4 ms·
AI fake nudes are booming. It's ruining real teens' lives
- babelthuap 3y ago[dead]
- mapt 3y ago[flagged]
- vivekd 3y agoYeah no. Making a nude of someone without their permission seems like a pretty serious violation of a persons sense of self and identity. It seems worse to release it the public.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoNo, taking a nude photo of someone without their permission is a pretty serious violation. Drawing a picture, regardless of the technology used, is harmless in and of itself. Imagine some middle school kids. One of them scribbles a drawing and writes the name of a girl in their class above their stick figure drawing and a giant penis in their face, with the name of some boy above it. It gets passed around at school and people pick on her. Are we going to fault the drawing for this? Or are we going to fault parents, the school, culture, kids being assholes? Imagine some Mothers Against Tomfoolery group agitating for this to be punishable by felony convictions, most reasonable people would be wildly against it. Now, because we have computers instead of pencils all of a sudden this panty wringing has momentum? It is a moral panic, just like every one that came before, and it is dangerous just like every one that came before.
- vivekd 3y agoDifference is in this case the image is indistinguishable from a photo. Google teen suicide nudes and then come back and tell me it's just a moral panic You assume it's a moral panic because some people don't behave in ways you deem rational and don' share your views on sex. Guess what, we're not Vulcans. We're humans with feelings and violations like this can have serious consequences for the people it's done to
- friend_and_foe 3y agoSo we pander to feelings? It's a dichotomy? Either we are vulcans or we pander to feelings. That sounds unreasonable. First, teens take nudes of themselves to send to each other because they're horny. When those nudes get leaked, it's betrayal by someone they trust, it's actually a picture of them that they took, and it is harassment. Now, killing yourself in response to it, that in my mind is an indicator of an unhealthy environment at school. But that's still a real violation of their trust, it's real harassment, it is understandable that they'd feel extreme stress as a result. We are talking about drawings, not some mirror selfie some girl sent to her boyfriend that he showed his friends. The two scenarios are not the same thing. People behaving in ways that aren't rational is a core part of a moral panic. I don't care if people share my views on sex. Moral panics to make homosexuality illegal had different views of sexuality also. Just because someone has a different view than me doesn't give them the right to pass laws that affect everybody. We ideally determine what should be illegal based on what's reasonable, not based on how people feel. It is unreasonable to throw people in jail for technologically modern doodles.
- defrost 3y agoI'm not sure why you're asking questions about this, it's SOP in schools where I live for the kid that draw the picture to get sent out of class to the principals office and they'll end up picking up litter for a few hours. No felony convictions .. and a half decent chance some of the kids he passed it to that passed it on giggling get the same deal, yard duty.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoThat sounds reasonable. I expect a school I send my children to to teach them proper conduct and discipline them for bad behavior. What I don't expect them to do is refer them to the state attorney for prosecution when they haven't physically harmed anyone or destroyed any property.
- windowshopping 3y agoI'm not sure why this got downvoted into oblivion. Even if you don't agree, it's not some outrageous drag on the discourse to suggest that "maybe this is inevitable, and we have to get used to it." After all, we've gotten used to a million things as a society that Puritans said would ruin us and destroy the fabric of our lives, our families, our relationships, etc etc. I'm sure it's pretty shitty to have nudes of you passed around at school, but the fact remains that this tech isn't going away, and it does seem rather likely that being able to create nudes/pornos of anyone trivially will eventually diminish the impact of them to the point of near insignificance. If you know you can just type in "getnudes.io" or something and upload a couple pictures and get a full-blown porno of someone in seconds, then there's going to be pornos of everyone that anyone is interested in. To misquote The Incredibles, if everyone is nude, nobody is.
- happytoexplain 3y agoThe first sentence of the parent is a highly sarcastic/exaggerated snipe.
- ryandrake 3y agoIt's an emotionally charged topic, so the up and downvotes are going to be flying around everywhere. Yours is probably the most practical response. The technology isn't going away, and in all likelihood it is going to get more and more refined and better, faster than we think. It's conceivable that in 5-10 years, there will exist software that anyone can run on a commodity PC or phone, that produces high-definition media of any target person doing or saying anything that the software user can dream up. The technology isn't just going to disappear. So it's up to society to figure out how it is going to deal with that reality. Asking me what I would think if someone produced an AI nude porno of me or one of my family is irrelevant. If someone for wanted to make it, it would get made regardless of what anybody thought about it. So how do we respond?
- fortran77 3y agoHere’s a thought experiment. Suppose the pictures weren’t shared or distributed. People would just take a photo in the privacy of their own homes, run it through a piece of software, and see a realistic nude image of what that person might look like. Would that still be immoral? Would you want this to be illegal? Would it be a problem that needed to be solved?
- vivekd 3y agoI think if you ask any person in a society where porn is not prevelant they would absolutely think it's a problem. Unfortunately we live in a society that tells us it's okay to sexualize others in this way. Let's change the thought experiment, what if it wasn't some nameless girl, what if it was your mom, your sister or daughter - anyone who tells me they're completely comfortable with that is either weird or lying
- justanotherjoe 3y agoi wouldnt even take my mother on a nice date. Comparing other women to your mother is weird.
- vivekd 3y ago[dead]
- friend_and_foe 3y ago[dead]
- Engineering-MD 3y agoYour argument style closes it to any counterpoint. Anyone in your head with a different opinion is weird or lying. Perhaps others have a different rationale to you?
- vivekd 3y agoThe argument that having nude photos of you mother or daughter spread spread is about a rational response is weird because for most people the response would be emotional. The arguments being made here rest on discounting human emotions, requiring that they be justified rationally. That's not a fair or reasonable standard. What would you call a guy who feels nothing about having his mother or daughters nude photos spread. You're telling me you take issue with characterizing that as weird and unusual?
- apwell23 3y agodebt collectors in india will have a field day with this ( if they aren't already)
- tennisflyi 3y agoIdeally/eventually nudes will be worthless.
- happytoexplain 3y ago"Worthless" is possible, but "not embarrassing" is probably as far-future as a post-scarcity society.
- Canada 3y agoI don't understand the logic of this. Belle speaks as if it is actually a nude photo of herself. Doesn't she understand that it's not?
- mjevans 3y agoThe slander / reputation damage alone is the issue. It's an attack on their sense of self and community.
- Teever 3y agoIt sucks, but it's the lesser of two evils scenario. A world where nudes of you are floating around and you can't make the claim that they're AI fakes is far worse than one where nudes of you are floating around and you can make that claim. Even the slimmest of plausible deniability is enough to save face in a lot of situations.
- webninja 3y agoPerhaps the solution is to not let nudes cause damage. As an example, look at how Amazon founder Jeff Bezos treated the situation when a nude was lifted off of his phone by a middle eastern hacker. His response was: “So what?”. We’re in the Age of AI so it’s okay to not be prude Victorian-aged puritans over naked bodies.
- mjevans 3y agoWere it that easy... The community is not that understanding. Groups of people go mean surprisingly easily. This is also one of the reasons victims of other crimes are further damaged beyond just the initial crime. They become classified / treated as a victim rather than empowered and supported in positive ways.
- 8note 3y agoJeff b is up towards the richest person on earth. He's not a comparable rxample
- Canada 3y ago
- laristine 3y agohttps://archive.ph/xImHl https://archive.ph/xImHl
- Racing0461 3y agoI think its gonna have the opposite effect long term. Look at how the kim k sex tape turned out. Now when a celeb has theirs leaked, its literally non news. Long term ai nudes will result in the same thing for the avg person.
- OhioMan2943 3y agoYeah but do we want to live in a hypersexualised society?
- friend_and_foe 3y agoNot really, but people are sexual. We created this social structure where sexual endeavors are done inside, privately, and in that context they do whatever they want, provided all participants are of age and willing. In public we are permitted to pursue and attract each other but no more. I think that's a perfectly reasonable state of affairs.
- poisonborz 3y agoWhat that means changes fast. We live in a hypersexualised society compared to even 50 years ago.
- Racing0461 3y agoWe live in a hypersexualised society compared to 10 years ago.
- imgabe 3y agoI think we need to ask ourselves why a nude image of someone should ruin their life. That is something we as a society inflict on ourselves. We could just not care if there's nude images of someone, then we wouldn't have to worry about it and there would be no incentive for bad actors to create them in the first place.
- vivekd 3y agoThat's ridiculous. You're telling me if I took naked pictures of you and posted them in front of all your friends and family you would feel nothing. For a site that screams and cries about privacy of IP addresses and privacy of what sites you visit - apparently posting naked photos isn't a privacy violation? Human beings feel vulnerable when they are naked, and exposure like that is humiliating. This is not a western society thing, it's a human nature thing
- imgabe 3y agoWhy should you feel humiliated? Would your friends and family mock you if they saw naked photos of you? You might need new friends and family if they would. Mine would be angry on my behalf that someone violated my privacy, but I wouldn’t expect them to act negatively towards me. Plenty of cultures don’t have the shame around nudity that we do. It is not at all universal and feeling humiliated is just that, a feeling. You can choose to feel a different way if you want.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vivekd 3y ago>Plenty of cultures don’t have the shame around nudity that we do. You're mixing two things. The fact that there are nude beaches in Canada for example doesn't mean the women want sexualized nude images or wouldn't feel embarrassed or humiliated by that. There an important contextual difference you are missing. This whole you can choose is rubbish. It can be used to excuse any form of victimization. It's not sufficient to hurt, violate or victimize someone and tell them to choose to have a better perception or attitude about it. How about the people doing it change their attitudes on others privacy right and right to their integrity
- NoPicklez 3y agoIn the short term it will likely have an large impact on some young people's lives. Many of us forget how incredibly embarrassing and bullying school can be on us. Regardless of how fake they might be, it's how others react to them in front of you which is the most damaging part. People use them as material to bully and harrass people. Long term, it becomes "normalised" and they will lose their value quite quickly. If one bully has access to the software, no doubt the victims will too.
- allturtles 3y agoThe reaction of many commenters in stories like this is something along the lines of "the is just going to happen, people should just learn not to be bothered by this." May I ask, does technology exist to serve people or vice versa? I always assumed it was the former. If so, why should we tolerate this technology? Who does it benefit other than bullies and sexual predators?
- dnissley 3y agoCan you specify what you mean by "this" technology?
- defrost 3y agoIMHO the best possible course forward from here is to normalise the hell out of tools that AI photoshop and animate peoples faces with the bodies of animals, in various costumes, weightlifter bodies, etc and crack down on the nude | pornographic potrayals of real people. The upside is getting people used to photorealistic body fake images so that everybody knows that if compromising | embarrassing nudes do show up they're very likely fakes and being put about by people that deserve a bit of scorn. "The technology" is hyper realistic seamless image creation - it has all manner of applications beyond titillating porn for schoolyards, moreover regardless of how we do or do not tolerate it there's no going back in the box. It's time for focusing on judging people as we know them to be and damming tabloids that publish material that's very likely to be faked.
- coffeefirst 3y agoYes, and I have a creeping suspicion none of the people who hold those views are young women. Weird how that works. There's also a straightforward legal path out of this: add it to image and likeness rights. You distribute an unauthorized nude of a specific person the victim can collect $1000 per violation.
- bloopernova 3y agoFor the commenters saying people should just get over it: Imagine a similar fake was made of you. In it, you are shown to be performing sex acts your community and employer find objectionable. Would you want to be told to just get over it? Should women under threat of "honor killings" for perceived expression of sexuality or independence, just get over it? Or imagine you're faked into saying political opinions that are the opposite of what you believe? Opinions your peer group find abhorrent? Or you are faked into saying or doing something illegal? It's not just your reaction that affects the outcome.
- happytoexplain 3y ago> Imagine a similar fake was made of you This is always a non-starter if people have psycho-social or political motivation for their position. Though regardless, it's also a low bar. A healthy society should ideally consist of people who are capable of feeling sympathy for people who have feelings in response to things which the observer does not share.
- imgabe 3y agoOk, imagine a similar fake is made of me. Imagine there is a link to it right below this comment. Are you going to go look at it? Sure, curiosity is a thing. Are you going to come back here and mock me? Are you going to tell me that my life is ruined? That I am worthless now? Are you saying that is an appropriate and reasonable response to seeing a nude picture of someone? Do you think that is what people should do to you if a similar picture of you surfaced online?
- MF-DOOM 3y agoThis is all very unfortunate. However - once the world realizes that deepfakes can be generated virtually for free and for anyone, no one will trust them. We might even be better off with them rather than without as no one could tell if a genuinely leaked photo of yours is real. The same has happened with phone records as evidence in court (in some countries)
- jacknews 3y agoThe images are fake, so this just seems like another form of bullying to me, with possibly an added sex dimension, which is always a red-hot button for anglo-protestant societies. Is this really much different to bullies sending out pictures of the victims marked up with slurs? Or even cartoons depicting them in degrading situations or acts, eg like a cartoon of Mohammed with his pants down maybe, or of politicians and pigs and whatever.
- edanm 3y agoYes, it's really different on at least one dimension - the person in a nude photo has usually given consent to being photographed nude, which implies something about their actions. Whereas sending a picture of someone with slurs on it says nothing about the person themselves. Obviously if we get to a world in which it's common to see nude photos of people that are AI generated, such that the inference is wrong, that might change. But for now at least, sending a fake nude photo of someone can hurt them by making people think wrong things about them. (Whether it should hurt them, etc, are all irrelevant to my point btw - I'm saying there is a difference, not whether it matters or how.)
- jacknews 3y agoBut this is about AI generated nudes, not actual nudes, so there is no consent. I don't think there are many people now, especially young people, who are unaware that AI can generate such content, so the assumption must be that nudes are most likely fake until proven genuine. So much so in fact that even actual nudes could probably be brushed off as AI fakes - I know that's what I'd do.
- bearboy10 3y ago[flagged]
- lunaticlabs 3y agoAs a person who has lived most of their life in the USA, but now lives in Germany, I find the German/EU law about likenesses being a perfectly sane alternative to the US law. If you use my likeness for anything commercial that is not specifically documenting a historical event, you require my permission to use my likeness. You want to make deep fake porn at home with my image? Have at it. You distribute it? Prepare to lose a lot of money. Same for commercial entities, so there just seems to be less of an incentive for this kind of thing (I'm sure deep fake porn happens in Germany too, just not at the same level as in the US). Its the same reason that Google Street View photos are blurred so often in Germany. It seemed a little crazy when I lived in the US, now that I live here, I can't imagine going back to the old ways.