3 ms·
> I'm ambivalent about the mortgage interest tax deduction. People act like it's some amazing cut-from-whole-cloth subsidy, but from a business context it's jus
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
> I'm ambivalent about the mortgage interest tax deduction. People act like it's some amazing cut-from-whole-cloth subsidy, but from a business context it's just a regular straightforward deduction of a customary expense.
Then why isn’t there a deduction for everything else we buy? It is a handout to real estate owners and lenders, and has zero reason to exist.
If the government wants to help people who do not have enough money, the government should give them cash. Or a home, if that is the goal.
- lotsoweiners 3y agoMost homeowners use the standard deduction now for about the past five years. This is a result of a tax policy change by the Trump administration.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoStandard deduction is incomparable to a specific deduction. A standard deduction is simply lowering tax rates for everyone.
- mindslight 3y agoPhilosophically, I think W2 workers should be able to deduct all of the expenses that are necessary and proper to earn one's income - commuting, professional clothes, a portion of food and housing, etc. What makes it a pragmatic non-starter is that it pushes individuals into even more accounting minutiae, which is its own form of horrible. Also keep in mind that interest on a loan is being reported as income elsewhere, so it is being taxed. It's just being taxed one less time. Politically, I don't see the point of singling out people who aren't short housing (aka they own one home) but still have a mortgage. Remember with rental properties all expenses are straightforwardly deductible (or depreciable), because revenue that pays expenses is distinct from income.