4 ms·
ECPA primarily covers networks and attacks on networks, and incidentally protects certain forms of communication, including stored information. In general, ECP
by rdl 15y ago
ECPA primarily covers networks and attacks on networks, and incidentally protects certain forms of communication, including stored information. In general, ECPA seems to restrict government activity. I don't think it goes far enough (it protects certain types of communication more than others, and the way they were picked seems to be a historical accident.)
CISPA, as I read it, both protects networks AND "information rights holders". Given the history with DMCA, COPA, (+ SOPA, PIPA), etc., it doesn't seem at all unreasonable to think the government (and those information rights holders) will use CISPA to use the tools provided for national security to address copyright violation.
This is the same government using PATRIOT to go after local drug dealers.
I could support CISPA if it focused solely on information sharing from government to private enterprise (and protection from liability) for network or infrastructure attacks.
Most of the legitimate network-defense activities which would be permitted under CISPA are already allowed under existing laws. There might be a few corner cases around classified intelligence and uncleared entities, but this legislation is overly broad.
- tptacek 15y agoWhat action currently unlawful under the ECPA would be made lawful in a plain reading of CISPA?
- rdl 15y agoI'm not sure. (You probably know/care more about this than I do; I assume everything can be done under NSL already, or entirely internal to large companies or their existing business partners, or by criminal organizations, so the legal protections are largely irrelevant.) I assume by ECPA you mean "ECPA as modified by the Patriot Act", which is a substantial change in protections. Under ECPA as originally enacted, a great many things currently done would be illegal. However, there's at least one major area which is currently illegal but would become lawful under CISPA: Providing classified intelligence to private companies in violation of the NSA of 1947 (which I don't think is permitted by ECPA; ECPA just allows info to go from private company to government in ways which would otherwise be wiretap act violations without specific court orders). Couple this with the government enjoying overclassifying everything, and it's a problem. I don't really have a problem with this, except that the procedures and safeguards need to be built well to protect that information. I think they can do this. The other addition is that intellectual property is covered. If "theft of [...] private information, intellectual property ..." provides "exemption from all liability [...] acting in good faith", this would seem to allow private entities to do a lot of things. I don't think ECPA/Patriot gives those powers to private entities, so a provider could have one (badly written) legal contract with customers (violation of which might lead to civil liability), then invoke CISPA to violate it. Most contracts are written to permit information sharing for security issues, but adding copyright protection would greatly expand their scope. I think it would allow a copyright holder to request (with no legal basis) information from an ISP, including ECPA protected information like VOIP/email in transit/etc., and or the ISP to turn it over with no legal protections to the requestor. So, overall: The Lungren (http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/112/hr3674 http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/112/hr3674) HR 3674 does not have this feature/defect. I'd support Lungren as written.
- tptacek 15y agoThis act doesn't allow private companies to provide classified intelligence to other private companies, or the government to provide classified intelligence to anyone (the government can obviously just declassify). To keep things simple though: what's lawful under this act that was unlawful under pre-PATRIOT ECPA? I'm most familiar with the pre-PATRIOT ECPA anyways.
- rdl 15y agoI agree, basically nothing, in a non-paranoid reading. You could stretch interpretation of the law in crazy ways (which has been done), but it's not reasonable to predict that. The most clear example I can think of is protection from civil liability for a provider turning over information (stored messages or on-wire communications) to another third-party where the user hasn't already consented to terms of service which allow that. I don't think any ToS are written to not allow that kind of thing, for this very reason. I'm still against the law, but it's in one house now; it could change for the better or worse. If they struck some of the language related to intellectual property/copyright to make it more clear, I'd actually support it.