5 ms·
The case against Microsoft was based on Microsoft giving away a free browser. That never made any antitrust sense - no consumer harm was ever demonstrated. Iro
by WalterBright 3y ago
The case against Microsoft was based on Microsoft giving away a free browser. That never made any antitrust sense - no consumer harm was ever demonstrated.
Ironically, today every platform includes a free browser.
- metabagel 3y agoConsumer harm wasn’t originally a requirement for antitrust enforcement. It was added by conservative jurists mostly to make it difficult to successfully bring antitrust cases. And hey, it worked!
- WalterBright 3y ago> It was added by conservative jurists mostly to make it difficult to successfully bring antitrust cases. Other than harm to consumers, what do you say is the harm from a trust? After all, aren't high prices an indicator of a monopoly? > And hey, it worked! And maybe it should. Imagine the hellfire and damnation stemming from having a free browser! I suppose I'll be damned forever for providing a free implementation of D.
- metabagel 3y ago(sigh) I think you're a lost cause, but maybe someone else will read this. Monopolies tend to keep growing until they are broken up. Monopolies don't have to charge high prices to consumers if they can increase their profits at the expense of sellers. In the case of Amazon, sellers may be authors or publishers who get squeezed. They may be small businesses. They may be big businesses. There is additional harm to the consumer from the distorted marketplace which results. You may not be aware, but Microsoft engaged in a lot of monopolistic activity, including preventing OEMs from including the BEOS operating system as a dual boot operation on systems which shipped with Windows. You may also not be aware that Microsoft tried to get Apple to kill their own browser, a.k.a. "knife the baby". Google it.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Monopolies tend to keep growing until they are broken up No, they don't. Left alone, they grow until they collapse from internal bureaucracy and inefficiency. > Monopolies don't have to charge high prices to consumers if they can increase their profits at the expense of sellers. Microsoft gave away the browser for free. > In the case of Amazon, sellers may be authors or publishers who get squeezed. Resellers normally buy at wholesale prices and sell at retail. The same percentage as Amazon takes for providing retail services. As a small business (Datalight and Zortech days) I am well aware of this. > You may not be aware I am aware. Microsoft failed to stop Linux, and failed at stopping Apple.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoTheir actions were taken to stop Netscape, and succeeded. Keeping Linux and Be off the desktop succeeded well enough also.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Their actions were taken to stop Netscape, and succeeded Making a much better product often does that. You'd know what I mean if you were a Netscape user :-/
- mixmastamyk 3y agoThey did lots shady things also, belt and suspenders style. Which is the subject here. I started on gopher and Mosaic and Netscape was far ahead and good enough for a long while. Only until IE4 did MS pull away. Of course by IE6 the damage was done and they left the entire industry broken with a moribund dominant browser that took a decade to recover from. Rot in hell.
- nicoburns 3y ago> No, they don't. Left alone, they grow until they collapse from internal bureaucracy and inefficiency. Eventually, maybe. But it usually takes far too long and if we speed up the process (and smooth out a boom/bust cycle at the same time) then that seems like a win to me. If we agree that smaller companies are more efficient then we should actively bias the economy towards them rather than allowing big companies to outcompete them purely because they have market power.
- taeric 3y agoThe case against Microsoft was that they used revenue from other markets to offer a browser for free so that they could prevent a competition in the browser space... There is an argument that the browser is a feature, not a product. But that is not the case for back then.
- WalterBright 3y agoBoth parties offered a free browser. Boo-hoo. Have you noticed that vast categories of computer programs are free today? Do you realize that every one of those was funded by revenue obtained elsewhere? That whole anti-trust case was chock full of jaw-dropping absurdities. BTW, the D Language Foundation is funded by donations. We charge $0 for our products. Anyone can also fork it and do whatever they please with the fork. We particularly like it when people use it for commercial purposes, i.e. making money!
- taeric 3y agoThis is largely true, of course, but also a complete non sequitur? There have been free and donation based things for a long time. Shareware was very awesome, to me. But to pretend Microsoft was not engaging in questionable practices feels very bullshit heavy. And an equivalency game here is very discrediting to both arguments.
- WalterBright 3y agoWhat is "questionable" about it?
- taeric 3y agoQuestionable about their practices? I remember the effort it used to take to get netscape to be the browser your machine used. It was comically difficult to do, at times. So much so that I was never comfortable going for the paid Opera, as I just didn't think it would stick to my machine. It is frustrating, because I think it is largely fair to say that netscape was the worse option at the time. Navigator was largely trash. That said, jscript and activex controls were both obvious land grabs on the internet. I'm... not really sure how most any part of what all Microsoft did back then can be defended.
- Karunamon 3y agoClassifying what Microsoft got in trouble for as merely "giving away a free browser" shows that their PR campaign was a resounding success. It wasn't just having IE be distributed with the operating system, or even having it be the default (as the EU later got upset about). They would have been perfectly fine in this position had they not attempted to use it anti-competitively: coercing OEMs to not include competing browsers like Netscape on pain of financial penalties. That is textbook monopoly abuse.
- WalterBright 3y agoI installed and used Netflix for free in those days. Nobody paid a penalty for that. I later switched to Explorer, not because it was free, but because Explorer crashed far less often than Netscape. Netscape crashed constantly. Only a desperate person would continue to use it.
- FireBeyond 3y agoBut were you using Netscape or Netscape Gold??
- WalterBright 3y agoThe free one, whatever that was. It was a long time ago. If you're saying Netflix Gold didn't crash as often, the crashing free version was not a convincing advertisement for it. There was a lot of money made in the PC era by making better tools than the ones bundled with DOS. Netscape wasn't one of them, because it was worse than the bundled one.