5 ms·
11% of the world’s billionaires have held or sought political office
- nh23423fefe 3y agoCrassus was onto something
- andrepd 3y agoHe also died in an... interesting fashion.
- ejb999 3y agoWell I for one would much prefer people get rich in the private sector, and then go into politics, instead of going into politics and then getting rich, which seems to be standard-operating-procedure these days.
- cmurf 3y agoI prefer strongly applying ethical standards in politics. This would protect the public against corruption by public officials than just one variety of conflict of interest.
- MrRolleyes 3y agoI'd much prefer the private and public sectors remain as separate as possible. The alternative is difficult to distinguish from corruption.
- kcatskcolbdi 3y agoThe notion that wealth prior to politics might deter in-office enrichment is understandable, but the reality is a bit more complex. Wealth doesn't inherently negate the potential for conflicts of interest or policy biases that could benefit a politician's own financial interests. After all, the same drive that helps individuals amass their fortunes—ambition, competitiveness—doesn't just switch off once they're in a position of public power. And personal integrity isn't tied to one's bank account balance; it's about character and the robustness of political and legal accountability systems. So, regardless of whether someone is wealthy before politics, without strong ethical standards and transparent oversight, the risk of using political office for personal gain remains.
- tristor 3y ago> the risk of using political office for personal gain remains. You're absolutely correct. I think the person you were replying to was being pithy about the fact we have essentially in-the-open legal corruption happening in the US today where politicians can get elected to high office with minimal personal fortunes and be millionaires before they complete their first term simply due to the nature of that corruption (for instance, legalized insider-trading for Congress).
- kcatskcolbdi 3y agoOh, I may have missed the nuance there, thank you! I very much am against the corruption we witness so blatantly. Personally I thought that if wealthy people were elected to office we may be able to eliminate some of that, but it seems as though if anything they are just better at it.
- houseinthesky 3y agoI believe the insider-trading thing pretty small in real world impact. Paid speeches, book deals, consulting payments and jobs for family members or after holding office are the more significant items. We have a funny system where paying a politician $250k for a one hour speech to your company, trade group, union, political action committee or whatever is treated as a perfectly reasonable speaker fee, and totally different than just handing the politician the money in a briefcase. Or hiring a politician's 22 year old new-grad child at an executive salary.
- bobthepanda 3y agoIIRC most congress people do not beat the S&P.
- djkivi 3y agoWhile some of them beat Warren Buffett.
- bobthepanda 3y ago
- jedberg 3y agoThe article points out that most seem to do it for wealth preservation.
- JohnClark1337 3y ago[dead]
- darklycan51 3y agoeither way it's wrong, the "rich" people often get there through cutthroat practices and then want to keep their fortune via policy making... not much better
- ajross 3y ago> instead of going into politics and then getting rich, which seems to be standard-operating-procedure these days. I can't think of a single billionaire who made their wealth while in politics, or after. You can come out of politics and get a kushy low-seven-figure lobbying job, at best. Maybe if you were really senior (congressional leadership, VP, president) you can write a few books and give a bunch of speeches and get to the tens of millions in income, but that's as far as it goes. Basically "politics" produces maybe 5-6 people per decade able to pull what a median FAANG acquihire founder gets. That sounds... pretty democratic to me, really.
- rsynnott 3y ago> I can't think of a single billionaire who made their wealth while in politics, or after. Common in extremely corrupt authoritarian regimes; Putin would be an obvious example. But yeah, less common in democracies; I'm struggling to think of a modern example.
- LeafItAlone 3y agoWhy’s that? I would rather they get rich after being in politics, but not because of special consideration while in politics. When I was younger, I used to have the attitude that “if they got rich running a business, clearly they know how to succeed and would be great to run the country”. But that turns out to be naive thinking. I have absolutely no problem with a former politician becoming a millionaire (or billionaire or they can do it!) from using what they learned while in office, provided they didn’t use their time in office setting up for that against the betterment of the public. In my experience, it’s easy to quickly forget what it is like to be an “average citizen“ when you can pay $10 for a banana. How can you truly represent what you don’t understand?
- vore 3y agoIn practice, I think this gets you politicians who are completely detached from the common man – what do you mean you don’t have a personal maid that does all your shopping for you?
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agoThis is only true for inter-generational wealth.
- renjimen 3y ago“Self-made” people can have their own distorted understanding of how a healthy society works (through hard work and sacrifice! /s)
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agoIs it your belief that self made people got there by not working hard? Name a self made person that didn't work hard.
- hotpotamus 3y agoName a "self made" person - presumably an infant who was abandoned and somehow survived on their own, and then built everything they used to live on. Pedantic I'm sure, but it's such a ridiculous idea in a modern industrial society as to be meaningless anyway.
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agoThat's not what self made means, try again.
- vore 3y agoI don't think that's true – look at your average Wall Street first generation finance bro, I don't think they can understand the plight of the single mother clipping coupons to scrape by.
- renjimen 3y agoSure, but those are two of the least egalitarian things that can happen in a democracy. Conflicts of interest abound. Business and politics should be discouraged from intertwining at the individual level like that.
- justrealist 3y agoOk.
- gnicholas 3y agoOf course — how do you think they became billionaires? /s
- olegious 3y ago"89% of the world's billionaires have not held or sought political office." Makes a far less interesting headline.
- haskellandchill 3y agowell taking what percent of the control group have held or sought political office and then making a comparison has potential
- _aaed 3y agoThey've only lobbied people who did
- tux3 3y agoI would like to quote from Wikipedia. The Base rate: It is the proportion of individuals in a population who have a certain characteristic or trait. For example, if 1% of the population were medical professionals, and remaining 99% were not medical professionals, then the base rate of medical professionals is 1%. The base rate for people who have never held or sought office is much higher than 89%. It's not enough to mirror the number around 100% to make a small number into a big number, you also have to compare with the base rate.
- idlewords 3y ago"Held or sought" is quite a catchall category. People concerned with the influence of money on elections should take solace in the time Bloomberg spent $100 million in the Presidential primary to win American Samoa. Meg Whitman, although not a billionaire, is another encouraging example. By the end it's estimated she had so saturated the California airwaves that her ads were losing her votes.
- pleasantpeasant 3y agoWhat about the billionaires/multimillionaires who don't seek any positions but donate to campaigns, PACs, ideological think-tanks. This article would never have the Koch brothers in their study because, technically, they never sought to be in office, even though we know they donate billions of dollars to their think-tanks and super PACs.
- pb7 3y agoHe actually spent $900 million according to the New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/20/us/politics/bloomberg-campaign-900-million.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/20/us/politics/bloomberg-cam...
- alpha_squared 3y agoI think that actually worked out in his favor, too, because had someone like Elizabeth Warren or Bernie Sanders won, he'd have had a much larger tax bill than that.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThey’d have no control over tax policy in Presidential office. Bloomberg burned almost $1B to realize he was unviable. If that’s how billionaire wish to divest their wealth, with enormous spend that gets no traction, we should not get in their way.
- pjscott 3y agoInterestingly, there's huge variance by country. Billionaires are much more likely to seek office in countries where this is either a source of valuable behind-the-scenes connections (e.g. China) or a way of preventing the regime from plundering their wealth (e.g. Russia).
- gojomo 3y agoNotably, it's only 3.7% in the US, & 5% across democracies – but 29% in autocracies, and 36% in China. There are some fishy things in their choices, with potential rationales but still creating caveats about their results. For example: • "excludes politicians and royal family members whose wealth and political power cannot be disentangled. Vladimir Putin, for example, is not on the list despite speculation that he may be the world’s wealthiest person" • those who had political roles before they became billionaires, like Sheryl Sandberg, are excluded because "they reflect a different dynamic than the wealth-to-politics trajectory that we explore in this paper" (?!) • it even includes failed runs (election losses & early-aborted campaigns) & some positions that can be almost entirely ceremonial (ambassadorships to minor countries) Further, the only comparison to rates of participation of non-billionaire groups is a vague mention of that only "4%" of people in "pipeline fields" like "law, business, education, and community activism" who "consider" running-for-office do so. Notably, that's about-equal to the US billionaire's "3.7%" participation. And, it'd be interesting to drill-into the mega-political-feeders (in the US) – like children/family of politicians, or law degrees from top/Ivy schools. I suspect those may blow billionaire involvement rates out of the water.
- rsynnott 3y ago> those who had political roles before they became billionaires, like Sheryl Sandberg, are excluded because "they reflect a different dynamic than the wealth-to-politics trajectory that we explore in this paper" (?!) She was a civil servant, who then moved into the private sector doing ad sales, and won the lottery twice (she joined Google in 2001 and Facebook in 2007). Not to say she wasn't skilled, she clearly was, but she was also very lucky with timing and with which companies she joined. Going from public to private sector isn't uncommon, and her role in Google wasn't closely related to her civil service role. There are, presumably, hundreds if not thousands of civil service people who left the same year she did, took roles in the tech sector, but oops, most of them joined Yahoo or Pets.com, or a million companies who were gone by 2003, and that was the end of that. She's such an edge-case that it probably makes sense to exclude her. Now, if Nick Clegg (former leader of the LibDems and Deputy PM of the UK, now works at Facebook) were to become fabulously wealthy, that would be more relevant (and arguably more worrying); so far that hasn't really happened tho. EDIT: Yahoo may be a bad example; thinking about it I'm not sure it actually was in decline in 2001. Worldcom? Webvan? Netscape? Whatever; loads of examples available; most high-flying exec types joining tech companies, just as well-regarded as Google at the time, out of the civil service (or anywhere else) in 2001 would've ended up with some worthless paper, but joining _Google_ was winning the lottery, and then she did it again with Facebook.
- paulpauper 3y ago"sought" could be a bid for office in which the objective is to generate PR and not to actually win
- libraryatnight 3y agoThinking about this comment; I imagine some are sincere, but I imagine for more it's PR as you say, or just a thing to do at that strata of wealth - they have all kinds of means at their disposal of influencing political or cultural change, actually running for office seems (as you point out) likely less about obtaining the office or the power. I also wonder if resigning yourself to some sort of business that you can make appear successful while you live off your inheritance is like their working retail, and getting yourself onto a board, or into office is like being a doctor or lawyer to us ;) This is just pure poor person musing though for funsies on lunch :P
- lapetitejort 3y agoA few poor souls accidentally won their seats. And since backing out would be a sign of weakness, they've had to keep up the facade for going on decades now.
- swayvil 3y ago89% of the world's billionaires have "contributed to the campaign fund" of the other 11%.
- ProfessorLayton 3y agoWild. If I was a billionaire I'd be way too busy figuring out how to spend money and time with my loved ones before we're all dead. I'd maybe join a non-profit, but a political office wouldn't even cross my mind.
- jdminhbg 3y agoSame, that’s why we’re both not billionaires.
- Xeoncross 3y ago"Large portion of asset-controlling people seek to influence laws" Tell me, has there ever been a government not controlled by wealthy people? Does the form of government really matter if the laws are all written by lobbyists and company PR (democracies) or bribed officials (dictatorship) or both (socialism)?
- swayvil 3y agoMy local city council consists entirely of millionaires who are there to look after their investments.
- Xeoncross 3y agoI think more people would be shocked if they knew how common this was. As a high-net worth individual, either be present or pay someone to do your bidding - but don't ignore your chance at maintaining and growing your assets!
- amadeuspagel 3y agoInteresting for a number of reasons: - Working behind the scenes doesn't seem to be enough. Otherwise, why bother running for office. Of course, it can not be enough in different ways - not enough power, not enough fame. - The same people are successful in wildly different fields - or these fields aren't so different at all.
- pleasantpeasant 3y agoThis article fails to mention the ultra-wealthy who lobby, donate to super PACs, donate to think-tanks, sponsor biased research studies. It's ignoring the real way most of the ultra-wealthy use their wealth to influence politics, on a local level or national level.
- rsynnott 3y ago> The same people are successful in wildly different fields I mean, define _successful_. I can't think of any _highly regarded_ billionaire politicians. In democracies they rarely even get elected; they just blow a load of money on a futile campaign.
- seydor 3y agoIs this increasing or decreasing? If it 's increasing it 's worrying, because it means that more power lies with in the State than with private enterprise. If it's decreasing it would mean that rich people feel their money has more power. Obviously money is more equally distributed than positions of state power. Maybe that explains why billionaires are so enmeshed in public function in autocratic states: their money doesn't give freedoms. Extreme examples are the Saudis where money and power are one and the same.
- chmod600 3y agoSeeking political office is asking for punishment. The media can be brutal. A small slice of the general population will be haters no matter what and in absolute numbers that's a lot of people that hate you. Billionaires can insulate themselves from this brutality and may have some experience with it already. Non-billionaires can't, and so it's just not worth it to run for office unless you care more about power than about yourself and your family. Not saying that billionaires are great politicians or anything, but it certainly makes sense. If we want something better we need more civilized discourse.
- alpha_squared 3y ago> The media can be brutal. "The media" can also be pretty favorable in practically any set of loosely held beliefs you want to cobble together into a campaign. You'll find some platform willing to give you a mic to espouse the ideology with a nudge, nudge, wink, wink to working closer together once you accumulate power. I'm skeptical that tying politics and wealth in any form leads to a good outcome.
- chmod600 3y agoFavorable in that they may support your acquisition of power. Almost never favorable at a human or family level. So if all you care about power, they media is a great ally. If you also have ordinary human desires, like not having a constant mob of haters saying horrible things to you and your family, then the media is not great. In other words, the media filters out most normal people from politics by the sheer horrribleness of the process.
- bobthepanda 3y agoIt also costs money to be a politician. Billionaires are able to loan to their campaigns pretty heavily, Michael Bloomberg loaned himself $65M to get re-elected as NYC mayor in 2009. There’s no political expenditure cap in the US and media slots are not cheap. Meanwhile first term congressmen that were poor have trouble finding housing in DC. https://www.npr.org/2022/12/09/1141635119/the-first-gen-z-member-of-congress-was-denied-a-d-c-apartment-due-to-bad-credit https://www.npr.org/2022/12/09/1141635119/the-first-gen-z-me...