3 ms·
I just finished, “How Big Things Get Done”, I think on a recommendation some time back from someone on HN. He says that among the projects that tend to be on t
by hinkley 3y ago
I just finished, “How Big Things Get Done”, I think on a recommendation some time back from someone on HN.
He says that among the projects that tend to be on time and on budget, roads, solar and wind are three of them. While he doesn’t say it, I read this as “all large successful projects start as small successful projects”. Once you’ve built 10 miles of road the next 10miles is mostly more of the same, subsurface conditions notwithstanding. Once you’ve installed three wind turbines in a field installing the rest looks much the same (getting the first one in required solving a bunch of transportation problems of course). The teams just get a little faster with each one, because they are iterating on a pattern they already know.
You try to build a nuclear power plant and it might not show up until after the politicians who pushed for it to be built have retired. Which means it might not show up at all because all of the skin has left the game. But if I try to cap my career as governor with a new wind or solar farm? I may actually get to cut the ribbon.
It makes me feel a bit better about our prospects that solar and wind are easier logistical problems than repeating the old patterns.
- credit_guy 3y ago> You try to build a nuclear power plant and it might not show up until after the politicians who pushed for it to be built have retired. You can try to reactivate nuclear power plants that were shut down. I state I live in (New York) closed 2 nuclear reactors in 2020 and 2021, each providing more than 1 GW of clean electricity. Both reactor were closed because of political pressure. If we were to apply the reverse political pressure, I think we could have them up and running in 5 years, if not sooner.
- tomatocracy 3y agoYes - this is (part of) the motivation for the current idea of "small modular reactors". The idea with SMRs is that if you build the units in a factory, not on site, then things like unexpected ground conditions necessitating costly design changes can be mitigated. Making them smaller might also reduce things like extremely tight tolerances on certain parts leading to potential delays due to having to "throw it out and start again". It's closer to the model used for nuclear submarines which have a better track record in terms of delivery to time and cost than civilian nuclear power.
- pfdietz 3y agoIt looks to me like NuScale is staggering toward a shutdown. They have just 15 months of money left and the CFPP project with UAMPS looks doomed.
- tuatoru 3y agoExcept that they're not small or modular enough. To get decent learning curve effects they need to be 10 kW to 100 kW each.
- regularfry 3y agoIt's a fairly easy assumption to make that the current flock of SMR proposals are designed to build on naval reactor experience, given the size range.
- pfdietz 3y agoAt that size the diseconomies of scale would swamp any experience curve effects.
- ben_w 3y agoWhat's your reason for those numbers? The power output of a normal car engine seems a bit on the low side to me.
- hinkley 3y agoI just looked up a typical gas turbine plant. The US Energy Information Administration (what is that, PR for the DOE?) thinks that a 'typical' gas turbine plant is 600MW. The DOE says nuclear plants clock in around 1GW, but is that single reactor or a four reactor core system? I feel like most of this is barking up the wrong tree though. If you're trying to get people to use a new power plant type, you may be looking at small cities and large towns. At which point you might be comparing your situation to how much power you can get from the nearest metropolis via high tension power lines, and how much more secure your winter power supply would be if you didn't rely on those lines working. And a cursory search suggests those can vary from 40MW to just under 600. So can you sell Geneseo a 50 MW reactor/solar/wind farm?