4 ms·
Google is paying 21B because they expect to lose more than that if they stop. Which suggests they don’t think people would choose them.
by Retric 3y ago
Google is paying 21B because they expect to lose more than that if they stop.
Which suggests they don’t think people would choose them.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoExactly and they know this. The biggest market is mobile now, and people on mobile don't open their web browser on their phone and start typing google.com before they search for something like people used to do on desktops 20 years ago, but they search for something directly in the built-in browser's address bar whichever search engine that might be, as most people stick to the default on their device whichever those might be. Defaults matter. Apple could probably switch the default search engine in Safari to anything else and most users wouldn't bother changing it back to Google unless the results were to be absolutely terrible.
- neuronerdgirl 3y agoHow well does that hypothesis fit the maps experience?
- RandomDistort 3y agoThe maps experience was terrible, if the search isn't terrible, it will survive.
- utopcell 3y agoOr, the most likely scenario, especially in the Apple case: Google is made to pay these obscene amounts and has no alternatives other than abandoning a part of the market.
- asah 3y agowhat? um no: they are paying 21B because * Apple * has a monopoly on their platform and would divert users to another search engine who paid $1 more.
- prepend 3y agoYou’re not using the word monopoly correctly. Apple doesn’t have a monopoly on their platform. They make a platform that’s part of a market. And they have a minority portion of that market. That’s like saying Folgers has a monopoly on Folgers coffee. The sentiment is kind of right, they are the only ones who make Folgers, but it’s not the right term as being an exclusive manufacturer is not a monopoly in terms of anti trust or this conversation.
- spot5010 3y agoI don’t know why you are getting downvoted. You’re right. Not justifying apples tactics though.
- bogwog 3y agoI'm not an expert on this in any way, but I've been following this Google case and have learned a few things. In antitrust lawsuits, a critical part is to define the "relevant market" over which a company is being accused of doing illegal anti-competitive things. This isn't straightforward or easy to define, but I do think it's very easy to make a strong argument that Apple has enough market power over some markets to justify enforcement action against them. > Apple doesn’t have a monopoly on their platform. They make a platform that’s part of a market. And they have a minority portion of that market. I don't think "a minority portion" means anything, since illegal activities are still illegal. I.e. collusion doesn't become legal just because you're a small company. And again, I think it'd be pretty easy to identify more than a few markets where Apple very clearly has an overwhelming market share.
- fallingknife 3y agoCan you name any of those markets? I can't think of any.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoEven by your broader definition it's a duopoly, with one whose taking 90+% of the profits in the smart phone market of the US.
- cherrycherry98 3y agoI my guess is that what's really happening is that Apple is being paid off not to compete in search. As Google has shown, search can be incredibly lucrative. The profit motive would be pushing Apple to this end. They have a large base of loyal users that Apple Search could be be pushed out to as the default. Google pays Apple enough not to take the risk in trying. If Apple Search was a hit it would be a threat to Google. There's always the possibility that it would be the next Bing or Apple Maps, an inferior money pit, so Apple is happy to take the cash.
- bogwog 3y agoI can't think of a more in your face example of anti-competitive business practices harming innovation.
- janmo 3y agoVery correct, although Apple controls only a minority of the Smartphone and Desktop market, they have most of the high income individuals, which advertisers love. If Apple loses that sweet 21B USD, they will come up with their own search engine for sure.
- kmlx 3y ago> Google is paying 21B because they expect to lose more than that if they stop. google is paying that much because otherwise microsoft would be paying close to that. there is no innovation in the search space, there is only a battle of cash.
- carlosjobim 3y agoMost people would choose Google, but they are too incompetent or too indifferent to select the search engine on their device. If you study normal people using a computer or smart phone, they will panic and instantly click "OK" or "Continue" on any alert or dialog that shows on their device.