3 ms·
So just to be clear, you believe gut-instinct "public good" overrides due process and the rule of law? This is certainly a very common and hence reasonable opin
by mindslight 15y ago
So just to be clear, you believe gut-instinct "public good" overrides due process and the rule of law? This is certainly a very common and hence reasonable opinion, backed up by decades of juris-"prudence". I'd just like to be explicit about its general prevalence, lest people are misled into thinking that the lofty ideals in the country's founding documents have much relevance to modern society.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 15y agoNo? Do you just read the middle sentences out of comments, start fuming, and then get to typing?
- mindslight 15y agoFunnily enough, I was replying to the general progression of your three comments. You started off arguing as if abstract legal analysis was the most important thing, moved to a guilty-by-construction example while implying that Supreme Court precedent is the most important, and ultimately fell back on the court of public opinion. It's fine to hold a barbershop "he's guilty" viewpoint, but framing it as something much more philosophical is dishonest.
- tptacek 15y agoNo. You alluded to the notion that I'd already made up my mind about this case. As a courtesy to you & the thread, I confirmed your suspicion, and then stated that my bias is why we're glad I don't decide the case. You repaid the courtesy by ignoring the last sentence and then hitting my over the head with other sentences of mine out of context.