3 ms·
Great subject, poor video. Too much 'wow' and travel photos, not enough explanation of what's going on in those things. I've seen the Jaquet-Droz automata[1] i
by Animats 3y ago
Great subject, poor video. Too much 'wow' and travel photos, not enough explanation of what's going on in those things.
I've seen the Jaquet-Droz automata[1] in Neuchatel on the one day a month they run them. They're demoed by a watchmaker who understands and maintains them.
The three automata are the Musician, the Artist, and the Writer. These were made between 1764 and 1778. The Musician and the Artist are just playing back pre-recorded motions from a set of cams. To increase the length of the recording up, there's a stack of cams, and after one turn, the stack moves vertically to play the next cams. So there are two clockwork trains taking turns - playout, and cam selection. It's a beautiful piece of work, especially when you realize someone made all those cams by hand, with a file.
The Writer, which writes text with a quill, is programmable. There's the stack of cams that move vertically to switch cams, as with the others. But with the Writer, the cam selection is programmable. There's a programming wheel made of little screw-on sections of different heights, and a supply of cam sections which indicate what letter to print next. It's an encoding with at least 26 different levels, probably more. I'm not sure if letter case is encoded on the main cam.
It's all very compact, fitting inside the bodies of the dolls. There's no huge mechanical box hidden away somewhere. Even today it would be tough to make that mechanism work, although there are still watchmaking companies that could do it.
Better video of the Writer.[2] You can see the cam stack and the programming wheel working.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaquet-Droz_automata https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaquet-Droz_automata
[2] https://youtu.be/ux2KW20nqHU https://youtu.be/ux2KW20nqHU
- dirtyv 3y agoThe entire time I felt as if the narrator was aggressively disgusted at me
- jstanley 3y agoI agree that the video doesn't do a very good job of explaining the workings of the automata, but I don't think that makes it a poor video. I don't think he is trying to explain how they work, he's just trying to give an overview of the topic, with particular focus on how they influenced the society around them, and I think he did a good job.
- jsenn 3y agoThere's an episode of BBC In Our Time about Automata: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0bk1c4d https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0bk1c4d
- crystaln 3y agoI believe the shape of the letter is encoded into the cam, thus the ability to draw arbitrary figures such as the dog drawn in the video. This makes it far more flexible that 26 letters with casing.
- Animats 3y agoWatch this video section of the mechanism.[1] That big wheel at the bottom with things sticking out at different heights is the programming wheel. The big stack of cams up above has all the motion control for each letter. Watch the cycle. Big stack of cams rotates a turn and generates some motions. Then the cam stack stops, a sensing feeler touches the wheel to get the setting for the next letter, the cam stack moves vertically to set up for the next letter, and the the cam stack starts rotating. At some point the programming wheel advances one position for the next letter. This logic is derived from the way better striking clocks work. They have a stepped cam called a "snail", which is the program for how many times to strike vs the time of day.[2] It's just a table from 1 to 12. But there's no reason it couldn't be an arbitrary function. It's beautifully made, but not mysterious. [1] https://youtu.be/ux2KW20nqHU?t=164 https://youtu.be/ux2KW20nqHU?t=164 [2] https://youtu.be/rxM7lk21F0E https://youtu.be/rxM7lk21F0E
- kragen 3y agothe crucial thing here is that the code selecting which letter to write next is a digital code, like the alphabet itself, not an analog one, though the letterform is then encoded in analog form on the cams vaucanson (and others) had previously devised a digitally controlled loom, though it didn't come into general use until jacquard's later improvements, and the pascaline and leibniz's stepped reckoner were controlled by digitally encoded numbers, but jaquet-droz's work may be the first machine controlled by a digital character encoding even if it was just a plotter rather than a theorem prover or something
- MH15 3y agoDid this "Writer" inspire the one in the movie "Hugo"?
- blooalien 3y agoAccording to Wikipedia [1] the answer is at least partly "yes, indeed", as that and one other similar automaton are mentioned as inspiration for the design of the automaton in the movie. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugo_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugo_(film)
- userbinator 3y agoEven today it would be tough to make that mechanism work, although there are still watchmaking companies that could do it. I wonder if one of the various YouTubers with a CNC mill might be able to build a replica --- that would be a video (series?) I'd certainly watch. The tolerances involved would be extremely difficult 250 years ago and probably involved much manual trial-and-error, but are likely not out of the ordinary for a modern machine shop.
- iancmceachern 3y agoMechanical and mechatronics design engineer here. The complexity isn't in the manufacturing of the gears. It was extremely difficult back then, easy now. The challenge is in the design. Even with today's advanced CAD software I use and access to CNC machines, etc. It would be quite the project for me to design one of these. A lot of it is that much of the real in depth complicated mechanical engineering isn't super common anymore, much of it has been replaced with electronics and computers. I've made a good niche for myself kind of being the old school mechanical engineer who knows how to design those old school type mechanisms, but with modern CAD and design automation software tools.
- djmips 3y agoHave you thought of making an automata? Perhaps not as complex as this but just as a cool hobby project?
- iancmceachern 3y agoNot really (although thinking now!). My dad's a master jeweler, I've always wanted to make a fancy Orrey with him.
- 6510 3y agoIf imagined as discrete logic components there could be a HDL to model the logic while ignoring the challenges of folding it into a box. The cam is an immutable fixed length array of fixed length arrays. It actually seems like a useful enough thing to have it in a programming language. The arms read a value from one place and write it some place else like a multiplication or division like contraption that turns 1 cm of motion into 2. Having it do one thing after the other (by default) seems challenging but not impossible. What would a for loop look like? I cant begin to imagine how to design such a device but if you provided less complicated building blocks it seems something one could learn pretty fast.