5 ms·
Parents are teaming up to delay their children's first cell phone
- fguerraz 3y agoI get "Access Denied" when trying to access this page. I guess they are taking me for one of their children.
- gumballindie 3y agoThis should be law. Kids below 16 should only be allowed “dumb” phones. The internet has become the new tv and with ai becoming more prevalent it will be even worse.
- TomJansen 3y agoI don't think denying children of phones is a good idea. First, we shield and deny them things enough as it is already (which only makes them less prepared for the real world later in life, a thing we can observe already). Secondly, I think that we should make policies that make (social) media on the internet less addictive, and implement stuff like good internet behavior into our parenting.
- gumballindie 3y ago> Secondly, I think that we should make policies that make (social) media on the internet less addictive, and implement stuff like good internet behavior into our parenting. I agree, and i think we should regulate fake news, manipulation, propaganda, etc. But it’s rather difficult as there is the risk of censorship and there is too much corruption allowing corporations to do as they please. Therefore the only two options are either complete blackout - as we do with other sensitive topics - and good parenting. But how do you achieve good parenting since kids are raised by the state? Parents barely spend any time with their children, at least in most of the west, and there’s little control over what they do. In the uk massive numbers of kids are hooked onto people like andrew tate and other toxic popular figures. Those children will grow aggressive and sexist. Corruption allows tik tok to reign unhinged and teachers are helpless and in some cases clueless. Therefore the only option is to make it law that smart phones are banned for children. The risk is simply too high for individuals and the society at large.
- fh973 3y agoI think word the "phone" is obstructing the problem a bit. It's a lot of things, but being a "smart" "phone" is usually not in the top 10 of uses. You can somewhat make it what you want it to be by restricting apps, but you can't restrict the content of the apps to have safe or non addictive content (is there such a thing as dynamic non-addictive content at all?).
- davedx 3y agoNo thanks, nanny state. I’ll give my kids their first phone when I determine they are ready, and will manage it according to my own parenting principles. Doesn’t the state already have enough power over us, and over our kids?
- averageRoyalty 3y agoI agree in principle. But you lose some of the decision autonomy when every other person they interact with has one and those peoples communication is all digital. Critical mass is the biggest issue/driver here, and you as an individual don't have the power to impact that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoExactly. And I don't understand parents who give their kids unrestricted access to the internet (inc. on desktop machines) then expect the government to regulate what the kids see. Take some responsibility like these parents.
- dazc 3y agoThe irony being parents giving kids unrestricted internet access also not allowing those kids to wander out of their sight.
- drewcoo 3y agoParents need to "team up" to control their own children? Now we have two problems.
- aninteger 3y agoIt's more about reducing the peer pressure that kids feel when their friends have phones. While it's great for a child to have it in an emergency, these days phones are more likely to be used as a constant stream of TikTok, Reels, or YouTube shorts by children.
- igetspam 3y agoA cell phone is the best tracking device I've found for knowing where my kid is. They won't leave it behind and if it's outside of where I expect it to be, I get an alarm. I'd love a better option but I really haven't found something that's more reliably close to them at all times.
- pwdisswordfishc 3y agoGotta teach your kid about surveillance capitalism.
- mosselman 3y agoThe better option is to not track them and to trust them and teach them about risks and autonomy and then allow them to make small mistakes now, so they won’t make big mistakes later when they don’t listen to you anymore.
- RALaBarge 3y agoAnother cloistered bad take on the internet. You are legally responsible for your child until they are 18. There is a universe of difference between not trusting your children vs taking reasonable steps to ensure their safety by knowing their location when necessary.
- doublerabbit 3y agoSometimes somethings don't have a one direct answer.
- TrickardRixx 3y agoThis somehow wasn't an issue when my parents were raised. It's just me that has to bear having been raised by a controlling narcissist.
- skeeter2020 3y agoHow did "legally responsible for your child until they are 18" turn into "track them 24/7"? I would strongly argue permanent surveillance exceeds "reasonable steps", but I know I'm in the minority.
- cj 3y agoIf kids were addicted to solving math problems and watching educational videos on their phone at age 12, would we still disapprove? I think framing the problem as "smartphones are bad" isn't as easy or effective as "certain categories of apps are bad". One practical way to implement / enforce something like this could be similar to the movie rating system in the US: G, PG, PG-13, R, etc. "R" rated movies ban kids < 6 completely, but allow kids 7 and older to see the movie if accompanied by an adult. Similarly, companies could sell versions of their smartphone that have parental controls enforced by default, with all app categories disabled by default, so that parents have to explicitly opt-in to the features and apps they allow kids to use.
- pelagicAustral 3y agoHow are parents supposed to exert control over their users when they can't control themselves? I don't use social media (other than HN, if you will), but I have dozens of friends with kids that are unable to detach from their phones, even for a 60 minute dinner. Their kids are dozed on YouTube videos, not for the parents to have a break from work life, but instead so they themselves can doze on social media. What a clown world. I don't have kinds, if I do have some in the future, they will not be allowed to be nowhere near a phone before they can put up an argument for it.
- lepus 3y ago>If kids were addicted to solving math problems and watching educational videos on their phone at age 12, would we still disapprove? We should disapprove. Saying an addiction is fine because it's educational is like saying being addicted to working out is okay.
- mmh0000 3y agoI'll admit. I'm very addicted to eating. I've tried to stop a few times, but the withdrawals get so bad I end up in the hospital with doctors telling me I have to keep this addiction for the rest of my life because after using food for so long, the withdrawals would kill me at this point.
- herpdyderp 3y agoIt seems to me that the real culprit here is social media, not cell phones themselves. So why not focus on on-device restrictions instead? Is that not good enough?
- hombre_fatal 3y agoOnce you block social media and chat apps like WhatsApp, I suppose there isn't much reason for a <16yo to have the device on them at all times.
- kossTKR 3y agoThe most frightening thing about these new consumption patterns is that you miss large but subtle aspects of life, the depth, magic and fantasy that bubbles up as weird emergence in the quiet moments before you sleep, when you wake up, exploring alone etc. I'm hooked as an adult and can already see that i've become addicted to superficiality but the battle is getting increasingly harder as tech hooks deeper and deeper into our neurology. There was a wave of books 10 years ago, "The end of absence" one them, exploring the themes of being the last generation to have experienced both before and the after 24/7 media consumption. In one way it's echoing historical cycles like Thoreau talking about noisy trains in the distance distracting his poetry from his wood cabin in 1854 - but in other ways the distraction has become so exponential i seriously fear a generation will have problems with concentration, imagination or autonomy of thought. Will they learn the beauty of solitude, that you often need some amount of boredom or tranquility for fantasy to arise, and that as in meditation the exploration of internal states can be key to a good and interesting life. I'm reminded of a video game i once played about the native american ritual called Vision Quest where one isolates himself in a dark cabin - and as a lack of inputs creates vivid imagination like in a floatation tank - one finds his purpose eventually. Not much different than religious sabbath or sitting meditation. To get something beautiful you have to remove noise.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoJust turn it off. You will get a short period of withdrawal then you'll get the world as it is. I did, and while I miss some stuff, I'm better off. Don't blame "I'm hooked". It's down to you.
- kossTKR 3y agoThe problem is that i can do this but not kids. I've become better at it and is always reminded of the quiet summers when i was a child, the beautiful boredom and fantasy of "some part of my life that happened a long time ago", or running around without a cellphone, just being completely present and "away" from others in good and healthy sense like a rite de passage. When i see nieces in family everyone under the age of 20 is always inside of cyberspace, never present in the here and now, and while being hypersocial is normal for a teen, it's to an extreme degree for everyone including the smallest ones.
- danielvaughn 3y agoI agree with some of the comments that it's not necessarily phones themselves, but I disagree that the culprit is simply social media. Any app on their phone is going to be geared towards keeping them locked into the experience, because that's how apps are built. Full stop, I don't want anything manipulating my child's attention. Because as I'm getting older, I'm realizing that the most powerful tool you have as a human being is your ability to focus on a task and see it through to completion. Digital media of any kind has a perverse effect on that ability. Parents of the 50's were too simplistic with their mistrust of televisions, but they had the right intuition. Digital screens are avatars for daydreams, and to dream too often is to drain your life of its most precious resource - time.
- ethanbond 3y agoStrong endorse! Something that really stuck with me from David Foster Wallace’s The Pale King, and has been repeatedly borne out in my experience: “To be, in a word, unborable.... It is the key to modern life. If you are immune to boredom, there is literally nothing you cannot accomplish.” Our devices are a 24/7 anti-unborable medication. They’re other things too, which is what makes them especially challenging to get rid of.
- irishloop 3y agoI don't agree with the notion that time spent dreaming is wasted. There is more to life than being productive and focused. There's no prize at the end of life. There is a balance, of course. We can't just laze around all day for both psychological and survival reasons. In the end, though, time spent enjoying yourself is rarely a waste.
- ethanbond 3y agoGP said “too often.” Time spent enjoying yourself is frequently a waste — not because enjoyment is bad or immoral, but because there are so many easily attainable and shallow pleasures available today. Many of the richest pleasures in life sit on the other side of intense bouts of boredom or tedium or even pain.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI'm 40 and have three kids including teenagers. I grew up on the unrestricted internet before cell phones. I've lost all hope here for one reason: Your kids friends parents don't care because they are all addicted to their phones and ignoring their kids It's not even like "choose better friends." Unless your kids are literally in friend groups where all of the parents choose to restrict phones and change their entire lifestyle compared to their peers you're in a losing battle with the broader culture. The only thing I feel I can do is create such a trusting relationship with my kids that they will come to me with anything that we have discussed is problematic. So far so good and we've been able to catch things that would have been a bigger deal without such a trusting relationship It's always been hard to be a good parent.
- dangus 3y agoParents will always lose this type of battle because devices like tablets, phones, and TVs give parents a legitimate break. For every parent who is going “no screens until age XYZ” there’s ten others who just need to get something done around the house and have their children leave them alone or stop breaking shit for 10 minutes. Your strategy is the right one. The parent should be the trusted confidante.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI'd quibble with whether the break is "legitimate" but I wholeheartedly agree here It is unconscionable the pervasiveness to which parents literally stick a device in front of their kids for their own benefit. I get it, life is hard and kids are a lot of work. Your work or friends or instagram or whatever, is infinitely less important than building a healthy engaged relationship with your children. You're harming them and they are losing out on the vanishingly small amount of time you have to give them the focus, attention and attachment that is REQUIRED to create a healthy person and these are things only a parent (or adoptive parent) can give.
- kuchenbecker 3y agoIt's just like anything else you need to teach moderation. My daughter gets to choose what she does on her tablet, and it has educational games. She gets to choose when she watches. I decide how much total screen time, < 1hr per day total, and 50% of the time she will choose to watch something with me after dinner on the big TV rather than use it during snack time.
- eli 3y agoAge that kids acquire mobile phones not linked to well-being, says Stanford Medicine study https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2022/11/children-mobile-phone-age.html https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2022/11/children-mobi... —- Are mobile phone ownership and age of acquisition associated with child adjustment? A 5-year prospective study among low-income Latinx children “Findings suggest an absence of meaningful links from mobile phone ownership and acquisition age to child adjustment.” https://srcd.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cdev.13851 https://srcd.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cdev.13851
- kelsey9876543 3y agoPoor kids of these helicopter parents will be crippled in life when they don't have basic skills like operating a keypad to text or using a phone to check assigbments, getting into the habit of healthy use, instead they will be struggling compared to their peers who grew up with the technology. If you hate cell phones, you are probably better served being amish
- ethanbond 3y agoUX design is so good today that literal 3 year olds pick up basic usage in like hours. Will they develop the skills to really master complex technologies for big fancy jobs? No, but then neither is the kid playing Candy Crush for 8 hours a day.
- ghusto 3y agoWhat on Earth are you talking about? These things didn't exist when I was a kid, but me and others from my generation helped _build_ the damn system as I grew up!
- tarboreus 3y agoYeah, no. Anyone of reasonable intelligence can learn to use a smartphone in less than a day, and the ins and outs in a week. The kids I teach programming to who grew up with smartphones are hilariously technologically inept, not even knowing what files and folders are in the median case. The main thing the phone teaches is to mindlessly swipe or to stand there watching a video.
- cgearhart 3y agoI’ve been leading the charge with peer parents that the new starter phone is a cell enabled smart watch rather than a smart phone. They can text; they can call; they can share location. Best of all: no social media. My youngest kid had classmates with phones in second grade… ugh. Unrelated story time: at my daughter’s 9th birthday party, one of her friends at the party literally tugged my shirt sleeve and asked if I could find her another activity to do because the party was boring. I explained that this was the activity for now and we’d be changing soon. Apparently this child has never been told no in their life because they whipped out a cell phone and called their mom, said the party was boring, and asked to be picked up. Their mom came and they left. I was pretty shocked.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoI'd be shocked at the child's behaviour, the parent's infinitely more so. Jesus.