3 ms·
> Eh, this is still a civil matter. Well, yes, that's clearly true whether or not it is also a criminal matter. > Unless the picture was made for the purpose
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Eh, this is still a civil matter.
Well, yes, that's clearly true whether or not it is also a criminal matter.
> Unless the picture was made for the purpose of harassment, there is no ill will we can presuppose the perpetrators had towards the victim
That is almost tautologically true, but on what bases do you conclude that it is so certain as not to warrant inquiry that there was no intent to harrass?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> on what bases do you conclude that it is so certain as not to warrant inquiry that there was no intent to harrass I conclude it is uncertain enough to warrant solely civil engagement on the basis of them being kids. Otherwise, every five year old pantsing their sibling becomes a matter for armed law enforcement.
- dragonwriter 3y agoYeah, no, that doesn't follow. "Kids" aren't a uniform category; there's a reason that kids under 7 are generally viewed as incapable of the necessary mental capacity for criminal accountability, and between 7 and 14 there is in most states a presumption of incapacity that must be overcome in addition to the usual proof requirements for crime. So, no, you don't have to treat acts by minors in their late teens as irrefutably noncriminal without investigation to avoid considering acts by five year olds to be that way (even before considering ways that the act you suggest for the five year old was dissimilar to the one at issue for the older minors in the article, which would be another axis on which treatment could also reasonably be differentiated.)