6 ms·
The US is quietly arming Taiwan to the teeth
- lakomen 3y ago[flagged]
- jvanderbot 3y agoAs a US citizen I am happy to pay taxes to allow small democratic nations to defend themselves from large bully neighbors. All the better when the large bully neighbors would happily do away with USA if they could. If small nations bolstering self defense and making treaties is viewed as threatening to much larger neighbors, then I'm very curious about what those large nations had planned for the smaller ones.
- rodonn 3y agoI don't understand how you think that building up defensive capabilities is provoking war. Making the cost of invading higher makes it less likely the PRC will try to invade. The US's long standing goal has been to preserve peace in the Taiwan strait by making the cost of attempting to invade sufficiently high to deter PRC from making the attempt at invading https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/3531094/us-strengthening-deterrence-in-taiwan-strait/ https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/35...
- corethree 3y agoRussia did the same thing to Cuba. Just like one or two missiles. Did you see how the US reacted to that? Honestly what do you think the Chinese are thinking? We whine at even one missile in Cuba while China and every other country has to accept the fact that the US has military weapons and outposts around the world. Seriously this is a hugely provocative move. Also as a Taiwanese person I agree with the US about how the lives of Taiwanese people are more important then those in Gaza (sarcasm). Weaponize Taiwan but let Israel slaughter its enemies. In reality the US could give a shit about either people. This is a story about patriotism and power. China is becoming an economic and technological peer to the US and in order to stop it the US needs to stop china from controlling the Pacific and tsmc. This is what's going on. Not some preservation of peace, that's garbage. The attitude of the American public largely echoes your point of view. Basically at the back of your mind you know it's a power play coming out of jealousy and fear, but we lie to ourselves and pretend it's some sort of move to defend the innocent people of Taiwan. Well as I stated earlier that's a lie we Americans tell ourselves. I have a realistic view of this because my heritage straddles both worlds and I can tell you the US side is the delusional one. To clarify the US is making logical and rational military maneuvers in terms of power projection at the greatest threat but their justification for such maneuvers is delusional. Your post is one example of the delusion. The hypocrisy of what's going on in the middleeast and Ukraine is proof of that. Unless you actually believe that the lives of Taiwanese people are worth more than those in Ukraine and the middleeast. Think about why military intervention is justified for Taiwan and not Ukraine.
- jauntywundrkind 3y ago> Honestly what do you think the Chinese are thinking? We whine at even one missile in Cuba To my knowledge we have not equipped Taiwan with nuclear missiles, which is what the Cuban Missile Crisis was about. Big difference. > while China and every other country has to accept the fact that the US has military weapons and outposts around the world. Seriously this is a hugely provocative move. provocative seems like a questionable choice of words, given that the US military has time and time again been used to resist militarists & authoritarians exploiting populations. We have enormous military capability that we don't use, that is not for making war, but defending the world against warlike powers. > China is becoming an economic and technological peer to the US and in order to stop it the US needs to stop china from controlling the Pacific and tsmc. This is what's going on. Can't it become an economic and technological power without pushing around & pushing out so many neighbors? Here's to Chinas rise, I hope it does great, but it keeps acting so zero sum, keeps creating conflict, and it gives everyone great unease to see such military buildup from a country that keeps acting hard & ardent to those around it. > The attitude of the American public largely echoes your point of view. Basically at the back of your mind you know it's a power play coming out of jealousy and fear, Absolutely on fear. We are scared of an authoritarian country so ready to go to war with it's neighbors, so willing to push people around. We have projected power so far for so long, but so rarely begun conflict, in hopes of preventing destabilization in the world, in hopes of preventing authoritarian overreach. As for the whataboutism of other situations, the US has greatly helped Ukraine & our direct involvement would make it World War scale, so let's not if we can. We have both given Israel Patriot and Iron Dome missile-defense systems, while trying to get neighbors & Israel moving towards peaceful resolution. We are trying. Although you lambast us in these situations, we seem to be doing all we can in both situations to re-stabilize the world & in spite of your sharp words it's unclear what we could be doing better.
- corethree 3y ago>To my knowledge we have not equipped Taiwan with nuclear missiles, which is what the Cuban Missile Crisis was about. Big difference. It's big but nowhere near as big as you imply. Think about it from a chinese citizens perspective. How big of a difference is air raids, bombings and missiles vs. nuclear missiles? Would the chinese citizen be calm and nonchalant if it was just non-nuclear weapons and suddenly be thrown into hysteria by nuclear weapons? Let's be real here. It's a physical threat. >provocative seems like a questionable choice of words, given that the US military has time and time again been used to resist militarists & authoritarians exploiting populations. We have enormous military capability that we don't use, that is not for making war, but defending the world against warlike powers. Our military power is used for maintaining our own power. Just look at gaza. Again we aren't doing shit because it's not a threat to american power. Taiwan Is. Hence the difference in response. It's unrealistic to characterize the US as some international white knight. Clearly we aren't. >Can't it become an economic and technological power without pushing around & pushing out so many neighbors? Here's to Chinas rise, I hope it does great, but it keeps acting so zero sum, keeps creating conflict, and it gives everyone great unease to see such military buildup from a country that keeps acting hard & ardent to those around it. Unlikely. The US did a ton of pushing around. A ton. and it largely gets it's way on the international front. China is pushing it's way to become an equal player and that's unacceptable for the US. This is normal. It wouldn't be acceptable for China either if it's the other way around. Both countries are human. I think you're placing the US on a bit of pedestal. You remember how the Bush administration basically lied and made up a bunch of shit about WMDs just to go to war in Iraq right? That whole fiasco basically puts a hole in your "white knight" view point. >Absolutely on fear. We are scared of an authoritarian country so ready to go to war with it's neighbors, so willing to push people around. We have projected power so far for so long, but so rarely begun conflict, in hopes of preventing destabilization in the world, in hopes of preventing authoritarian overreach. Largely disagree with this. The US is not some White Knight projecting power to keep stability. It chooses it's conflicts based on it's own interests. >As for the whataboutism of other situations, the US has greatly helped Ukraine & our direct involvement would make it World War scale, so let's not if we can. Direct involvement in war with China will be world war scale and the US doesn't hesitate in this matter. Russia is the greater threat for war because Russia is just less stable. China is less of a threat for war but the US steps up military power here because China is more of a peer and competitor on the world stage. Let's be real here. >Although you lambast us in these situations, we seem to be doing all we can in both situations to re-stabilize the world We are doing our best to maintain an edge over China. That's what we're doing. That's the entire point of why there's so much military projection in Asia and none towards say Gaza. Does Gaza have a threat for world war? No.. so your theory doesn't apply here.
- corethree 3y agoYes. Literally the US is the one building a military wall around China and we say China is the aggressor? China is largely reacting to this in ways that can be considered mature and will prevent war. I don't like a lot of what china does but in this specific situation the country is making the right choice. Imagine if China did the same thing and tried to build a blockade around the US. Something minor like maybe putting some missiles in Cuba... how would the US react? Oh wait. Honestly the real thing going on here is the economic and technological rise of china to surpass or become a peer to the US. It's a story about patriotism, power and refusal to to become 2nd place.
- ericmcer 3y agoHaving independent countries around your country isn’t a blockade… as far as I can tell things are flowing pretty freely in and out of china
- corethree 3y agoPutting a missile in Cuba isn't a blockade either.. things can still move freely out of the US. What's the problem here? Why all the hysteria?
- fnordpiglet 3y agoThere’s a difference between a missile and a nuclear missile. I would note that advanced nuclear submarines somewhat make the issue moot. You keep saying a single missile in your comments. I’m not sure if you’re mistaken or being hyperbolic. But the Soviet’s actually deployed 24 R-12 medium range missiles and 16 R-14 intermediate range missiles as well as a large number of long range bombers. At this time the soviets had several hundred nuclear warheads, so deploying 40 to Cuba was something like 10% of their entire nuclear arsenal. The entire point of such a move at the time was first strike capability, which is entirely offensive in nature. This is not comparable to establishing defensive capability in nations surrounding a geopolitical rival who has been expansionist and nationalistic. The Soviet move established their desire to destroy us without provocation (after all first strike requires surprise), while establishing defensive positions is meant to stabilize a status quo.
- ericmcer 3y agoYeah just let China takeover the small nations around it. Why do we keep bullying China and Russia.
- anon291 3y ago> single reason for all wars since at least the year 2000. You are conflating reason with participant. The main reason for wars since 2000 is middle east terror groups. Regardless of your thoughts on Afghanistan or Iraq, it is clear that the US would not have invaded anyone were it not for the fact that it suffered a pretty major attack on its own soil. I would suggest those that don't want war stop attacking other countries. But at the end of the day, when you are the only military power in the world (the US military is in a class of its own) and the only one responsible for the current state of world peace (the world is more peaceful than it's ever been), you're going to be involved in the battles that crop up here and there. Luckily, we can assure the outcomes.
- enterprise_cog 3y agoThe US was the main reason for those “terrorists” existing. We are the ones who funded and armed the mujahideen in the 80s.
- anon291 3y agoYes. We funded the mujahideen while their countries were being invaded by the USSR. Would your solution be to let Russia colonize other countries at their leisure? Once again, taking money to defend your country and then, when you're done, coming to wreak havoc in the US is going to lead to war... duh Next time be grateful that Uncle Sam helped you keep your God-forsaken land
- enterprise_cog 3y agoYes, it would actually. I’d take socialism over religious extremism. I mean, look at how they responded, as you said. But I don’t blame them, it makes perfect sense why they did that. I blame the US officials who thought it was a good idea to back up those mujahideen. The US officials who sabotaged peace talks to keep the war going. The anti communist ideologues who damaged this country in ways we are still seeing play out today. And let’s not skirt the fact that the US was in it to secure natural resource rights. We weren’t saving their country as much as saving our access to it. The mujahideen knew this as well, so not sure why they’d be grateful.
- msteffen 3y ago…what did the US have to do with Russia’s invasion of Ukraine? (To another comment: the resolution of the Cuban missile crisis was that Kennedy negotiated a compromise with the Soviet Union…not a war)
- interactivecode 3y ago[flagged]
- hollerith 3y agoIt's not only the US. The people of Taiwan are annoyingly reluctant to give their island nation to Beijing.
- amenhotep 3y agoPeople with this worldview don't see the people of countries like Taiwan or Ukraine as having any agency. They're either subservient to China or Russia or the USA - there are no other options, so any alignment against one country can only be interpreted as interference by another. They also frequently describe themselves as against imperialism, weirdly.
- hollerith 3y agoThe only realistic way for Taiwan to retain any independence from Beijing is to ask the US government for military assistance. Do you disagree? ("Realistic": a coalition of Japan, South Korea, Australia and Great Britain would have the means to help Taiwan effectively, but it is very unlikely they would have the will.)
- zb1plus 3y agoI am fully in favor of the US reducing its military. Sadly, fascists, racist and religious fundamentalists won't stop violating the rights of other people, fueling the American military industrial complex.
- wkat4242 3y agoAs a European I lament some of the oil wars America has dragged us into. The second gulf war, Afghanistan.. They were a bunch of BS and accomplished nothing (Afghanistan is worse off now). On the other hand, defending Taiwan and Ukraine and Kuwait (the first gulf war, while motivated by oil interests there was a clear humanitarian principle too) are pretty honourable IMO. I would definitely not want to see China or Russia as the major world power. The US is not perfect but it's not the worst either.
- Workaccount2 3y agoUnfortunately for China, they successfully pissed off every single neighbor in the pacific, making it exponentially harder for them to attack Taiwan since all those neighbors went to the US for protection. The US basically has a barrier of military bases along the entire Chinese coast. The US also besties with Singapore, sharing a navel base there, where it could easily cut off China from middle eastern oil via The Straight of Malacca. China should just take the L on Taiwan. In a war they wouldn't get any of the chip fabs or tech. Everything would be destroyed. It would be purely to fulfill their ego at an extreme cost.
- art_vandalay 3y agoChina is better off pursue peace and forgoing their Communist zealots
- FFP999 3y agoChina may nominally be a Communist country, but in practice, they've been more an authoritarian capitalist state for a generation or two now.
- art_vandalay 3y agoGood
- LispSporks22 3y agoLately I have been thinking military aid from the US is not very effective, or underwhelming by several orders of magnitude.
- anon291 3y agoPerhaps you should raise your country's taxes and fund your own defense
- cedws 3y agoSomething that didn't occur to me until reading this is that the Russia-Ukraine war is giving Western allies an opportunity to test weapons and strategies on a real battlefield. That must surely be anxiety inducing for China that has no such opportunity. I'm surprised Russia and China are allies, considering Russia kicked the hornet's nest and will make annexation of Taiwan harder.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoIt’s also depleting western stocks and distracting forces, as is Gaza. If Iran, China, and North Korea were to simultaneously iron out their grievances, the west could not stop them.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThe west could not stop all of them. They probably could stop whoever moved first. As Iran, China, and North Korea are not really allies, nobody wants to be the one who goes first. (And if the one who went first wasn't China, they would probably be not only stopped but stomped.)
- audunw 3y agoThe artillery being sent to Ukraine isn’t very relevant for Taiwan. And much of what is sent to Ukraine is old stock that was about to expire anyway. If anything, this has given western countries an excuse to ramp up production of new modern stocks that wouldn’t otherwise have been accepted by its citizens. Not sure how Iran and Koreas is relevant. If Iran latched out at its neighbours and that region is plunged into chaos, it’ll hurt China more than USA. China is desperately dependent on oil from that region. USA is a net exporter. There’s not much we could do for South Korea regardless. Seoul will be flattened by artillery before we have time to react. And in the medium term I think what’s left of South Korea could wipe out the North on their own. Not good for China either. Would open a land bridge from a US ally to Chinas mainland. The drone boats Ukraine is developing is a disaster for Chinas invasion plans as well I think. Chinas plan depends on overwhelming Taiwan with thousands of ships, many of which will not have advanced anti ship weapons. If Taiwan can take out most of them with cheap drone boats or even small drone submarines, Chinas plans aren’t viable. I’m sure Taiwan is studying Ukraines solutions closely.
- arp242 3y agoAlternative headline: "US is helping Taiwan protect from an unprovoked and unwarranted invasion by an unhinged dictatorial regime" Of course it would be naïve to think there aren't also some more self-serving geo-political interests at play here, but this is really what it comes down to.
- greatgib 3y agoThis situation is really sad. In my opinion, Taiwan is one of the last really nice and democratic place on earth. The population is incredibly wonderful with foreign tourists, compared to the Chinese population that is either hostile or trying to abuse or defraud of occasional travelers. All this stress and money wasted on military stuff just because of megalomaniac old fart dictators in China. Nothing to advance the world and nothing to be won from going on with such a conflict.
- simonblack 3y agoUkraine II. No matter how much stuff the US ships to Taiwan, the Chinese have much more. The only result is that Taiwan's chip manufacturing will be destroyed and that will be more destructive to the West than to China. Anyway, China won't go to war with the Republic of China unless the Republic of China declares its independence. Just like the US went to war with the Confederacy in the 1860s when they declared independence.