4 ms·
The US court system is really dropping the ball here. Simple evictions for nonpayment should take a week and almost no legal costs. Instead, I am looking at 6
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
The US court system is really dropping the ball here. Simple evictions for nonpayment should take a week and almost no legal costs. Instead, I am looking at 6+ months of lawyer and court costs in some of the states.
And this is at hotels. Our solution? Force all hotel guests to checkout before reaching the statutory number of nights that afford them tenant protections. Which is massively inconveniencing responsible people, all because the government wants to protect scammers.
- WalterBright 3y agoIn general, all of these "protections" just result in higher costs for everybody.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoSomewhat, some people suffer more costs than others. Scammers benefit from the protections, and responsible people shoulder the cost. Politicians should be providing housing to people if they want them to not be homeless, or paying the housing vendor. It’s easier to get elected by promising housing and low taxes though, and punt the costs onto select portions of the populace who play a game of trying to determine who is going to use the laws to scam them, which ends up resulting in discrimination.
- WalterBright 3y agoWhat do you think would happen if the government offered free middle class housing?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoConversing about anything involving the term “middle class” without an extensive definition of it is a waste of time. Obviously, free too much of anything skews incentives. But the consequences of homelessness should not be borne by select portions of the population.
- WalterBright 3y agoWe all know what the middle class is.
- michaelmrose 3y agoNo, no they shouldn't. We don't really want folks who lost their job last week to be out this week with all their possessions on the sidewalk. Everyone should have the option of a court date and some degree of legal help before ending up on the street in case they are getting cheated even if some people misused this. It is absolutely impossible to ensure good faith and lawful process by having the landlord make an unverifiable assertion followed by the cops kicking people out a week later. This isn't enough time to schedule a hearing let alone have the counter party getting representation. Furthermore factually society as a whole is better off as a whole if we have fewer people with crashed lives living like hobos on the sidewalk so its advantageous for such a process to be orderly and slow enough that people land somewhere other than flat on their back. People staying long term in hotels is an extreme edge case we shouldn't optimize the rest of the system for. What the law is telling you is that if you offer long term tenancy you are a landlord even if you call yourself a hotel. This and your decision not to get into the landlord business both seem to me perfectly acceptable. To quantify this let me ask you a question. How many of your folks staying over 30 days were planning on staying indefinitely? If the majority of the folks planning on staying 30 days were planning to leave in 90 perhaps the threshold should be increased to accommodate contractors and students who might need accommodations. If most of the folks over 30 days are lifers then maybe the threshold is already accurately set.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> We don't really want folks who lost their job last week to be out this week with all their possessions on the sidewalk. Cool, then that “we” (government, voters, taxpayers), should pony up for all the time that a tenant ends up staying and not paying. Otherwise, what “we” want is for a certain subset of society to subsidize not having people out on the sidewalk, as opposed to having it come from government coffers where everyone’s taxes would pay. Another option is for the government to provide housing for people. >It is absolutely impossible to ensure good faith and lawful process by having the landlord make an unverifiable assertion followed by the cops kicking people out a week later. This isn't enough time to schedule a hearing let alone have the counter party getting representation. I disagree. We have computers, broadband, and electronic databases. It takes 2 minutes to prove if you did or did not pay someone. Hell, in my case, I have an email from the squatter explicitly stating they will no longer pay unless they get a reduced price AND that they have done this to other hotels in the past AND that they waited until the statutory time passed so they could take advantage of eviction wait times.
- throwaway626 3y agoYou made an investment decision (allowing hotel guests to legally become tenants) and it ended poorly for you. Why should the government bail you out for “almost no cost”? The legal system doesn’t exist to insulate you from risk.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIt did not use to take 6+ months to evict a non paying tenant. This is a post Covid phenomenon. That is an insane amount of time to prove that someone did not pay you. How can anyone trust in the legal system if such a simple thing takes so long to get resolved? The legal system should exist to remedy legal disputes, for everyone, in a timely manner. Whether it be a big business or a small business or a personal dispute. A clogged legal system where simple disputes take an inordinate time to resolve is a sign of decay and corruption. You end up with people losing trust in the system, so now you have an incentive to take advantage, because others are going to take advantage of you. And then it becomes a game of who you know (more than it already is), or taking matters into your own hands.
- throwaway626 3y agoI’m sorry you failed to react to changing market conditions. Have you considered reinvesting in a less risky sector, like index funds?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoWe did react once we had the information. Do you expect businesses to monitor how long court cases take on a regular basis? Now, our many long term hotel guest have to pack up all their shit after a certain number of nights and go stay at a different hotel. So society inconveniences productive people, and conveniences a scammer. Does not sound like a net win for society. I don’t know if you are trolling, but if you are not, trust is worth a lot. Trust is what makes businesses in the developed world so productive, and lack of trust is what makes business so costly in the developing world.