3 ms·
> Since 1998, Apple has declared all of its online sales made in California as having taken place in Cupertino. How did anyone think that was okay, and how did
by rayiner 3y ago
> Since 1998, Apple has declared all of its online sales made in California as having taken place in Cupertino.
How did anyone think that was okay, and how did it escape notice for 25 years.
- madrox 3y agoThis came from an era when online purchases did not have sales tax
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FireBeyond 3y agoAnd yet even Amazon complied and now computes tax based on where the buyer is. As does B&H. Years ago (approaching, if not a decade ago).
- lotsofpulp 3y agoSo does Apple, for even longer than Amazon and B&H since Apple has had physical locations in most states for longer than Amazon and B&H, so they always had to remit sales tax to most states.
- FireBeyond 3y agoUh, no? This entire article is how Apple declares all online sales to have happened in Cupertino, regardless of where the buyer is. Amazon doesn't do that, they say the sale happened where the buyer is. B&H does the same. Apple says "it happened in Cupertino, so we'll pay taxes related to Cupertino and our special tax agreement with Cupertino".
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThat is a California specific situation that applies to California taxes and California’s local governments’ portion of those taxes. If you are in any state, Apple still collects and remits sales tax for that state. Amazon/B&H example was that they were not collecting sales taxes in states they did not have a physical presence in, until the South Dakota Wayfair ruling.
- tzs 3y agoTechnically correct, but in practice if you bought something online from out of state it was subject to your state's use tax, which had the same rate as your state's sales tax. But your state could not make the seller collect the use tax for the state so instead consumers were required to report those purchases to their state and pay the tax. Almost no consumer did that, except for items that had to be registered like cars where the state would not allow registration if the use tax was not paid, and so the use tax was widely openly evaded. For online purchases where the buyer and seller were in the same state the state did have the power to make the seller collect sales tax and I believe most states did. It was pretty common though for the tax to be the sales tax at the seller's location, not the buyer's location. And not just in the US--prior to 2015 a seller in an EU country selling online to a buyer in another EU country collected their own country's VAT not the buyer's country's VAT. A few years ago the Supreme Court in the US decided that states could make online sellers in other states collect for them. I believe it is technically use tax that is collected in this case, not sales tax, but since the rates are the same and most consumers weren't even aware of use taxes, so everybody just calls it sales tax.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoBoiling the frog. First online purchases were tax free, Then local governments wanted a cut. Now the state wants a cut.
- alex_young 3y agoThis is about the state / local split. Right now California receives 6.25% and Cupertino receives 1%, regardless of where a California buyer lives, the processing location, or the point of purchase.
- Analemma_ 3y agoIf you're going to have sales taxes (or consumption taxes in general) at all, it makes no sense for them not to apply to online purchases. That situation was only in place for a brief time because of a weird interpretation of Constitutional law which would never have been made had internet commerce existed at the scale it does now. This isn't "the terrifying creeping overreach of government", this is "sales taxes working how they're obviously supposed to."
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIt would be preferable if the government held the buyer responsible for paying sales taxes. Moving everything to electronic payments should make this possible. Then it would be even possible to implement marginal sales taxes, so that you are progressively taxing consumption. Which would make it impossible to avoid taxes by being so wealthy that you can take a loan out to fund your lifestyle and hence not have to pay income taxes.
- Analemma_ 3y agoAny tax needs to balance how nice and efficient it is on paper with how practical it is to collect in the real world.. Replacing both income and capital gains taxes with a single wealth tax would be theoretically most efficient and incentive-aligned, but wealth taxes are extremely difficult to administer in real life, so we don't do them and instead have income and capital gains taxes as an imperfect but easy-to-collect proxy. It's the same thing with "buyer-reported sales taxes": nice in theory, impossible in practice (note that this isn't a hypothetical: as others have mentioned in the thread, before sales taxes were extended to internet purchases you were supposed to report internet purchases as use taxes, which approximately nobody did).
- BXlnt2EachOther 3y agothe fun part: "Then under the same deal, Cupertino actually returns approximately one third of this revenue to Apple."