4 ms·
The gas industry sponsored Julia Child's TV kitchen
- CalRobert 3y agoI just moved from my home with an induction to a home with a gas hob (a nice one, even!) and I really, really miss my induction. Temperature control is a lot harder, I can't dial in the values I know work for a given dish, and I notice that some of my pans are just... dirtier than they were before. Also it's emitting poison in to my air.
- datavirtue 3y agoJust accept the profit gas emitted by your overlords.
- iamthemonster 3y agoThe first time I used an induction stove I set it to maximum, because I set my gas to maximum. I waited a while for the pan to warm, then I poured in some cold water for boiling. I was amazed at how much heat induction could put out. It instantly boiled the water touching the surface of the pan and it was at a rolling boil shortly after. If there weren't such health and safety risks, it would be great to let customers just have a go with an induction cooktop in a showroom. Along with most people, I'd thought of induction as a substitute for gas, when really it's an upgrade.
- fomine3 3y agoGood gas has temperature control feature (at here in Japan), though IH is better for such use case
- CogitoCogito 3y agoIt’s funny because my experience is the opposite. I have used many induction stoves whose temperature junps are too big. E.g. my brother’s stove basically can’t make Swedish style pancakes because one setting is too cold and the next is too hot. This is obviously not something inherent about induction stoves, but weirdly something I’ve seen there quite a few times. That said, does anyone know if induction stoves could work with a continuous knob? Like with some variable resister maybe? If that’s possible has anyone seen such a stove for sale?
- GaryNumanVevo 3y agoWe recently built out our dream kitchen, we've got a full gas hob with an industrial amount of ventilation. We also have an induction hotplate which is great for keeping sauces warm or boiling water faster, although I've noticed that induction doesn't have the fine grain control that I've come to expect from gas.
- encoderer 3y agoThe PR push by the climate activists against gas stoves is remarkable to watch.
- al_borland 3y agoEverything I see seems very one-sided. I listened to a podcast about gas stoves and the marketing behind them. It mentioned in passing that before the gas stoves people were using wood burning stoves, but never mentioned that a gas stove is a significant improvement over a wood stove. Not only does it burn cleaner, but it also allows someone to control the temperature much easier. It was a better stove in every way. They also seemed to gloss over the shortcomings of the standard electric stovetop everyone knows and hates. Gas is easier to cook with than a normal electric (coil) stove. They also just assume everyone is just going to know to move to induction (without really bringing it up), but it also has it's shortcomings... price, not all pans work, and if you're unlucky, some buzzing while you cook. Awareness is another big issue with induction. My sister has a gas stove and can't cook on electric without cursing the whole time. I mentioned induction and she had no idea what I was talking about. When these hit pieces on gas come out, if they fail to educate on induction, they aren't going to win over die hard gas users, as they have all used old electrics stoves by now and know that they didn't like it. When I was last looking to buy a home, the realtor even pointed out a gas stove as a selling feature for a home, which it is for many people. There is no perfect stove, and gas was an improvement and the clean option when it came out... yet all these stories paint it as purely a marketing move with 0 redeeming qualities. I can't take these people seriously when they aren't honest about the situation. All that said, I have a traditional electric stove right now and hate it, to the point of not using it. I plan to replace it with induction and will hope for the best. I don't have a big investment in cookware currently, but already know I'll have to throw out/donate at least 1 or 2 pans (one is my favorite one and I'm not excited about losing it). I always find it interesting when the climate activists pick causes that people are really passionate about, as it serves to put up walls to action, rather than getting people on board.
- tomatocracy 3y agoIt's also remarkable that none of these pieces (and this is no exception) ever seem to talk about proper air extraction. You would have thought that would be the first thing anyone researching this topic seriously and objectively would look at. The relative damage done by pollutants emitted by cooking oil and food on a stove (regardless of type) is also rather larger and better documented (though still not huge in the grand scale of things), which gives another reason to talk about extraction.
- PopAlongKid 3y agoI wonder why all these health issues weren't more widely observed back in the day when every gas stove and gas-powered water/room heater had a continuously burning pilot light. Shouldn't the additional combustion 24 hours/day have magnified the effect to the point where no one could ignore it? I grew up in a house with an electric coil stove, not because of worries about exhaust but more about leaks in the gas supply line. The house actually had a powerful vent fan built right into the exterior wall above the stove location. The house also had a coal-burning gravity furnace, and directly across the street was a railroad with diesel engines for both freight and commuters passing by many times a day. And one of my parents was a cigarette smoker, which I was exposed to every morning. And yet somehow I don't have asthma. But now when I cook I do run the vent fan to outside that is in the microwave mounted over my stove.
- javagram 3y agoOlder houses “breathe” aka leak air like sieves. Air pollution from a small source like a pilot light is quickly diluted by air exchange with the outdoors.
- ender341341 3y agoalso for many areas the rest of the pollution you were exposed to made it relatively trivial in the scheme of things, like it may have contributed but all that smog outside had a much more drastic effect. As we clean up other sources more minor ones will stick out. I definitely miss my gas for lots of stuff but on the other hand besides having a cast iron grating instead of glass like surface pretty much every benefit of it is matched by induction, except on cheaper models it can be hard to see what's hot or not (capacitance touch on kitchen appliances is beyond stupid)
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoGas with proper ventilation is fine. The problem is most American kitchens have garbage to no real ventilation.
- ender341341 3y agoWhen I was house hunting I saw a house built in the mid-90's that the range vent vented into the kitchen. They did a lot of deep frying and every surface besides the counter was coated in grease. Like I can understand it not being required on existing houses from years earlier but how was a house built in the 90's with that... Also seen ones that vented to the attic with pretty gross results in the attic too.
- adamomada 3y agoEdit, oops mixed up LPG and natural gas, which is methane, ignore
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoGas stoves release all kinds of nasties, from N02 to unburnt gas [1]. You don’t need an anaerobic environment for combustion to be incomplete. And natural gas is a mixture of gases; it doesn’t burn into just C02 and water vapour. [1] https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/have-a-gas-stove-how-to-reduce-pollution-that-may-harm-health-202209072811 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/have-a-gas-stove-how-to-...
- adamomada 3y agoYeah made a quick edit when I realized that NG is methane But here’s something from your link that completely reframes the problem: > The Stanford study tested gas stoves in 53 homes. All of the stoves leaked methane gas, even when turned off. Wtf? Are these health effects mainly from (unburnt) gas poisoning and have little to do with actual burner usage/combustion?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago