5 ms·
Malpractice insurance is something like 2% of the overall medical costs in the US, and at least some states have caps on liability lawsuits. Looking now, it see
by dalke 15y ago
Malpractice insurance is something like 2% of the overall medical costs in the US, and at least some states have caps on liability lawsuits. Looking now, it seems malpractice insurance premiums have stayed pretty constant over the last couple of years.
Are you sure that malpractice is one of the major factors "driving up medical costs in this country", and if so, do you have a pointer to something which reinforces that statement?
Personally I thought the big increases in liability insurance coverage 5 or so years ago were because the insurance companies were so invested in the market, that after the market crash they needed to hike rates to build back their reserves. Those hikes were then used as justification in advocating liability caps.
- Retric 15y agoIt's not a major direct cost, however due to inefficiencies in the system your paying for that 2% in several additional ways. Doctors do a lot of tests to cover their ass. People without insurance tack their get their costs shifted to other people. Then Insurance company's tack on their profit margin above that 2% that's already been compounded a few times. And many of those unnecessary tests can cause further complications down the road due to things like false positives.
- dalke 15y agoI believe that 2% includes defensive medicine. Ahh, here's one of the relevant papers: http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/29/9/1569.abstract http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/29/9/1569.abstract "Overall annual medical liability system costs, including defensive medicine, are estimated to be $55.6 billion in 2008 dollars, or 2.4 percent of total health care spending." I really don't see 2.4% as one of the major things "driving up medical costs in this country." Here's another from http://www.factcheck.org/2009/10/malpractice-savings-reconsidered/ http://www.factcheck.org/2009/10/malpractice-savings-reconsi... "In an Oct. 9 letter to Republican Sen. Orrin Hatch of Utah, CBO Director Douglas Elmendorf said that a package of changes including limits on malpractice awards 'would reduce total national health care spending by about 0.5 percent (about $11 billion in 2009).'" "That figure includes a 0.2 percent reduction just from lower premiums for malpractice insurance paid by medical professionals. And it includes an additional 0.3 percent in reduced costs of medical tests, imaging and other medical services. " This would imply that the malpractice overhead isn't more than a couple percent. Personally, I think the major perception regarding malpractice is based on propaganda by people who want to put caps on all lawsuits. See, of all things, a Cracked article on the major examples of 'outrageous' judgements where the actual facts are at odds with the perceptions: http://www.cracked.com/article_19150_6-famous-frivolous-lawsuit-stories-that-are-total-b.s..html http://www.cracked.com/article_19150_6-famous-frivolous-laws... . Civil lawsuits are one of the few ways that individuals can take on large companies with bad business practices. Caps mean those companies are more free to make decisions in favor of cost-cutting over quality. Of course it's hard to justify it that way. It's much easier to say "idiotic medical lawsuits are one of the major reasons for increases in medical costs, so lets cap all lawsuits." Where do you get your idea that medical malpractice costs are a major contributor to increasing medical costs, either direct or indirect?
- Retric 15y agoWhere do you get your idea that medical malpractice costs are a major contributor to increasing medical costs, either direct or indirect? edit: I am not predicting future costs just describing things as they are right now. I know a few doctors paying well over 100k / year in personal malpractice insurance. Though it looks vary regional. http://www.ama-assn.org/amednews/2003/11/10/prl11110.htm http://www.ama-assn.org/amednews/2003/11/10/prl11110.htm Obstetrician-gynecologists Florida (Dade County) $201,376 (2002) $249,196(2003) South Dakota $13,325(2002) $14,662(2003) I agree that on it's own it's not the single top issue. But, don't forget those cost estimates 2.4% get multiplied by all the other inefficiency's in the system. I don't think putting cap's on all lawsuits is the best idea, but neither are lawsuits an efficient processes. Still, if you eliminate 5 different 2 percent inefficiency's your talking about a 10% drop in healthcare spending and around 220 billion dollars a year. There is no single bullet solution to healthcare. And a lot of people make their living directly from those inefficiency's, but you can't provide everyone the 'perfect' care that everyone seems to expect. Nor does 'perfect' care mean everyone get's to live forever.
- dalke 15y agoYes, I saw that article as well. It is now 9 years old, and out of date. Quoting from http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/751009 http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/751009 : "Premiums indeed rose dramatically in the early part of the new century, but in 2011, they declined for the fourth straight year for 3 representative medical specialties, according to a publication called Medical Liability Monitor (MLM). Its annual rate survey, highly regarded in the field, was published this week." You first said the 2% doesn't include the impact of defensive medicine. I pointed out that it did include defensive medicine, so now you say it's magnified by other inefficiencies in the system. I don't believe you, because your arguments sound very hand-wavy, and don't change in the presence of contrary data. Do you have any evidence to strengthen your statement? I could be even more hand-wavy and argue that the increase number of medical malpractice payouts is due to the medical system in the US getting worse. As http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/29/9/1565.full http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/29/9/1565.full points out, "One way to attack the medical liability crisis is to make health care better and safer in the first place" and "Another key to limiting medical malpractice suits is to improve communication with patients immediately after an injury" and "Most health policy experts, he says, believe that “caps on damages [are] tangential to the real problems with the malpractice system, which involve excessive numbers of medical errors, inaccessible compensation for most avoidable injuries, and a slow, expensive process of dispute resolution that is inhumane to both plaintiffs and defendants”." You pointed out that you know doctors paying over $100K/year in personal malpractice insurance. According to http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/29/9/1585.abstract http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/29/9/1585.abstract "We found high levels of malpractice concern among both generalists and specialists in states where objective measures of malpractice risk were low. We also found relatively modest differences in physicians’ concerns across states with and without common tort reforms. These results suggest that many policies aimed at controlling malpractice costs may have a limited effect on physicians’ malpractice concerns." or as stated in http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/29/9/1565.full http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/29/9/1565.full "Emily Carrier and colleagues find that physicians’ perceptions of the threat of being sued are out of step with their actual risk of being the target of a malpractice lawsuit." In other words, those doctors might not be needing the $100K+ coverage which they are paying for. According to http://www.kaiseredu.org/Issue-Modules/US-Health-Care-Costs/Background-Brief.aspx http://www.kaiseredu.org/Issue-Modules/US-Health-Care-Costs/... , "health care costs for chronic disease treatment account for over 75% of national health expenditures" and "At least 7% of health care expenditures are estimated to go toward for the administrative costs of government health care programs and the net cost of private insurance." Those two factors - which you didn't mention in your list of four things affecting the increase in medical rates - are both larger than the 2.4% we're talking about related to malpractice.