7 ms·
Why can't hotels make showers easier?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- resolutebat 3y agoI hate US hotel showers with a vengeance. Water pressure and temperature are orthogonal, you should be able to independently adjust each instead of cramming both into a single crank!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ars 3y agoAgreed. Pressure Balance valves are terrible. Instead get a Thermostatic valve, with a separate volume control. It costs more, but a much better experience, and better temperature control "set and forget".
- ginko 3y agoIt's strange that thermostatic valves aren't more common. They're pretty much standard here in Norway (and also in Japan as far as I've seen) but barely anywhere else for some strange reason. They're just downright better than anything else.
- kuschku 3y agoThey're also available in most of the EU, but no hotel actually uses them. My parents got them for their own bathroom and it's just so much better.
- karolist 3y agoPlenty of hotels I've been throughout Europe uses them, it's also easy to spot in the room pictures before booking usually. The most pleasant system I've tried is Grohe Smartcontrol which I've promptly installed in my house after trying, too bad they charge an arm and a leg for colored options, but plain chrome finish can be had for reasonable prices.
- mcv 3y agoWhen I first discovered those, I wouldn't have anything else anymore. It solves so many issues.
- ubercore 3y agoThis was a very pleasant surprise for me when I moved to Norway.
- troupo 3y agoUS showers and faucets in general are atrocious. I've been in houses with multiple showers, and each shower would have a different control scheme requiring a PhD in engineering to figure out. And don't forget the fixed shower heads
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stop50 3y agoThe best hotel showers i used had a lower level than the floor, a glass door and the door handle was at the wall with the regulatorso i was able to enter the shower without beeing hit with cold water. Tge only thing i dislike are the heavy perfumed soaps.
- kukkeliskuu 3y agoArticle is behind a paywall, so I did not read it. But here in Finland, most showers at homes and in hotels have traditionally used a Finnish brand which had a nice, simple design with two controls: one for both temperature and water volume (up and down is water volume, left and right is the temperature), and another for choosing the shower head (over the head or the hand held one), if the shower had two heads. But apparently that is changing now as well, and even the showers from that company are becoming more complex. The biggest change is that the now the control for choosing the shower head has been combined with water volume control. Temperature has another control. Also, instead of red and blue colors, plus and minus are used as symbol. They are often not as visible as red and blue. I guess that is "innovation". My 7 year old daughter sometimes has problems with these newer showers, as they work slightly differently depending on the model.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Someone 3y ago> one for both temperature and water volume (up and down is water volume, left and right is the temperature) Sounds inferior to having two controls. IMO the best designs have them separate. If you live alone, you set the temperature once and from then on only use the volume one. The magic that allows that is the thermostatic mixing valve (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermostatic_mixing_valve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermostatic_mixing_valve)
- mrweasel 3y agoI've replaced so many those thermostatic mixing valve shower controls, they absolutely suck. The build quality, even for the high end, is terrible. They don't deal well with hard water, high levels of lime in the water. Technically you're suppose to let cold water run through them after each shower to avoid it, but that means adjusting the knob every time you use it, and most of them are plastic, gripping a brass valve and that breaks the plastic over time (like 6 months to a year). I've given up and just buy the cheapest single control fitting I can find. The ones I've installed last have lasted 5 years so far without issue. You can't beat simplicity, $500 fixture breaks within a year, a $40 one will last a lifetime.
- adityaathalye 3y agoShowers are well and good, but bucket baths are underrated. Sit on a nice stool, with the bucket by you, a mug and a nice sponge if you feel like that. Any hotel that lets me have the option of a nice comfortable bucket bath is a winner in the bathing department.
- kylehotchkiss 3y agoI still love a hotel with a clean bathtub to soak in after a long day, but those appear to be fading away. Since you seem to be based in India, I have to say a lot of nice Indian hotels have the best giant bathtubs.
- adityaathalye 3y agoYeah, I've stayed in some of those, but I never could bring myself to fill up the bath owing to having grown up in a culture of water rationing (for good reason). One learns to have a hearty, satisfying bath using a little to maybe a little more. You could say I bathe in my conditioning.
- anilakar 3y agoGood old summer cottage bath. Ours must be the luxury version since two buckets and a large scoop is the norm though.
- Modified3019 3y agoDid that in indonesia. Place had a washroom with a large basin of water, a sort of tall bathtub looking thing. Sat on a stool and used a bucket to dump water on myself. It was... not my favorite thing.
- adityaathalye 3y agoOuch, I wouldn't like that either. A bucket and a mug is where it's at. Size matters you see.
- rapsey 3y agoYears ago when I was traveling the states with friends it was always amusing to figure out the damn hotel shower. Sometimes some just gave up and showered with cold water. Our simple European minds were not ready for the complexity of US showers.
- corbezzoli 3y agoLucky you. My first shower in the US was sitting down in the tub splashing some water from the lower faucet.
- stavros 3y agoIn Greece, we tend to have navy showers, which means that the water is only turned on when rinsing. I really hate US showers for not having a separate temperature control, forcing me to freeze every time I want to rinse. I also can't figure out how to actually soap myself up with a bunch of water on me. Do you actually step out of the stream and leave the water running, wasting it all?
- upon_drumhead 3y agoI let the water hit the back of me as i soap up the front and spin and rinse while I soap up the rear.
- Gud 3y agoIt's not just the US. Many European hotel chains also have some weird ass showers.
- quickthrower2 3y agoMy guess: it cuts into margins to make the showers better. And only at a certain point of luxury does it make a difference (i.e. I didn't pay for a Hyatt to get a cold shower...)
- wkat4242 3y agohttps://archive.ph/HiA9V https://archive.ph/HiA9V
- afterburner 3y agoArticle says half door means half as much to clean, but I think the most important part for the hotel developer was that it was half the price, or even cheaper since there's no hinge either. Neither the developer nor the supplier are using the shower, so what do they care. Hard to use controls probably also sold poorly and so were heavily discounted. What a deal! Again, no one would buy it for themselves. One joined floor for the shower and rest of the bathroom is a weird non-North American thing that is absolutely wrong and I sure hope isn't catching on here.
- brtkdotse 3y ago> One joined floor for the shower and rest of the bathroom is a weird non-North American thing that is absolutely wrong and I sure hope isn't catching on here. Hah, funnily enough every time I’m in the US I reflect about what a weird design those low faux-bathtubs are. To each his own I guess
- Espressosaurus 3y agoHaving spent weeks in countries with a single common wet bathroom, a separated wet and dry zone is much more friendly to use, but also less easy to clean. If your bidet is just a hose attached to the toilet instead of a washelet, there's something to be said for it, but I still don't enjoy the single common wet zone. A split zone design that separates the wet zone (like the shower or the tub) from the dry zone (toilet plus sink) is nice.
- brtkdotse 3y agoOnce you add kids to the equation the whole bathroom + a good portion of the connecting hall is now a wet zone.
- neodypsis 3y ago> One joined floor for the shower and rest of the bathroom is a weird non-North American thing that is absolutely wrong and I sure hope isn't catching on here. It is easier to clean and doesn't get mold.
- Physkal 3y agoCould much of the low pressure complaints could be associated with required to use a flow restrictor in the showerhead?
- happytiger 3y agoAbsolutely. There’s a correlation between popular states and low flow regulation too. If you are European and go on a regular trip to Vegas, Los Angeles, San Francisco and New York like so very many do you will literally be in low flow states the entire time. Isn’t that something? https://www.wilmar.com/info/low-flow-legislation https://www.wilmar.com/info/low-flow-legislation
- Physkal 3y agoI didn't know so many states require them, great info. Would be really interesting to hear from the hotel industry perspective what amount of customer complaints are largely due to regulatory decisions?
- happytiger 3y agoThanks! I have no objective data but there are lots of unintended consequences to well meaning regulation. Lots of good examples in the Law of Unintended Concequences: https://www.economicshelp.org/blog/2381/economics/law-of-unintended-consequences/ https://www.economicshelp.org/blog/2381/economics/law-of-uni... There are a lot of hotel issues that make it difficult for customers requiring accessibility. They can be fully in compliance with the ADA and the like, and consider themselves “accessible,” but the reality is far different. Lends some credence to the question of unintended side effects because they are meeting or exceeding the law’s standard but still not serving accessibility adequately. https://destinationsinternational.org/blog/seven-unintended-consequences-being-accessible-hotel https://destinationsinternational.org/blog/seven-unintended-...
- userbinator 3y agoI've seen talk on some forums of guests doing "restrictor deletes" where they stay. Unfortunately, but not surprisingly, it's a lot harder on newer fixtures, but on the older ones it's just a piece that is easily removed.
- sasaf5 3y agoThere are many more things hotels should get rid of: - carpets, - centrally controlled AC, - checkout lines. It baffles me how a cheap motel can get this right whereas the expensive chain hotel across the street can't.
- arghwhat 3y agoIn most hotels you can just drop the keycard at the front desk and leave. They know what to do. There’s also a lot of people that set the A/C to 18 degrees and leave, which is terrible.
- acjacobson 3y agoThis is why you see a number of hotels linking the A/C (and electricity etc) to keycards. If the keycard isn't in the slot, then the A/C isn't running.
- moepstar 3y ago..until someone finds out that whatever plasticky card you got in your purse doubles up as a keycard just fine - something just has to disengage the NC contact... Edit to add: and also keeps the outlets on (charging your phone, ...) and the lights if you so desire...
- eru 3y agoBusiness cards work as well.
- throwawaysleep 3y agoYou assume they haven’t. AC I understand, but I would bet carpets and human service are part of the perceived added value (especially when the expensive hotel crowd would be older). Also, most high end hotels I have been at have a key drop box at the front desk if you want to just go.
- 3y ago
- Someone 3y agoNext subject: hotel toilets. I’ll ignore water usage, but the ADA (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Americans_with_Disabilities_Act_of_1990 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Americans_with_Disabilities_Ac...) is decades old, so why are they still so low, and why do you have to bend over so far to reach the flush handle? (if you’re somewhat tall like me, it’s often easier to do that with your foot, but that feels weird)
- gniv 3y agoThe flooding issue is related to a general problem that seems hard to solve: when something breaks in the room and is not easily spotted by the cleaning person (like the shower drain being partly clogged), how do they find out? Do they rely on guests telling them?
- fwlr 3y agoGood cleaning checklists are set up to test quite a few of these things. Turn TV on/off to make sure remote works, turn AC on/off for the same, flush the toilet, run the shower, open the windows when you enter and close the windows when you leave, etc. Stocking the minifridge also functions as a check that the fridge is working, and so on. The maintenance team has an even more thorough checklist for preventative maintenance. But yes, guest reports are critical as well. You can elicit feedback with a simple "how was your stay? / how did you find the room?".
- mattlondon 3y agoShowers I can deal with, but a glass door and/or wall into the bathroom itself is just madness. I would like some privacy in the bathroom please.
- eru 3y agoPerhaps that's how they force more people to book separate rooms?
- koliber 3y agoThe half door is not the root of the problem. When I was building my house I very specifically did not want a door in my shower. I wanted a fixed glass wall that kind of looks like the first picture in the article. We paid tremendous attention to make sure that the floor in the shower is sloped at a sufficient angle to provide drainage. We measured and did splash experiments to make sure that the fixed glass wall extended far enough to keep the rest of the bathroom dry. The result is an elegant bathroom that is functional. If someone just superficially copies the look without paying attention to the functional aspects, the result is a wet bathroom. Cargo culting is everywhere.
- mcv 3y agoI also didn't want a door, so we've got a shower with no door, no threshold, no curtain. But the shower is around a corner. The rest of the bathroom stays dry because it's around the corner. The floor slopes, but sometimes we do manage to flood the bathroom because the drain gets clogged with hair fairly easily. And my oldest son always manages to get everything wet anyway.
- stavros 3y ago> “Unless you’re staying [overnight] in the model room, you’re not showering. You’re not flushing the toilet,” he says Wait, who pays for a hotel to not stay overnight? 100% of the use I make of a hotel room is for sleeping in.
- fwlr 3y agoI work at a medium-size hotel (~80 rooms), I can offer some insight. It's a combination of accessibility, cleaning, and maintenance. Accessibility: a hobbed shower - the small ridge, step, plinth, etc., around the edge of the shower base, that keeps water in the shower - is quite simply a huge dealbreaker for guests with mobility issues. Tripping over a toe-height ledge and trying to regain your balance on wet tiles is dangerous. Most accessibility-friendly non-hob solutions are going to let water out of the shower and onto the rest of the bathroom floor somehow, which pushes you towards a single joined floor for the whole bathroom to avoid water damage. Cleaning: Complicated surfaces, little pokey panels, extra seals, moving parts. All of it means cleaning takes longer (cleaning is by far the main cost for a given booking), and it also means cleaning is done less thoroughly (leading to poor reviews on cleanliness due to accumulating mould, grime, etc). Shower curtains in particular are brutal on your review score: they are hard to clean, so the cleaners don't do a great job, so they get mouldy quickly, and your guests hate this and give poor reviews for it. Maintenance: The median guest is fine, but one in twenty guests is just a hurricane of destruction. Want a shower door? That means hinges, which will snap and drop the door when this guest slams the door open or shut. Want shower curtains? This guest will grab them like they're handles and tear down the curtain rod. They will twist off tap handles and somehow lose them, they will pull those shower mixer taps out of the wall trying to get more water pressure - just about anything you can think of, plus many things you can't. (If you don't have a "one joined floor" setup, you're relying on the shower door being closed to prevent water damage, and this guest will definitely shower with the door open.) In the end, the main reason hotels can't make showers easier is fairly prosaic: they have to make showers robust towards all sorts of guests.
- koliber 3y agoIf you'd like to go deeper into the subject of confusing shower water controls, I recommend the book The Design of Everyday Things, by Don Norman. The problem is not new. The study of human factors is fascinating. Don Norman is something of an authority on this subject. While the book is largely about faucets and doorhandles, it helped fuel my passion for building functional software.
- underseacables 3y agoThe low flow showerheads in most hotels absolutely suck. It takes twice as long to shower, and not nearly enjoyable.