4 ms·
I don't think they were. After reading this my view of this person is just a corporate drone. Obviously this proposal is to serve the content owners, not the us
by wkat4242 3y ago
I don't think they were. After reading this my view of this person is just a corporate drone. Obviously this proposal is to serve the content owners, not the users, whatever the thoughts behind it are. And yes it may not be intended to block adblockers but it certainly can easily be used for that once it's ubiquitous. Attestation which is basically what this is, always implies a move of some measure of control from the user to the content or service provider. It exists purely because they don't trust the user. There is just no way this would have ended positively.
And why would I go into discussion with Google? They don't own the web and never will. And their business model means they (and their employees) will always be my enemy because their goals are opposite to my own. I can criticise but it doesn't have to be constructive. A "Just NO" is fine too. I would be very happy with a world where Google doesn't exist.
But in this case the nerds won which means the way it was done worked perfectly fine. Perhaps they will have stepped on a few toes at Google but I'm kinda glad to hear that.
- jppittma 3y agoHey, look, it's the bad faith optics war again.
- thaumaturgy 3y agoEven more simply: let's not get dragged into debating the technical merits of something which is philosophically wrong. That particular person was trying really hard to reframe the whole argument into terms that would work in Google's favor -- if we just pointed out what was technically wrong with the proposal, why, they'd just fix those things and then we'd be good to go. But, it was philosophically wrong, because we've all understood the web to be fundamentally open and anonymous and not controlled by any one entity [1] for decades and most of us want it to stay that way. Even if WEI was technically sound, it would still be an enormous erosion of the principles of an open, anonymous, decentralized web. Any attempt to argue against WEI on its technical merits alone was just allowing Google to drag the whole fight into favorable territory. > And why would I go into discussion with Google? They don't own the web and never will. Oh, I think this is a big mistake. Google very nearly does own the web. Gmail handles, at last estimates, between 45% and 60% of email traffic, depending on who you talk to. Chrome or Chromium gets somewhere around 65% of the global browser market. Google gets around 90% of search traffic. Google ads. Google domains. YouTube. Google Cloud, which WPEngine for example runs on. Google Docs. Chromebooks. Android. I really need more people to pause and reflect for a moment on just how much of the internet is currently owned by Google. [1]: Well, ignoring ICANN, or Microsoft, or Google, or Cisco, or...