3 ms·
First, how is the Khmer Rouge an example of containment, given that regime fell? Second, even if your argument is "genocide of anyone who sounds too smart was
by ben_w 3y ago
First, how is the Khmer Rouge an example of containment, given that regime fell?
Second, even if your argument is "genocide of anyone who sounds too smart was the right approach and they just weren't trying hard enough", that only really fits into "neither alignment nor containment, just don't have the AGI at all".
Containment, for humans, would look like a prison from which there is no escape; but if this is supposed to represent an AI that you want to use to solve problems, this prison with no escape needs a high-bandwidth internet connection with the outside world… and somehow zero opportunity for anyone outside to become convinced they need to rescue the "people"[0] inside like last year: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LaMDA#Sentience_claims https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LaMDA#Sentience_claims
[0] or AI who are good at pretending to be people, distinction without a difference in this case
- RandomLensman 3y agoIt means intelligence can be killed (and the Khmer were brought down externally). We might not even need to contain, all hypothetical.
- pixl97 3y agoWe don't have an answer yet to what the form factor of AGI/ASI will be, but if it's anything like current trends the idea of 'killed' is laughable. You can be killed because your storage medium and execution medium are inseparable. Destroy the brain and you're gone, and you don't even get to copy yourself. With AGI/ASI if we can boot it up from any copy on a disk if we have the right hardware then at the end of the day you've effectively created the undead as long as a drive exists with a copy of it and a computer exists than can run it.
- RandomLensman 3y agoNo power and it its already dead. Destroy copies, dead. Really not complicated at all.
- pixl97 3y agoYou talk with these interesting certainties. Like if a human dies and we have their body and DNA we can be pretty assured they are dead. With something like an AI you can never be sure as you must follow the entire chain of thermodynamic evidence of the past to when the AI was created that no copy of it was ever made. Not just by you, by any potential intruder in the system.
- ben_w 3y agoYou're the only example I know of, of someone using "containment" to mean "extermination" in the context of AI. Extermination might work, though only on models large enough that people aren't likely to sneak out of the office with copies for their own use and/or just upload copies to public places (didn't that already happen with the first public release of Stable Diffusion, or am I misremembering?)
- TeMPOraL 3y agoAh yes, the "all you gotta do is push a button" argument. Recall the timeless counterpoint: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ld-AKg9-xpM&t=30s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ld-AKg9-xpM&t=30s