4 ms·
You're explaining why they cost more to design, not why they cost more to manufacture. The kind of redundancy you need for this doesn't require an excessive amo
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
You're explaining why they cost more to design, not why they cost more to manufacture. The kind of redundancy you need for this doesn't require an excessive amount of raw materials. The cost of a diesel generator that can run coolant pumps, or five of them, isn't a meaningful percentage of the construction cost. A large proportion of the plant isn't any more safety critical than it is in any other kind of turbine-based generating plant, because it's doing the same thing in the same way.
It's also working against one of the most effective design criteria for ensuring safety: Simplicity. Things with fewer moving parts fail less. But they also cost less. It shouldn't cost more. Something's being done wrong.
And if your argument is that nuclear plants are required to have higher safety standards than anything else does even for doing the exact same thing with the exact same risk as it is in some other kind of facility, yes, that's the point -- that's why it's a regulatory problem. Uneven application of standards. Either one of them is too loose or one of them is too tight, but they shouldn't be different.
- lamontcg 3y agoThey're different because one of them has a risk of a meltdown with hundreds of billions of dollars of damage. That's the asymmetry and why a nuclear plant costs more than a refinery.