3 ms·
okay, i don't agree with anything in your reply. segmenting a video file for HLS/DASH delivery is not at all the same thing I'm suggesting. Just for the sake of
by dylan604 3y ago
okay, i don't agree with anything in your reply. segmenting a video file for HLS/DASH delivery is not at all the same thing I'm suggesting. Just for the sake of round numbers, i'm saying to take a 90 minute feature into nine 10-minute segments. fire up 10 separate instances to encode each 10-minute segment. you've just increased the encode time 10x. also, DASH/HLS does not require segmented files. you can have a single contiguous file like an fmp4 as a DASH/HLS source.
>Ok, but why not split the file up for standard encoding?<snip>
at this point, you would be better served by just writing an elementary stream rather than a muxed mp4 file since it's just a segment anyways so why waste the cycles on muxing? you then absolutely 100% can concat those streams (even if you did mux them into a container). if you think you can't, you clearly have not tried very hard.
>I don't work there, just something I read once
I don't work there either, but do have 30+ years of experience with this subject. Sadly, you're not as well informed as you might think. People don't tend to encode to AV1 from RAW. They instead are dealing with a deliverable file most typically a ProRes in today's world after the post process has been completed. No where near terabytes for a feature. More closely to a couple hundred gigabytes for UHD HDR content. You seem to be unnecessarily exaggerating.
Edit: it's a 10x increase in encode speed, not time. that would be opposite effect.
- bick_nyers 3y agoWhy did the encode time increase by 10x in that instance? Can't you just seek in the video to the I-frame before the cut point and start your encode there? I've never tried merging streams across computers so was naively just thinking that your output from each computer would be an MP4 but that makes sense. I pulled that info. from a Netflix talk, perhaps video cameras back from when that talk occured didn't compress the video for you? Besides, isn't IMAX all intra-encoded? It was my understanding that IMAX films are actually just a series of J2K images, so I would imagine that the video cameras used there would also be intra-encoded.
- dylan604 3y agos/increase/decrease/ i was thinking increased the encode speed 9x, but typed increased encode time. i also swapped the number of segments by segment duration. 9 segments of 10mins = 9x increase in performance. Sounds like you are confusing Netflix' recommended formats for acquisition vs delivery. Cameras capture RAW formats (rarely is it uncompressed though), and the post houses use that as sources. The post house/color correction will the create the delivery formats which is typically ProRes. RAW is not a friendly format for distribution in the slightest. The full workflow from camera original to what ends up being streamed to the end viewer changes formats multiple times through the process.
- bick_nyers 3y agoGotcha, that makes much more sense