pill-taking women may be putting themselves at risk for becoming dissatisfied with their relationship due to a lack of attraction and sexual satisfaction if they ever go off of it. Emphasis is author's.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vasectomy 3y agoIf you’re a man who doesn’t want children or has finished having children: get a vasectomy. They’re easy, low risk and help reduce the (significant) contraceptive burden on partners. (Although technically a vasectomy is reversible, it isn’t guaranteed and so a vasectomy is not a good option if you intend to have children someday)
- gumby 3y agoI consider it a hardware upgrade.
- cies 3y agoSoftware upgrade: immutable by default. :)
- WA 3y agoNot as easy as the current trend of "just get a vasectomy, it's easy and reversible" suggests. The problem with a vasectomy is that there is a low, but non-zero chance that you get long-lasting pain from it. After all, they cut through a bunch of nerves and muscles. These aren't just some dumb useless tubes. So, given you're in a stable relationship, you essential trade X years of care-free sex (until menopause) for a slight risk that it fucks you up pretty badly. In other words: the potential upside is limited, the potential downside is quite severe. Regarding reversibility: Not as easy. It's a sophisticated operation which requires a specialist and takes 2-3 hours. If your body produces more sperm than it can absorb, they might rupture tiny tubes in your epididymis, which makes it almost impossible to reverse. The risk is higher the longer ago the vasectomy was.
- cies 3y agoFriend had a lot of pain from one going bad. He's stil happy with it now. But not entirely risk free.
- gwervc 3y ago> suggesting a mechanism on how OC use could impair emotion regulation in women This doesn't surprise me the slightest, as I've noticed change in behavior in my ex-girlfriend between the periods (pun intended) she was on pill or not. She was more emotional, and seemed to have a bit harder time to control herself. It's quite scary how medicine with such impact are marketed as something quite benign, even by public institutions.
- dangom 3y agoI appreciate that people are looking into this, and I think more research of this kind should be funded. However, one needs to be cautious when claiming an "impairment" in fear regulating regions from a measure of cortical thickness with MRI. For once, there is no evidence that a slightly thinner or larger cortical thickness means better or worse regulation of any kind. Second, morphology studies are susceptible to many sources of biases which are not really addressed in this study. For example, anything that affects hydration levels or causes a redistribution of blood and cerebral spinal fluid volume can lead to significant changes in measures of cortical thickness, since they will change the contrast between gray and white matter that drive cortical thickness measurements. Changes in thickness have been found even when comparing people scanned in the morning and in the evening [1]. Any drug intervention could be expected to cause physiological changes that could act as confounds. Also, in the discussion one reads: "Interestingly, no lasting effects of combined oral contraceptives (COCs) use were detected when comparing the four groups." This suggests that the changes could be driven by physiological changes instead of permanent changes in brain circuitry. It would be great to see a follow up study controlling for potential confounding effects (for example, measuring baseline perfusion, blood pressure and controlling for time of day effects and usage of other drugs), and expanding the study with functional tests that involve fear regulation. [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1053811916001439 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S105381191...