5 ms·
>YouTube’s efforts to stop ad blockers could result in more complex blocking tactics. These more complex tactics could lead to the creation of unintentional sec
by charcircuit 3y ago
>YouTube’s efforts to stop ad blockers could result in more complex blocking tactics. These more complex tactics could lead to the creation of unintentional security holes.
Just say that you want to leach from the website and not pay for it. Trying to tell YouTube to not bypass ad blockers because it would make YouTube less secure is pure coping.
- lazycouchpotato 3y agoI have my adblock on for targeted ads. I believe the lengths that these companies go through to profile you to serve you ads are terribly invasive. Even if you pay for YT Premium, the tracking does not stop: https://mastodon.social/@nixCraft/111257004092595145 https://mastodon.social/@nixCraft/111257004092595145 My adblocker is off for DuckDuckGo. DDG does not track my activity across websites. I'm one of the few suckers here paying for YT Premium. This is what I got rewarded with for being a paying customer: https://mastodon.social/@lazycouchpotato/111347456188566575 https://mastodon.social/@lazycouchpotato/111347456188566575 Precious screen real estate ruined with Shorts. They've set themselves into this monopoly position leaving you nowhere else to go, and are dead set on making the experience as terrible as possible to extract every little bit of "engagement" out of you. I don't sympathize with Google for users wanting to use an ad blocker on YT. I'd gladly support YT if any other half-decent company owned it.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI have absolutely no shame in leaching off a company with a 1.62 trillion market cap.
- arcticbull 3y agoHow do you balance that ethically against the content creators who have decidedly smaller market caps? I’m not judging by the way I’m just curious your thought process.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI donate to them directly. Zelle, Venmo, Patreon, whatever can get them fiat.
- xkqd 3y agoI can only speak for myself, but there's a strong chance most content consumers don't weight heavily towards a content creator's livelihood. While I recognize that it's significant work to be a content creator, I also don't necessarily hold it as high as any other 9-5 job. As a result, my ethnical scale weighs heavily against the ad-sponsored profit machines - 1T MegaCo, or YouTube channels pushing products. For the creators who I do extract definitive value from (how-tos, DIY, teachers, etc), I'll donate directly or subscribe to a Patreon for a bit of time.
- jfdbcv 3y agoI don't think Patreon is an effective solution. People only have a limited Patreon budget and I'm sure it skews towards large YouTubers and is pretty winner take all. There's a three way ecosystem: the content creator, Google and the consumer. Money can only enter the system through either ads or premium subscriptions.
- lolinder 3y agoOther parties involved: * Patreon (already mentioned, money definitely enters the system through here) * Sponsors (VPNs, CuriosityStream, Brilliant, etc.) * Nebula (a premium subscription for a non-Google service) * Merch companies * Book sales Google would love for you to think it's a three-way system and they're the one and only middle-man who can help you to fund creators you like, but it's completely and totally false. Pushing their monopolistic line as if it were the truth does nothing to help the creators, it only helps Google.
- jfdbcv 3y agoPatreon = video consumer pays Sponsers = another word for advertisers Nebula = consumer pays again (similar to yt premium) The only exceptions are merch and book sales, which only a small amount of big YouTubers have access to. Wouldn't it be nice if you could pay a monthly subscription, and any video you viewed gave the creators a small fraction?
- niceice 3y agoWhy not? And what's the threshold where you would feel shame?
- xkqd 3y agoSpeaking candidly, somewhere between 50M revenue and 250B. The higher the revenue, the higher standard I hold them to.
- jjulius 3y ago>Just say that you want to leach from the website and not pay for it. I'm tired of hearing this. I use ad blockers, but I still had to sit through the "Wait 5 seconds to click through this ad" stuff. Then, it went up to like 30 seconds after you clicked through some ads. After a few more of those, it would escalate to not being able to click through the ad at all - you had to watch it in full before whatever you wanted to see. After a few further views, you then had to watch two ads before proceeding. And you know what? I didn't mind that at all. That's how YT makes money, so whatever. And then last week they told me to fuck off because I used an ad blocker that still let their ads through. So, now I mind. Fuck that. Edit: Between this and WEI, it's hard not to see this as a part of a broader user-hostile plan from Alphabet.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoEven if you were to pay for premium and thus "get rid of ads", there are still ads that show up. YouTube shopping widgets [0] still appear, as do creator posted ads. [0] https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/13376398 https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/13376398
- eklavya 3y agoThat's adjusted in the price, at least in my country (India) it's pretty cheap and I like how the vast majority is able to access all the content for free since it's ad supported. It has made a huge difference in many people's lives.
- skydhash 3y agoSo does Wikipedia. And at one point, I was able to download the whole thing on my computer because I was online only for few hours a day. I'm not seeing Wikipedia asking to disable any adblockers.
- eklavya 3y agoWikipedia is a non profit and runs on donations. Static text vs YouTube scale service are also very very different in costs. That tutorial on internet is free, I can download the whole thing on my computer, why is that 5 years university degree program charging fees?
- bcrosby95 3y agoI'll turn off my adblocker when youtube stops serving me scams.
- soraminazuki 3y agoIt was serving fake history from a random right wing weirdo for my parents. YouTube ads are the worst.
- wernercd 3y agoAd blockers are a security measure: https://www.trendmicro.com/vinfo/pl/security/news/cybercrime-and-digital-threats/forbes-readers-served-malicious-ads-after-asking-them-to-disable-adblocker https://www.trendmicro.com/vinfo/pl/security/news/cybercrime... I have no problem leaching... it's also about a better browsing experience and security.
- charcircuit 3y agoYouTube ads can not serve malicious javascript
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoBut if people are uninstalling their adblockers to use youtube, now the entire web is less secure for them.
- wernercd 3y ago"can not" maybe... but it wouldn't be the first time a "trusted" company served malware. But the issue goes beyond just getting stuff from youtube directly. They are absolutely a source of links to unsafe places - their advertisement platform serves ads that send you to places with unsafe javascript. So even if you was correct about "can not" (which is obviously untrue)... they can and regularly do cause issue none the less. And "but youtube" sidesteps the issue that ad blockers aren't just security from youtube. Youtube is one of millions of websites. Full of shitty websites with horrible security practices and awful practices around annoying advertisements.
- charcircuit 3y ago>So even if you was correct about "can not" (which is obviously untrue)... It is not obviously untrue. Internet ads with malicous JavaScript come from sketchy ad networks. YouTube does not auction its ad space to third party ad networks.
- aaomidi 3y ago
- usea 3y agoI don't want to pay for it. That's good, because it's free. I don't have to watch the ads if I don't want to. I have no such obligation. They give you the videos for free. You don't have to watch ads. I don't know why you think you have to do that. You don't.
- summerlight 3y agoWith that logic, I guess YT reserves the right to refuse service for users like you?
- usea 3y agoI don't understand your meaning, but youtube can refuse service to anyone, not just me.
- eklavya 3y agoNo, you have to pay for it. It's not charity and you are not entitled. You can choose to not watch ads but don't cope by pretending to be moral or ethical about it.
- skydhash 3y agoHow do you pay for something that is free?
- usea 3y ago> No, you have to pay for it. No, I don't. > It's not charity and you are not entitled. You're right. I'm not entitled to it. They give them away for free. I'm taking advantage of that. They've been doing it a long time. I'll keep watching them until they're not offered anymore. At no point have I been obligated to watch their ads. I didn't strike some deal with them where I promised to watch their ads in exchange for videos. I'm simply accepting their free videos. You don't get to invent obligations in other people that they never agreed to.
- eklavya 3y ago
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y ago> Just say that you want to leach from the website and not pay for it. In what universe does anyone have a moral obligation (let alone a legal obligation) to pay them anything? But if we did somehow have a moral obligation to pay them, why would we have that obligation in the particular format of having to sit hostage while they put on their own little timeshare sales pitch for products none of us want? For that matter, is there a philosophical method of severing marketing from freedom of speech, such that we can just ban marketing outright and be done with it?
- ApolloFortyNine 3y agoWhat moral obligation do you have to pay your bill at dinner? It's the same idea, it's a transaction. YouTube and the creators on the platform provide content for free, and you only have to view an ad (or pay). You are essentially choosing to dine and dash, just without the same of doing it in person.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoDon't call this a transaction because it's not. They sent us a video for free. They did so hoping we were going to look at the ads. They took a risk and it didn't work out for them. They only have themselves to blame when their business model doesn't work out.
- pb7 3y ago> Don't call this a transaction because it's not. They put food on our table for free. They did so hoping we were going to pay after eating it. They took a risk and it didn't work out for them. They only have themselves to blame when their business model doesn't work out.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoNonsense. Restaurants give you a menu and the prices of everything they offer you are clearly listed. At no point do they insidiously attempt to extract that value out of you via indirect means. Some restaurants will even charge you up front before making your meal.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoWe're under zero obligation to watch ads, moral or otherwise.