2 ms·
Having been in the room during and after investment committee meetings at a much smaller VC, the thing to realise is that most VC's are inundated by founders wh
by vidarh 3y ago
Having been in the room during and after investment committee meetings at a much smaller VC, the thing to realise is that most VC's are inundated by founders who do not understand the economics of the VC business.
If you go in to a VC and tell them that you can likely do a $50m trade sale in 3 years time, you're telling them you're a waste of time, because odds are still that you will fail before that, and you're not betting on a big enough outcome that if you're successful their return will offset enough of the failures.
When I worked for a VC, if you weren't pitching 100m+ revenue within 5-10 years, it was a near instant no. Not because we believed you'd achieve that, because most likely you wouldn't just fail to achieve that but you'd be bankrupt before then. But because if you're not even setting your sights high enough, you're not even in the game, and we needed founders to set their sights high enough that the few companies who survive has a shot at high enough exits.
But most founders who pitch do not understand that. Their pitch decks are defensive, and full of worst case estimates. The VC's worst case is that you'll be bankrupt; the proportion of companies who survive and live on as "zombies" that eventually produce a low trade sale produce returns way too low to offset the bankruptcies - founders that aim that low are wasted opportunities for VCs.
That goes a long way to explain why they'd be excited about someone who is selling an idea of some crazy expansive plan: Whether or not they though it realistic, they were seeing someone unusual enough to dare voice a crazy level of ambition. He only really needed to convince them he'd try, and make them think that the potential returns outweighed whatever increased risk they saw.
After the umpteenth founder telling you how they're minimising risk and showing your forecasts of a worst case scenario that are irrelevant to the VC fund, I can see that being exciting.
I've lost count of the number of founders we had to explain to that while their defensive plans probably increased their chance of their company surviving, if you go for VC investment, being conservative and defensive is not going to convince anyone, or they'd be retail bankers instead. You're effectively pitching a guaranteed loss rather than a likely loss but a chance at a big prize. Even a totally crazy pitch where it looks like they're some chance at a big prize is going to be more exciting than a pitch where the founder is telling you how best case he'll still not earn you enough.
Of course the problem with this is that it also plays straight into the hands of delusional or crooked people willing to just make shit up to try to sell an idea they have no idea how to make work, and punishes a lot of otherwise brilliant founders who just don't understand what is expected by a VC.
- paulddraper 3y agoVC is rocket fuel for rockets. If you're not in the business of making rockets, you don't need rocket fuel.
- vidarh 3y agoExactly. But far too many founders don't get this, I guess in large parts because it is VC's that get talked about as the most prominent funding option and most founders might fantasise about making it big even though if they really think it through it's not where their heart is. So many founders should be talking to angel investors first, and may never be right for VCs. There's nothing wrong with never being right for a VC investment. But there are also quite a few founders who wants to make rockets, but don't get that VC's are perfectly fine with the risks and are more interested in hearing about your vision for making the best rockets ever than how you're going to make them lose slightly less of their money if you fail.