3 ms·
The bigger question for me is, "why is my SSN still such a valuable bit of information" We, the IT industry, have demonstrated repeatedly that we are not smart
by SoftTalker 3y ago
The bigger question for me is, "why is my SSN still such a valuable bit of information"
We, the IT industry, have demonstrated repeatedly that we are not smart enough and/or not diligent enough to consistently protect this information. I think we should admit that and try the reverse approach: make knowledge of our PII worthless for committing fraud and theft. We need to fundamentally shift our methods of proving identity to something that doesn't rely on keeping a 9-digit number a secret.
- purpleblue 3y agoThis is the dangers of a too-powerful bureaucracy. It's obvious that having the SSN as a single point of failure is exceedingly stupid, but our government bureaucrats refuse to do anything about it. You can't even request a new SSN, it's practically impossible to get a new one even if your identity is stolen. The only thing holding us back is red tape, which is the dumbest reason of all.
- vharuck 3y agoIt's the danger of using something as a universal password (terrible practice #1) that's often stored in plain text (terrible practice #2). I don't regularly deal much with federal government agencies beyond the IRS. Which ones let you do nefarious things if you only know a person's name, address, and SSN? The IRS doesn't, because they require you to know info from what you filed last year.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt probably seemed a lot more reasonable back when most people’s exposure to “password” was “the thing you needed to get into the speakeasy.”
- bee_rider 3y agoThat’s a bigger questions, and it is a good one, but practically it is not really relevant (other than, I guess, Okta’s vendor has made a small contribution to making it obvious how ill suited these numbers are for authentication).
- ls612 3y agoBecause the US has a political aversion to centralized IDs at the federal level, but an identity provider of some sort is necessary for lots of business interactions.