4 ms·
> But getting "founding engineer" level equity on the order of 0.5% (before dilution!) seems to basically be a scam, where you're working 2x the amount for lowe
by Aurornis 3y ago
> But getting "founding engineer" level equity on the order of 0.5% (before dilution!) seems to basically be a scam, where you're working 2x the amount for lower salaries than the market,
0.5% at an early stage with below market compensation, no refreshers with future rounds, negligible comp increase with future rounds, and below-market salary is indeed a scam. A lot of startups are happy to operate this way.
On the other hand, getting 0.5% equity in addition to market rate salary (or adjusted to market rate as soon as funding comes in) with refreshers on each raise to offset dilution and reasonable work life balance can be a very good deal.
I’ve worked for both types of startups. The first type quickly loses their best talent as they figure out they’re getting the short end of the stick. The second type can build a happy founding engineering team that grows with the company and wants to stay for the long term.
Fortunately, the internet has made it harder for companies to get away with the bad deal, below market rate, terrible WLB arrangement that was so common at startups a decade ago. Some people still get trapped by bad deals. Usually when you look at those companies giving bad deals it’s a small group of older founders managing a group of early 20s college grads who don’t yet know better.
- danielvaughn 3y agoYeah that's wild. I was a founding engineer once, and got 15% via a sweat equity agreement. No way I'd be considered a co-founder for under 1%.
- robervin 3y agoI believe the parent comment is using founding engineer to mean early employee (not necessarily first, and differentiated from "founder"). 15% is certainly "founder" levels of equity, but it's all arbitrary.
- Aurornis 3y agoFounding engineer usually implies that you’re getting paid because the company has raised funds or has significant income. Getting 15% is only really possible as a cofounder or if you’re joining as the only engineer before they have money to pay anyone. I assume that’s why you said “sweat equity agreement”. There can only be 100% total, so giving everyone from cofounders and the engineering team 15% would max out at 6 parties total, assuming no investors and the remainder goes to a pittance of an option pool for new hires. Unless you never plan to grow the company the math just doesn’t work. If you joined pre-money and took pure equity as compensation while building the company from scratch then you’re more traditionally called a co-founder.
- pc86 3y agoSerious question: if you're truly being paid a market-rate salary -- e.g. roughly as much as you could make at any other VC-funded enterprise, any FAANG company, etc, not the same $110k/yr you'd make at a bank or consulting firm -- why would you get any equity? The whole point of equity is that you have skin in the game and "work harder" (whatever that means) to make the company a success. At least in the early days part of that was accepting lower cash compensation in exchange for a piece of the upside. Why, if you're going to treat a founding or near-founding position as a 9-5, 40-hour week, clock-in-clock-out type of position, would you get a piece of the upside compared to just working at a bank or consulting firm?
- z0r 3y agoEquity is skin in the game. Why are you implying that a well paid engineer, in both salary and equity, would be treating their start-up role as a 9-5 bank job? At the very least a startup is not as safe a bet as a stable job at a big company like that. With equity they're going to want to work hard to increase the upside of their contributions.
- pdntspa 3y ago> Why, if you're going to treat a founding or near-founding position as a 9-5, 40-hour week, clock-in-clock-out type of position, would you get a piece of the upside compared to just working at a bank or consulting firm? One can be very dedicated on a 9-to-5 schedule. Just because you value WLB doesn't mean you are in a 'clock-in-clock-out' mentality. People have lives outside of work, may be even hobbies. The idea that a startup owns your life needs to die, stat. That is an extremely toxic line of thinking.
- axlee 3y agoThe point is also to keep people around. Software engineers are notoriously feeble, as they get offers extremely regularly.
- sokoloff 3y agoDo you mean “fickle” rather than “feeble”?
- satvikpendem 3y agoGenerally, startups don't pay market rate, it seems. I've seen offers for $125k - $175k as the base, while bigger tech companies will pay a total compensation of double or even triple that, so the 0.5% needs to make up for that difference. I don't see any startups paying at that "market rate" of big tech, as I've generally seen. Yes, I am focusing on big tech specifically but those that work at startups should be good enough to get into a big tech company anyway.