6 ms·
> Not so long ago the belief that rocks can fall from the sky was regarded as irrational and magical. When was this and which people, specifically, did so? Ev
by defrost 3y ago
> Not so long ago the belief that rocks can fall from the sky was regarded as irrational and magical.
When was this and which people, specifically, did so?
Everywhere you travel, it seems, there are old stories about sky iron - Tibetian Thokcha and other names elsewhere.
But who were the people who regarded such stories as irrational and magical. How widespread was that belief?
- anm89 3y agoYou are just encouraging fake news. Please don't ask people to substantiate anecdotes. It's better to just accept the narrative if it fits the consensus. This obsession with "proof" and "data" is anti scientific.
- nitwit005 3y agoAppears in the bible, so I suspect you'd have gotten in trouble for mocking the idea too loudly: > And it came to pass, as they fled from before Israel, and were in the going down to Bethhoron, that the LORD cast down great stones from heaven upon them unto Azekah, and they died: they were more which died with hailstones than they whom the children of Israel slew with the sword. Joshua 10:11
- defrost 3y agoIt's hard to not believe in meteorites when your environment is desert or snowfields .. micro meteorites are a steady infall and people with sharp eye notice small black rocks appearing on previously clean sand and snow. ( If your routinely clean your gutters and pick through the silt with a strong magnet you'll likely find micro meteorites sooner or later )
- Daub 3y agoOn the way to my gutter right now, magnet in hand..
- defrost 3y agoWe started a little thing here in Western Australia that's spread across the world .. no, not a novel Australian STD, but: https://dfn.gfo.rocks/ https://dfn.gfo.rocks/ https://gfo.rocks/ https://gfo.rocks/ The Global Fireball Observatory is an multi-institutional collaboration, with partner networks around the world. Our observatories take pictures of fireballs so we can recover any meteorites that might have landed on the ground.
- achates 3y agoThomas Jefferson for one. > "Gentlemen, I would rather believe that two Yankee professors would lie than believe that stones fall from heaven." http://www.meteorlab.com/METEORLAB2001dev/metics.htm#:~:text=Thomas%20Jefferson%2C%20President%20of%20the,that%20stones%20fall%20from%20heaven http://www.meteorlab.com/METEORLAB2001dev/metics.htm#:~:text...."
- defrost 3y agoAhhh, cheers for that. (EDIT: immediately followed by (in link provided): Whether Jefferson's quote is truth or myth, his belief real or an opportunity for a witty Virginian to take a shot at a two Yankees, is not known which undermines somewhat the claim that Jefferson held such a belief.) Leaves the question of whether that was a widespread belief. TBH it's the first I'd heard that anyone had ever not believed in rocks falling from the sky .. I'm 60 ish, have worked for decades in geophysics and read the original Scottish geologists, etc.
- Daub 3y agoSome good material here: http://www.meteorite.fr/en/basics/meteoritics.htm http://www.meteorite.fr/en/basics/meteoritics.htm From which: > Until the early 19th century, most scientists shared Isaac Newton's view that no small objects could exist in the interplanetary space - an assumption leaving no room for stones falling from the sky. And... >... From this, he [Ernst Florens Chladni] was forced to conclude that meteorites were actually responsible for the phenomena known as fireballs, and, more importantly, that they must have their origins in outer space. His view received immediate resistance and mockery by the scientific community.