3 ms·
They want to train their models for free, and then sell access for money like OpenAI. Counterpoint: Someone who teaches himself how to do something entirely vi
by userbinator 3y ago
They want to train their models for free, and then sell access for money like OpenAI.
Counterpoint: Someone who teaches himself how to do something entirely via freely borrowed books from the library, and then makes a living out of those learned skills, is normally not considered stealing.
- stevewallis 3y agoBut… how do you think the book got into the library? The state buys the book from the author’s publisher. The author gets paid their royalty. This happens with your tax dollars. This is a good thing, the library system allows authors to receive payment to provide a public good, that can educate citizens who can then make a living. Stealing their work to train an LLM to make a living is not the same thing.
- PeterisP 3y agoOkay, then let's have libraries train LLMs on the whole collection of the books that they have legitimately obtained. I'd assume that for this particular collection of Chinese printed works, the National Library of China would also own a copy of every one of them, so the end result would be literally be the same.
- sensanaty 3y agoAnd a computer isn't a human luckily, so this argument doesn't work here.