3 ms·
A significant portion of that growth is coming from Donor Aid. In 2019, foreign donor aid represented 14.8% of GDP [0] FDI within Rwanda has actually been decr
by alephnerd 3y ago
A significant portion of that growth is coming from Donor Aid. In 2019, foreign donor aid represented 14.8% of GDP [0]
FDI within Rwanda has actually been decreasing because of a larger pullback of donors out of Rwanda [0][1]
Most high value projects that are being built in Rwanda are being targeted at the energy sector [2]. Specifically in oil refining. The other half of major exports from Rwanda is gold, that is primarily extracted from DRC and exported from Rwanda.
Compared to its peers in East Africa, the Rwandan economy is much less complex than it should be. In all honesty, it's smokes and mirrors exacerbated by a strong PR relationship between the Rwandan govt, donors, and NGOs. You don't hear half as much about Kenya, Tanzania, or Uganda as you do about Rwanda, yet almost everything within Rwanda is basically being managed by donors, and a couple Chinese and Indian conglomerates making a quick buck [3]
> Sometimes free market economics lets countries grow without a government plan
Free Market economics still requires a formal vision or strategy to develop a country. South Korea had a formalized strategy in the 80s and 90s, China in the 90s and 2000s, India in the 2000s and 2010s, etc.
If you go purely free market, then there is no actual incentive.
Take a look at neighboring Kenya. Tanzania, and Uganda. They have actual formal industrial and Human capital development projects with the intended aim of building out that muscle locally. The kinds of programs Rwanda creates like this (eg. CMU Kigali) simply don't have an RoI. The exact same thing happened in Ethiopia.
> implying they are doing ok
High GDP growth is expected at Rwanda's stage of development. But Rwanda's rate of growth is not as impressive compared to Cambodia, Kenya, and Vietnam when they were at a similar stage to Rwanda, but with a much lower dependency on foreign aid. Hell, when Kenya was at the exact same stage as Rwanda today in the mid-2000s, they were actively building out an industrial program (eg. Cements), a services economy (eg. mPesa, microfinancing), and investing in govt run universites.
Around 1.3% of GDP growth in Rwanda can be attributed to foreign aid alone. With foreign aid, it ends up getting disbursed and managed by NGOs and Donors directly, not the government. As such, this causes a significant deficiency in institutional knowledge. This has been seen with falsified poverty alleviation and GDP growth data from Rwanda. This is a very big trap that can cause Rwanda to fail to expand beyond their existing capacity. Rwanda's extreme dependence on aid at it's current stage is developing into a form of Dutch disease.
It's already started happening with more capital leaving Rwanda than entering it [4]. When Kenya [5] and Tanzania [6] were in a similar position in the 2000s and 2010s respectively they saw net flows of capital into their countries. This is dangerous as this implies that any economic activity within Rwanda is reaped abroad.
[0] - https://issafrica.org/iss-today/could-fdi-be-rwandas-lifeline-as-donors-pull-the-plug https://issafrica.org/iss-today/could-fdi-be-rwandas-lifelin...
[1] - https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/RWA/rwanda/foreign-direct-investment https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/RWA/rwanda/foreign-dir...
[2] - https://www.gov.rw/highlights/economy-and-business https://www.gov.rw/highlights/economy-and-business
[3] - https://asia.nikkei.com/Economy/China-and-India-stage-investment-showdown-in-Rwanda https://asia.nikkei.com/Economy/China-and-India-stage-invest...
[4] - https://tradingeconomics.com/rwanda/capital-flows https://tradingeconomics.com/rwanda/capital-flows
[5] - https://tradingeconomics.com/kenya/capital-flows https://tradingeconomics.com/kenya/capital-flows
[6] - https://tradingeconomics.com/tanzania/capital-flows https://tradingeconomics.com/tanzania/capital-flows
- tim333 3y agoWell, I've never been to Rwanda or know much about it but good luck to them. I quite liked the concept of being the Singapore of Africa having spent some time in actual Singapore and also Hong Kong which had a similar model to Singapore. Both those worked well although they both had strong rule of law and low corruption which often doesn't apply in Africa. I'm sticking with my hypothesis that info tech will let Africa develop faster than most expect though. AI probably even more so.
- alephnerd 3y ago> that info tech will let Africa develop I agree that ICT will help development massively, but that's Kenya, Uganda, and to a certain extent Tanzania. ICT makes up around 15% of Kenya's exports and 10% of Uganda's, and they've both been working hard on actually building a both a strong tech industry and a strong financial industry. Tanzania doesn't have as same a size of tech industry as Kenya or Uganda, but has been investing a massive amount on building that muscle. They also have a fairly decent industrial economy for their relative position as a LDC. Rwanda just doesn't have a similar base or bureaucrat class as Tanzania or Kenya or Uganda. Also, Rwanda doesn't actually have a tech industry. The handful of tech companies that are even there are Indian and Chinese run MSPs there to help Indian and Chinese conglomerates that temporarily setup shop there. > I quite liked the concept of being the Singapore of Africa The only reason you hear about "tech", "Singapore", and "Rwanda" in the same sentence is because they use Racepoint Global, BTP Advisers, and Portland Communicstions as their PR agency [0][1][2]. Racepoint the same company used by YC startups and a couple large public tech firms for PR and image rehabilitation and BTP Advisers has provided concierge image rehabilitation services for troubled countries like Azerbaijan, Montenegro, Qatar, and a couple conglomerates affiliated to Hezbollah. It's used as a case example of PR in MBA programs to this day. Portland Communications is a lobbying firm founded by Tony Blair's special advisors and has been used by Qatar, Israel, Russia, Singapore, Gazprom, Cisco, and Rio Tinto as well as their primary lobbyist in the EU and UK. [0] - https://store.hbr.org/product/a-public-relations-campaign-for-rwanda/W14342 https://store.hbr.org/product/a-public-relations-campaign-fo... [1] - https://btpadvisers.com/case-studies/rwanda https://btpadvisers.com/case-studies/rwanda [2] - https://www.lobbyfacts.eu/client?cid=5735 https://www.lobbyfacts.eu/client?cid=5735