5 ms·
Dating apps lose their luster with college students
- anon23432343 3y agoWhatttt? You mean swiping the one side because of one picture is not how I find the love of my live? And all the fake accounts? fake bots? Scamming accounts? Premium? Super Premium services are not worth it? ohhh nooo
- dchung333 3y agoThis doesn't really feel that surprising when the vast majority of Tinder's users can be better described as predatory in nature rather than building up real emotional connections Tinder and all online dating apps have essentially become the adult friend finder which was never popular to begin with.
- siva7 3y ago>> 79% of respondents — college and graduate students around the country — said they don't use any dating apps even as infrequently as once a month. That number doesn't check with what i'm observing on college students. It's more the other way around. I also got the feeling that for more than a decade every month some article claims the end of the tinder/bumble/etc age.
- pavel_lishin 3y ago> Methodology: This study was conducted Oct. 11-16 from a representative sample of 978 students nationwide from 2-year and 4-year schools. The margin of error is +/- 3.4 percentage points. The Generation Lab conducts polling using a demographically representative sample frame of college students at community colleges, technical colleges, trade schools and public and private four-year institutions. Maybe there was some bias they didn't account for; a thousand students isn't that many.
- chomp 3y agoA thousand is enough for a representative sample.
- ericpauley 3y agoCould be the people that spend time answering random surveys online and the people that use dating apps are different.
- nvm0n2 3y agoIt's not even clear how they were recruited. Generation Lab says only that it was via proprietary methods i.e. they won't tell you. Why not? Is there anything so sensitive how they got in touch with students? Normally, polling firms are more open. It suggests they don't want you to know where their lists came from (could be as bad as MTurk).
- bluGill 3y agoIt is enough, but only if you collect a good sample. I'm not sure what a good sample is. In college I'd expect a big difference between undergrads and grad students (as students get older they are more likely to settle down with someone and marry, so even seniors vs freshmen should show a difference)
- itointegral 3y agoThis is absolutely false in lots of scenarios, one of them being when you're dealing with a heterogenous population, which seems to be the case here.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rjmunro 3y agoIndeed. Also a larger sample doesn't help with "some bias they didn't account for", it just marginally narrows the margin of error.
- code_runner 3y agoIt’s interesting to track college kids for dating app viability. They are surrounded by their peers constantly. They would be far less likely (hypothetically) to struggle to meet people in real life.
- larrymyers 3y agoI'm not even sure why college students would need dating apps. You are in a relatively dense environment surrounded by people your own age, in a similar phase of life. You have to actively work not to meet people you want to date.
- siva7 3y ago>> You have to actively work not to meet people you want to date. Societal norms have changed. Why risk rejection in person?
- Lacerda69 3y agoWhy not? In what way have norms (in the USA I assume) changed that rejection in person should be a big risk?
- doubled112 3y agoAnecdotal, but all of the men I know on dating apps were the ones that would get up and go ask any woman out before. The ones afraid of rejection are still afraid of rejection.
- slothtrop 3y agoProbably, because they aren't mutually exclusive. Apps let you see women you don't otherwise run into through a social medium, bigger pool bigger chances.
- TheOtherHobbes 3y agoExcept that many of those women aren't real, and the ones who are are getting hundreds of messages a day. The opposite is true on campuses. There are now far more women than men at college. Outside of IT/engineering, the ratio is around 3:2 and very favourable to men.
- motohagiography 3y agoGood, dating apps were scams and people are getting wise to them. Don't buy lottery tickets, don't gamble, don't use slot machines, and don't waste precious time on dating apps. Those apps had the same effect on relationships for whole generations as gambling addictions as well. When you hear someone say, "sounds like you had a bad experience there friend, maybe you should try again and do something different," admit that yes, you got taken at a casino, and the different thing to do is to not spend your time in casinos.
- luzojeda 3y ago>When you hear someone say, "sounds like you had a bad experience there friend, maybe you should try again and do something different," admit that yes, you got taken at a casino, and the different thing to do is to not spend your time in casinos. And also those that say "I've met my wonderful wife/husband in Tinder, maybe you should keep trying" and most of those cases (in my personal experience) date back to 2016 and before. When there weren't so many people just trying to get followers, bots, scammers, etc. etc. Besides survivorship bias, of course.
- Lacerda69 3y agoJust commented exactly that above -.- But yea I stopped using them in 2016, so they got that much worse since then I guess?
- plagiarist 3y agoI think so. Apps never worked for me finding a long term partner but they used to be kinda okay at least. Maybe something about reducing the profile to just swiping yes or no based on a photo has made it awful? And inviting men to pay to be the topmost left swipe in a series of a woman's hundreds of low-compatibility "matches."
- Lacerda69 3y agoI personally had great experience with dating apps. Met two of my long-term partners on an app. Not sure if I would still use them now, but back then it wasn't bad. Of course social media and the internet has enshittified a lot over the last 10 years, so my experience could be different now.
- xrd 3y agoI remember going to University of Washington. When I got into the freshman dorms, I met my roommate and his older brother excitedly talking about how the library there was considered the 2nd best pickup place in the country. I still don't know what that meant and I certainly didn't contribute to the statistics. My how times have changed.
- BoxFour 3y agoThe study's omission of controls for a social desirability bias might skew its findings, or at least I didn't see anything mentioning one. Considering lingering stigma about using dating apps, despite the large change in acceptance, it wouldn't be surprising if people under-reported heavily. This is evident even in this discussion where college students are partially stigmatized for resorting to dating apps amidst a sea of peers.
- throw932490 3y agoIdea for a dating app at college! Problem at college is consent for intercourse. How do you record consent, so it does not get revoked a few days latter? Too many students were dragged through mud, and had their lives destroyed!
- nologic01 3y agoAn immutable blockchain record would seem to be appropriate? I will let you come up with a suitable name for such a chain (and the corresponding coin).
- Shish2k 3y agoWe could also solve cheating by representing romantic interest as an NFT which can be traded from one partner to the nest, with hotels and restaurants only accepting two-person bookings from couples who are confirmed as owning each other’s tokens! #TechnicalSolutionsToSocialProblems
- constantly 3y agoThis is not a technical problem.
- willsmith72 3y agoDenmark tried https://www.heatherflowe.com/post/iconsent-app-consent https://www.heatherflowe.com/post/iconsent-app-consent
- vincnetas 3y agoSo if you consent and later change your mind and say stop, other person has right to continue? Someone has not thought this through :)
- minerva23 3y agoOr, you know, have sex sober with trustworthy people and don't rape anyone. It's not a high bar.
- nikanj 3y agoTalking to my younger friends, two salient points rise to the surface: 1) For men, the app is absolutely flooded with sex workers and bots. 2) For women, the app is filled with the small subset of men who haven't been repulsed by the sex workers and bots - namely the desperate and the chronically lonely Not sure if anyone knows the reality, as the dating apps for sure aren't sharing data on relevant metrics.
- Ajay-p 3y agoI use a dating app and I get a lot of people who want to sell me something, or invest in their business enterprise. It is very depressing. Supposedly if I pay and subscribe to the dating app it would be better, but I do not yet have enough faith to pay $25/wk (Tinder) to find out.. The apps have not seem to have done anything to stop scammers.
- xirdstl 3y agoIf you pay to subscribe, that does nothing to help with scammers, I promise you.
- Ajay-p 3y agoWhat could be done to stop scammers? One thing I believe would help is for the app to accurate reflect the person's geographical location, and if that person's geographical location changes wildly, to flag them and tell the viewer. "This person's geographical location cannot be assured." If more was done to verify and police location, it might lead to at least encountering less scammers. What do you think?
- HenryBemis 3y agoYes and no. There were years that I would travel constantly for work. All around Europe, and later in US, India and a bit of China. I never use dating apps (and have exited the social media many years ago), so tracking my location would have me banned in two weeks. It will have to be very strict, to e.g. move to 3 cities in 1 day, where the cities are over 200km apart or something. Kinda like trying to catch the Pokemon-Go Android modded apps 'walking' cheaters.
- xirdstl 3y agoGreat question. Something like you suggest could help. I definitely think it's possible to do better, because some of the apps have a lot fewer fake profiles/scammers compared to say, Tinder. I think there isn't enough incentive for some of them (again, Tinder) to bother. If enough people stop using them, maybe they will incentivized to do better.
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]
- ternaus 3y agoLove the idea of dating apps, but have a lot of questions to the execution. As other people mentioned in the thread I did not really need them while in University, but after graduation, being in SF Bay Area in tech, meeting women became challenging. In this geography (SF Bay Area) and subculture (tech) the number of women, especially good looking, who are single is objectively small. You rarely meet them in real life. Dating apps solve this issue - open an app, match, chat, meet. But in other geographies and subcultures, meeting in person would be more efficient and enjoyable. But even if students stay away form it, dating apps industry waits for disruption. And I hope, this time executive teams in Tinder, Bumble, etc will not ignore this signal and invest into creating a better experience for all sides.
- minerva23 3y agoWomen have similar issues finding quality men. Men who aren't looking for a live-in maid/sex-worker/nanny/cook. Men who are responsible, and yes, ideally good looking too. Men don't raise boys to see women as equals, so the pool of quality men can be rather small.
- snarkyturtle 3y agoI would posit that _most_ apps are losing luster. People are wary about Silicon Valley's business models and promises to make their lives better. Take Airbnb: it was supposed to be cheapter/more convenient but now people are using traditional services like hotel because of how expensive/inconvenient VC-backed platforms are. Same thing with dating apps, it just doesn't deliver on its promises and makes things more inconvenient than going to a house party.
- Webster09 3y ago[dead]
- Webster09 3y ago[dead]