4 ms·
> No one should ever sign a CLA that gives a company more rights to your contributions than you get from theirs. Why not? I've signed CLAs to contribute to ope
by bogwog 3y ago
> No one should ever sign a CLA that gives a company more rights to your contributions than you get from theirs.
Why not? I've signed CLAs to contribute to open source projects that I use every day. These projects already offer me tremendous value for free, and while my contributions may help other people, they mostly help me since they tend to be fixes for problems that I personally have with them. Having the fix contributed to the project also usually means that it becomes someone else's problem to maintain it in the long run, so it's not even a burden for me.
So I already get way more than I give in that kind of situation. Knowing that they can potentially profit off of my contributions gives me some peace of mind. If they can build a sustainable business from it, then they'll be able to survive and I'll be able to keep benefiting from it. It's a win-win!
Of course, I guess it's possible (maybe) that they'll be able to do a bait and switch and force me to start paying. I've never had that happen to me, and I might change my mind if it does.
- ensignavenger 3y agoThere have been GPL/AGPL projects in the past that used CLAs and gone propeietary... I don't have the details at the moment, but I prefer to the ounce of prevention, rather than waiting for it to happen to me.
- ryukafalz 3y agoThere have also been Apache v2-licensed projects that have not used CLAs and gone proprietary. The risk of a proprietary fork by Element is not changing as a result of this, and actually the risk of a proprietary fork by anyone else (that includes post-relicense changes) goes away. I too would prefer AGPLv3 with no CLA, but that doesn't seem like it's going to happen at the moment, and this seems like a step in the right direction.
- ensignavenger 3y agoIf I (and everyone else) have the same power to make a proprietary fork as they do, then I don't mind so much. It is when they have more power than everyone else that I start to mind.