I'm not sure if it's a matter of good faith or not to see that you were responding to statements that not only the person you're responding to didn't say, but w

I'm not sure if it's a matter of good faith or not to see that you were responding to statements that not only the person you're responding to didn't say, but weren't actually said by the original person (trivia != trivial). That said, I assumed you actually care about what you are communicating, so provided what I thought was constructive criticism. I guess you're either in a frame of mind you can accept it as it was meant or you aren't.