4 ms·
Because there's essentially a whole second sentencing trial. After the verdict, the Parole Office prepares a Presentence Report (I'm not sure if these are publi
by tptacek 3y ago
Because there's essentially a whole second sentencing trial. After the verdict, the Parole Office prepares a Presentence Report (I'm not sure if these are public? I'm always looking for them and never finding them on PACER†), the "PSR", which is like the opening bid for the recommended offense levels and grouping. The prosecution and defense then respond to the PSR with exculpatory, mitigating, or aggravating claims, victim impact testimony, your scout leader when you made Eagle Scout, all that stuff. Only then does the judge work out what the actual sentence is.
The guidelines calculations, contrary to public belief, are pretty easy! You will have a pretty good success rate just carefully reading the charged statutes in the indictment and then following the instructions in the guidelines. But the PSR, prosecution, and defense filings all take a bunch of time, and involve "reporting" or "research" or whatever you'd want to call it.
That process ostensibly can't even start until everyone knows what the precise convictions were.
For what it's worth, I think there's a very good chance he just gets the statutory maximum penalties here, because the dollar loss and victim count numbers max out the 2B1.1 guidelines (which, for instance, cap out at $10MM in dollar losses). Attributing specific dollar losses and victim counts is ostensibly one of the things that makes sentencing take so long, but as long as it takes I think the outcome is a foregone conclusion.
† Later: they're definitely not public; there's a whole victims rights thing about getting victims partial access to PSRs so they can be heard in the sentencing process. I guess I can stop looking for them.
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoThank you! I learned from this. Follow up - is there any kind of correlation in the gap length, between sentencing and PSR ? I could see a situation where the gap is longer than a sentence, and that would be pretty sad for the prosecuted...
- tptacek 3y agoThat's not so much going to be an issue in this case. But a lot of the time, especially in federal white collar cases, the defendant isn't in custody during sentencing anyways.
- alexchantavy 3y agoSo in this case is SBF still in custody awaiting sentencing?
- tptacek 3y agoI believe so, because he was an idiot during the trial and violated his home confinement conditions. But his sentence is going to be so long that there isn't going to be any injustice at play for him to be in confinement for a few months while they work the numbers out. He's not getting out in a year or two.
- Sanzig 3y agoYes. He was out on bail, but that was revoked for witness tampering ahead of the trial. I doubt he'll get out before sentencing, he's looking at up to life in prison so in addition to having a demonstrated history of ignoring his release conditions he'll also be a huge flight risk.
- costco 3y agoA guy named Lev Dermen just got 40 years with a guidelines score of 47 (the table doesn't even go that high). He was charged with defrauding the government out of half a billion dollars in biodiesel tax credits, went to trial and kind of like SBF all the other conspirators testified against him. That case also had destruction of evidence, witness intimidation, and at the time of sentencing the government was still trying to recover a Bugatti and a bunch of money in Turkey from him. But the number of victims and the hardship element probably means he's looking at life.
- tptacek 3y agoI got offense levels: * 7 as the 2b1.1 baseline * +30 for dollar loss, which caps out at $550MM, against CFTC's estimate of $8Bn * +6 for 25+ victims, another cap * +2 for financial misrepresentations, maybe, depending on how bankruptcy fits in * +2 for either sophisticated means or deliberate use of foreign jurisdictions (the same clause, one of those predicates is definitely going to hit) * +4 for jeopardizing (or, in this case, destroying) a financial institution --- at a minimum, +2 (same clause) for >$1MM gross receipts * +4 for his function as the leader in the crime * +2 for obstruction, maybe * +1-2 for grouping/combined offense level, depending on how the conspiracy, wire fraud, and campaign finance stuff groups out. So that's low-to-high 50s as an offense level. 43 is straight life. But there's probably a statutory maximum in the mix here that takes life off the table somehow. Later: I miskeyed the 2B1.1b1 cap, as 10MM (the bottom of the page); it's 550MM (on the next page). Doesn't change the analysis much, which is why SBF is so fucked.
- akerl_ 3y agoI was hunting around for an easy way to do this kind of math, and found https://www.sentencing.us/ https://www.sentencing.us/ . I haven't done an amazingly deep validation, but the math lines up with the above, and thankfully SBF has done a pretty good job stress testing the various clauses, so I'm going to be bookmarking it for the future.
- tptacek 3y agoI started with sentencing.us, but after entering the dollar loss figures, anything I clicked got me "life", which I don't trust.