3 ms·
so basically, threatening anyone who tries to leave with extortion. interesting. wonder how quickly it'll result in a lawsuit.
by cyanydeez 3y ago
so basically, threatening anyone who tries to leave with extortion.
interesting. wonder how quickly it'll result in a lawsuit.
- jgalt212 3y agoYou get what you paid for. oh, wait ...
- bko 3y agoIsn't this another form of cyber squatting? Highly coveted names encourage people to snap them up and hoard them with the hopes of reselling later. And they're almost certain sophisticated organized projects. Maybe not at the onset of social media, but now for sure. I've also heard that if you have a coveted name you're constantly fighting hacking attempts.
- neaden 3y agoI think there is a difference between a name that is covered because it's cool or noteworthy vs. a name that's coveted because it implies the identity of the person. If a business or celebrity is leaving Twitter they still probably would not want someone to have their old Twitter name because it could lead to deception.
- kodapoda 3y agoHighly doubt there is any basis for a lawsuit. It's a private company, if they want to take away someone's handle, they are free to do that. Pay-to-play public square—Musk's ultimate dream.
- Retric 3y agoThe problem is peoples handles aren’t arbitrary placeholders. Musk may want to resell NPR’s old accounts to some sock puppet, but that runs into criminal impersonation etc.
- kodapoda 3y agoSure, not arbitrary placeholders, but they are not owned by users in any legal sense. At least not until the Supreme Court decides otherwise.
- Retric 3y agoI don’t know why you think it’s a question for the Supreme Court. If you want to send tweets as @Microsoft after they leave the platform, you’re going to run into Trademark law among other issues.
- kodapoda 3y agoI just assume that this would only be resolved at the Supreme Court level. Any local court decision would be challenged by Twitter. Re: @Microsoft. I am not convinced that’s the case. If I build a public website with user handles it doesn’t automatically give all trademark owners the right to the matching handle.
- greenyoda 3y ago> I just assume that this would only be resolved at the Supreme Court level. Any local court decision would be challenged by Twitter. That's not how the Supreme Court works. The Supreme Court only agrees to consider a small number of cases every year, which are usually cases that could have a significant impact on constitutional law. If the Supreme Court refuses to hear a case, the decision of the lower court (federal appeals court) would stand.
- kodapoda 3y agoThat maybe true - I don't know much about the legal system. However, my guess is that the implications of being able to lock down vs seize and sell user handles in private companies are more far reaching than some of the recent cases the Supreme Court did agree to consider, e.g. whether "Trump too small" can be trademarked.
- x0x0 3y agoTwitter implemented the blue check originally due to impersonation issues. You can read the history on wikipedia, but Tony La Russa sued Twitter over it and the blue checks where the outcome. I'm not an attorney, but it seems not black and white.
- kodapoda 3y agoThis is conflating two separate concerns: a private company can do whatever it wants with its own user handles. Sell them, seize them, delete them. Impersonation, on the other hand, can be challenged in the court of law. Twitter will certainly prioritize the sale of short handles, single word handles, common name handles, and not something like @apple (just because of the volume of squatted and unused handles that can be easily monetized). If they seize and sell @apple, and the new account will impersonate the company Apple - that's a totally different legal situation. If the sold account will just post pics of apples, I don't think the crime of impersonation would be relevant.
- CapsAdmin 3y agoIt may be how the law is at the moment, but a lawsuit could change that. Isn't that how a lot of laws are made in the first place? (not a lawyer)
- plasticchris 3y agoNo, Congress makes laws. Sometimes legal opinions are referred to as case law, they are not making new laws.