4 ms·
The TIOBE index is measuring the hits these languages get on Google, Blogger, Wikipedia, YouTube and other search engines. See: http://www.tiobe.com/index.php/
by bad_user 15y ago
The TIOBE index is measuring the hits these languages get on Google, Blogger, Wikipedia, YouTube and other search engines.
See: http://www.tiobe.com/index.php/content/paperinfo/tpci/tpci_definition.htm http://www.tiobe.com/index.php/content/paperinfo/tpci/tpci_d...
It's easy to see how this measures the wrong thing. A better metric for me is the popularity of languages in open-source software, which could be measured by (say) the number of popular/active projects.
For instance take a look at: https://github.com/languages https://github.com/languages ... but this also has flaws, because GitHub is favored in the Javascript/Ruby communities and open-source C#/.NET projects end up mostly on CodePlex, a lot of Java projects are hosted by Apache, a lot of Python projects are on BitBucket and so on.
So a better metric would be to aggregate the projects from all popular project hosting services and count them, with some kind of weight attached. So for instance it would be unfair to count the lines of code in the Linux kernel, but it would also be unfair for the Linux kernel to have the same weight as some random project on GitHub that's being watched by 5 people. I would make this weight proportional to the number of active contributers, such that when a project is left unmaintained its weight will eventually drop to zero.
- MattJ100 15y agoTake a look at http://www.ohloh.net/languages http://www.ohloh.net/languages - you can sort by lines or commits.
- lkrubner 15y ago>So a better metric would be to aggregate the projects from > all popular project hosting services and count them, with > some kind of weight attached. Great idea. Do you think you might run with this idea? I like it as a corrective to TIOBE. On another topic: I know that TIOBE sometimes lumps several related languages together. Does anyone know if they are doing that with "Lisp"? What does "Lisp" measure? Common Lisp? Scheme? Emacs lisp? Does it measure Clojure?
- davidw 15y agoSomeone can and has run with it: http://langpop.com http://langpop.com "Unfortunately", that someone now has a house, two kids, and more work than he can handle, and is thus looking to exit the fun and flame filled world of language popularity. Based on Instagram's valuation, I guess I'd settle for a million for it;-)
- lkrubner 15y agoHi, David. I am stupid. I've checked out your site before and had totally forgotten about it. Can you email me at lawrence @ krubner . com? I'd like to know how much you want to sell langpop for.
- andyzweb 15y agoamount of open source code written in a particular language ≠ that language's popularity
- dwc 15y agoI would expect open source projects to have a bias toward languages inside the open source ecosystem. Specifically, languages that are open source themselves, or are historically popular within open source operating systems. I would not expect a survey of languages on the proprietary side to match very well. That said, you wrote "a better metric" and I agree.