3 ms·
I've got a theory that sub Saharan Africa will develop a lot faster than many people think. I think of lot of why it did not in the past is it was mostly cut of
by tim333 3y ago
I've got a theory that sub Saharan Africa will develop a lot faster than many people think. I think of lot of why it did not in the past is it was mostly cut off from information. Until about 2000 there was not much in the way of books, newspapers etc that most Africans could afford and long distance communications were terrible. Also it was hard to get around unlike the areas where much culture developed around the med where it had been easy to get around by sea. Now they all have smart phones and internet and are on much more of a level playing field with the rest of the world.
- alephnerd 3y agoIt will develop, but it will take 3-4 generations. Just looking at East Africa, even Kenya's current HDI is at 0.575, and the rest of East Africa is much lower. Rwanda is at 0.534 (this is potentially suspect as Rwanda has been fudging numbers [0]), Tanzania is at 0.549, and Uganda is at 0.525. It is a similar story in West Africa as well. While there are some bright spots in human capital in Kenya, it's much less diffused than similar undeveloped to developed stories like Bangladesh or Vietnam, let alone China, India, Thailand, etc. Going from less developed to developing requires some kind of a nudge and capital, and in South Korea, Bangladesh and Vietnam's cases it came from Japan, India and China respectively. There isn't a similar case in sub-Saharan Africa yet. If South Africa can get it's economy back in track, there might be a shot for the rest of the continent, as they are in the right position to diffuse capital, human capital, and businesses. [0] - https://www.ft.com/content/683047ac-b857-11e9-96bd-8e884d3ea203 https://www.ft.com/content/683047ac-b857-11e9-96bd-8e884d3ea...
- tim333 3y agoIf you look at the rate of increase in HDI though then less developed Africa is the fastest improving. (Average annual HDI growth from 2010 to 2021 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_Human_Development_Index#List https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_Human_Dev...) The other region which has grown fast is the China area but that may slow a bit as China de-accelerates.
- alephnerd 3y agoTrue, but it's at a lower base. HDI is a mixture of per Capita income, life expectancy, and literacy. Life Expectancy and Literacy rate has been growing at a significant amount in plenty of sub-Saharan Africa over the past few years, but that's from a low base. The extremely low hanging fruit will be largely caught within a decade, which will then slow down as that requires significant reforms and expansion in healthcare and education quality and availability. Per Capita Income will still always be a significant issue though, as my earlier point still stands. You need a strong economy to further grow out, and that is largely a factor of good education as well as you need to climb up the value chain. Climbing the value chain is hard without outside stimulus. Most countries that have seen a rapid transformation were able to do so because another country decided to mentor and invest a massive amount in the country's economic base. There just isn't a reason to do any manufacturing or high value services in most sub-Saharan African economies. There are plenty of cheap and well integrated Asian countries right now like like Bangladesh, Cambodia, Laos, Vietnam, parts of India that can still be competitive in low manufacturing for the next 1-2 decades. It will anyhow take 1-2 decades for some sub-Saharan countries to anyhow invest in human capital. Kenya and Tanzania have been doing some very hard work on this regard. With Rwanda, less so if we're being honest. Flashy projects like CMU Kigali and Thailand level cleanliness aside, Rwanda hasn't been able to bring a high value industry into the country yet. It's GDP per Capita is barely $1,000, median income is around $750-780, and around 60% of public and infra investment is coming directly from foreign aid. The business culture there is simply much less mature compared to that in Nairobi or Dar es Salaam, and what happens when Kagame dies? The same thing happened with Ethiopia. Addis Ababa became very flashy and clean, yet the country ended up collapsing into civil war and almost a decade of development was washed away. > other region which has grown fast is the China area The biggest winner from an HDI growth basis was actually Türkiye. They largely caught up with Eastern Europe over the last 15-20 years, and were able to keep consistently high growth (around 5-6% GDP growth rate in average since 2009) despite hitting China in 2023 level metrics almost 15 years ago China's growth has been amazing but it will largely slow down
- tim333 3y agoSometimes free market economics lets countries grow without a government plan. "Rwanda hasn't been able to bring a high value industry into the country yet" implies a lack industrial planning but googling a bit finds: >KIGALI, July 11, 2023—Rwanda’s economy grew by 9.2% in the first quarter of 2023, following 8.2% growth in 2022. implying they are doing ok. I wish we had that sort of growth in Brexit Britain where I reside! Here we get: >UK economy grew by 0.2% overall between April and June, after a surprisingly positive performance... which is not quite the same.
- vivekd 3y agoI'll believe that when I see a single startup come out of Africa and compete on the the world economy. 0, I see exactly 0. What about innovations or websites. Again 0. Look at Forbes list of African innovations - it's bull, a pedal powered toilet, an electric pedicab made from recycled materials (like what?!) This isn't a country we're talking about, this is a continent. Something is wrong. https://www.forbes.com/sites/mfonobongnsehe/2014/02/13/seven-innovative-products-from-africa-you-should-know/?sh=a0ff4957f1c3 https://www.forbes.com/sites/mfonobongnsehe/2014/02/13/seven... This guy's explanation hits on what I saw there. In Africa business and politics go together. The money isn't going to support innovators or entrepreneurs or business. It's going to politicians and that's it. That's where taxes are going, that's where foreign aid is going, that's where it's all going. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpbyDIpIStc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpbyDIpIStc