4 ms·
What is with politicians and blackface? How hard is it to find someone to run for office who didn't wear blackface? I remember at my university we even had a st
by ryandrake 3y ago
What is with politicians and blackface? How hard is it to find someone to run for office who didn't wear blackface? I remember at my university we even had a student government leader embroiled in a scandal because he wore blackface at a Halloween party.
People, stop with the blackface! How is this not obvious?
- whatshisface 3y agoThe problem is that it was apparently far less obvious 50 years ago... The sheer number of conservatives who have been caught doing it shows it's some kind of ex post facto social norm. For liberals supporting "traditional marriage" is the ex post facto norm but there is much more forgiveness available for people who spoke against gay marriage when Obama was against it. There should probably be some kind of accepted system of forgiveness... but the culture is run by its second most progressive so I only expect it to be available for those who merely failed to be the absolute most progressive. I have a good track record of being the absolute most progressive for what it's worth.
- ryandrake 3y agoYea, I get it, there's history and attitudes changing. But, you'd think in 2021, someone thinking about running for public office might take a few minutes, sit down, and run through the checklist. You know, the basics: Did I ever rape anyone? Was I in the KKK? Did I ever wear blackface?
- whatshisface 3y agoThat's an, "arson, murder and jaywalking" list if I have ever heard one. :-) And no, I think that when those teenagers were donning their offensive Halloween costumes, they did not think it was going to cause serious offense decades in the future.
- true_religion 3y agoIn this case, the governor wasn’t a teenager. He was a 27 year old medical school student when the yearbook photo was taken. To make matters worse, this was the same year his school had its first black student so many white students were using the yearbook as an excuse to protest.
- csa 3y ago> Did I ever rape anyone? Was I in the KKK? Did I ever wear blackface? I think this is a gross oversimplification. Let me modernize the questions for the current era (since the alleged infractions were decades ago): 1. Have I ever touch someone romantically in any way without asking for explicit permission and receiving explicit approval? This is the alleged “standard” these days, although I think that it is only strictly adhered to in one very narrow social group. Overall, “feeling safe” and “respect” seems to be more common than it was many decades ago, but those are still a far cry from explicit consent at every step that some folks use as a “standard”. So if a potential politician cannot answer yes to this, then they leave themselves to being accused of being a rapist and/or sexual predator. 2. Am I in a social group that has a racial mix that does not approximate the local ratios (esp. if white)? California, where I live, is taking stances on equality that focus on outcomes more than opportunities. An unfortunate byproduct of this is that a group that is open to all groups, has members of at least all major groups, and has no policy or pattern of discrimination can still be called racist if their racial ratios are not at a certain level. This basically means that most private clubs are “racist” by this definition. Moose, Rotary, Chambers of Commerce, golf clubs, fraternities and sororities, American Legion branches, Masons (even Prince Hall), etc. are all organizations that have active members now that could be deemed “racist” if “racism” is defined as equality of outcome (as it is currently in CA K-12 education). Any potential policitian who is a member of one of these groups runs the risk of being called a racist. 3. Have I ever worn a costume of a character that is not my race? Moana, Mulan, Tiana, Jasmine, Pocahontas, are some Disney characters that are potentially out of bounds. Luke Cage, Blue Marvel, Storm, Blade, Misty Knight, Black Panther, and Moon Girl are Marvel characters that are potentially out of bounds. Any potential politician has to make sure that they have not worn any of these sorts of costumes, since at some point they may be accused of being racist or engaging in cultural appropriation. Times change, people make mistakes, people grow… we need to allow space for this, especially when a questionable action was not done with malicious intent.
- whatshisface 3y agoThe KKK was a violent organization 100 years ago, there is no surprise that it would disqualify you from office. Literally nobody in that group is surprised to find that outsiders think they are too racist...
- flutas 3y agoI don't think it's a partisan issue as you're trying to make it, "the sheer number of conservatives." Even Justin Trudeau has blackface pictures out there.
- whatshisface 3y agoI think Trudeau is certainly not progressive by Canadian standards!
- true_religion 3y agoI don’t think it’s a problem to accept that people have changed their ways, but pretty much in all cases of blackface people either deny it like the governor or pretend it’s not a big deal like the attorney general. If anyone were to confront me on my record on gay marriage, I’d apologize myself. I thought civil unions were the best option, because I come from a country where government marriage and traditional (e.g. tribal or church) marriage are totally separate systems governed by different laws. I can see now that in the USA, the distinction has never been so deep thus asking for civil unions over marriage is just insulting people with second class status. I was wrong. We are all wrong about something, sometime. If only politicians could admit fault, I could respect them.