7 ms·
Boo. The paper is cautiously written, addresses a very tractable and well-defined problem, confirms what experts expected, and is straightforward to implement (
by anigbrowl 3y ago
Boo. The paper is cautiously written, addresses a very tractable and well-defined problem, confirms what experts expected, and is straightforward to implement (the source code is on Github). And yet this posturing is the #1 comment on this thread right now.
- notfed 3y agoGreat, then let's name it "Othello claimed to be solved", then pound it with peer reviews and reproductions for a bit, then we can phrase it as "Othello is solved".
- SomaticPirate 3y agoThe source code is on Github? Why not run it yourself and perform the peer review? The implementation is quite straightforward
- uxp8u61q 3y agoYou need to prove that the code is correct, that's the tricky part. Otherwise I could just write `return true;` as the whole code and tell people to run it, it's easy, just do the peer review yourself.