4 ms·
Hard reliance on nuclear power is one of the "we all die" options. Didn't we learn our lesson about building a whole civilization on consuming a limited resourc
by immibis 3y ago
Hard reliance on nuclear power is one of the "we all die" options. Didn't we learn our lesson about building a whole civilization on consuming a limited resource dug out of the ground?
- gpm 3y agoSure, at least with regards to fission, but it plausibly extends the timeline out so that the moonshots are no longer quite so difficult.
- kristjank 3y agoIs it not the case that Uranium and Thorium are not just more abundant than existing fuels, but also about a million times more energy dense? I find it hard to believe running out is a chance we'll face soon.
- ben_w 3y agoMillion times more energy dense, yes. More abundant? Depends. There's a lot in the sea, which isn't currently recoverable. There's a lot we could do (but actually don't) with breeder reactors to make more fuel. This means the answer to the question "how long could we last on just nuclear fuel alone?" varies from 5.7 years[0][1] to 4.3 billion years[1]. [0] https://globalwarming-sowhat.com/renewables https://globalwarming-sowhat.com/renewables [1] https://whatisnuclear.com/nuclear-sustainability.html https://whatisnuclear.com/nuclear-sustainability.html
- immibis 3y agoDon't forget about induced demand.
- lucb1e 3y agoNot like the sun is renewable either. Everything is finite if you use enough of it. The problem is that the old "limited consumable resource dug out of the ground" changes our natural habitat as a side effect of creating energy, assuming we continue to use it as we do today. (By that last bit, I mean: powering EVs from coal plants with carbon capture at exhausts might be different, idk, but probably not cheaper than just not polluting in the first place.)
- gpm 3y ago"Renewable" isn't the best word for wind and solar, better would be "use-it-or-lose-it", either you harvest it or it dissipates into useless low grade heat. Using more of it doesn't deplete the supply of it. Solar energy (and thus wind assuming otherwise constant environmental conditions) is only going to get more plentiful for next 5 billion years...
- pfdietz 3y agoThe Earth becomes uninhabitable in about a billion years due to solar brightening, but your point certainly applies to far future civilizations in solar orbit.
- rgmerk 3y agoI think nuclear is a red herring in most of the world (too expensive and SMRs are too far away to matter), but the idea that we’ll run out of fuel for them is a nonsense. We haven’t looked very hard at all for uranium. Nor have we tried very hard to use the uranium we already have efficiently. Nor have we tried very hard to use thorium as an alternative. Some combination of these would stretch out the supply of uranium we have essentially indefinitely.