6 ms·
One of the top comments on the YouTube video attached to the article talks about how someone wasted their 20s working as the founding engineer (employee #6 of a
by satvikpendem 3y ago
One of the top comments on the YouTube video attached to the article talks about how someone wasted their 20s working as the founding engineer (employee #6 of a 6-person startup) and when the company exited for $100 MM, they only got 100k and are still working at 40 years of age while the other 5, presumably having cofounder-level equity, are retired.
This is the true risk of startups, and, if you're looking to maximize your earnings, it's best to either join a big tech company or start your own startup owning most of the equity, perhaps as a side hustle while you grow it enough to be profitable.
But getting "founding engineer" level equity on the order of 0.5% (before dilution!) seems to basically be a scam, where you're working 2x the amount for lower salaries than the market, all while having some nebulous carrot dangling in front of you for a reward that may never come, most likely, or even if it does, the value is so small as to not make up even on a per-hour basis the amount you spent working at the startup.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Berone 3y agoThe path to getting into these founder / c-suite roles is those founding engineer roles in which you can learn how to scale and operate these ventures. The founding engineer role at 0.5% is not meant to be a role to retire on, but a stepping stone to those bigger roles.
- satvikpendem 3y agoNot really, it's better to just start your own startup instead, there is not much need to spend years as a founding engineer before becoming a founder, you might learn some skills but it's nothing you can't learn yourself, as evidenced by the people who are first time founders who did not previously work at a startup. If you get to some scale and get acquired (or even shut down), you can leverage that for future higher positions that a founding employee would not get you.
- Berone 3y agoIt just depends on if you have the background and talent to warrant that role. I think that is an exceptional case for someone to get funding and support to build a venture without any operating experience.
- lazide 3y agoIf operating == running an existing similar company, then almost no successful founders I’m aware of had such experience before hand, did they?
- satvikpendem 3y agoMost companies that YC and other VCs fund are by first-time founders, mostly those who have not been in other startups. Like the other commenter said, the path to being a founder is actually founding.
- Ancalagon 3y agoExcept I personally know a number of CTO/co-founders that never served their time that way and went straight from Google/FB/big-tech to CTO..
- Berone 3y agoSure, I didn't mean to imply it's the only path to those seats.
- Seattle3503 3y agoIt seems common enough that early engineers are purged for "higher quality talent" from the big companies at some point. Most of the high quality engineers won't join early on because they don't work for startup equity. Once the business is established and salaries are higher those FANG engineers are happy to join.
- ClarityJones 3y ago> meant by whom?
- Berone 3y agoThe folks designing the compensation plan and explaining the plan to the potential employee. I can't speak to unethical cases in which things are misrepresented.
- compiler-guy 3y agoA "Founding Engineer" at 0.5% is an inflated title for "someone who can actually produce a project but is going to get clobbered at exit time." The title itself is mostly a lie.
- Berone 3y agoI agree. What started as a title that signaled the individual was there at the earliest parts of building the venture, it has been abused.
- catlover76 3y agoThe path to being a founder is actually founding. One doesn't need to be a "founding engineer" beforehand.
- lazide 3y agoBeing a better wheel isn’t going to put one in the drivers seat - no matter how good of one they are. That said, if someone is the type who pays attention and learns what is going on, being close enough to see certainly helps.
- mushufasa 3y agoWhile it's hard to comment on a specific situation, in my experience engineers are typically more interested in cash compensation rather than equity, even with less than 10 employees. And this is when offering them the option; they just choose the cash most of the time. Meanwhile, the founding team often is just paying themselves stipends for rent. So there's some classic risk tolerance here: if the company fails (which 90% of startups do), the founders have burned all their savings and have skills that are more broad than deep, whereas the employees are better off, and often more hireable given the skills they've developed in their specialization. Also, when things aren't going well for the company, the engineers can put out feelers to leave ship and line up another job, whereas the founders typically have to go down with the ship and shut the entire company down if they are exhausted. Yes, in the small % of cases the company is very successful, the founders will gain more, but it's disingenuous to not consider the risk. Startups are not a risk-adjusted way to maximize earning potential for nearly anybody --- not even VCs! VC returns overall typically are less than S&P500.
- nytesky 3y agoFrom digging around, I suspect there is a starting base phenomenon for that risk tolerance. For example I was watching a documentary and got curious about theglobe founders — one was the son of Valley business type and the other was the grandson of the founder of Nestle. Many engineers come from more pedestrian roots, and need money to make rent if the company folds, while the founders can accept “stipend” money because they have cash flow guarantees (probably estate tax avoidant annual gifts) and possible even jobs from family connections.
- dboreham 3y agoWasn't it jwz who first widely pointed this out: startup stock is a lottery ticket. Nobody should take 1/2 wages because their boss gave them a lottery ticket.
- Zelphyr 3y agoAnd then, hilariously, he said, "I just happened to have won that particular lottery."
- pseudalopex 3y agoWhy is it hilarious?
- neilv 3y agoAnd then his accountant/advisor said something like, "If you'd told me you were going to buy a nightclub, there are easier ways to lose all your money."
- mistrial9 3y agoyou know the best way to have a million dollars in the Rock'n Roll world? A. start with two million !
- neilv 3y agoIn JWZ's case, IIRC, he actually had this exchange with an accountant/advisor. But it seems to have worked out OK for him. Andreessen has made a lot more money since then, but JWZ got to build up many aspects of something cool that he cared about, and also occasionally still write some code on the side.
- Zelphyr 3y agoI guess you have to see it first-hand: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Q7FTjhvZ7Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Q7FTjhvZ7Y
- Aurornis 3y ago> But getting "founding engineer" level equity on the order of 0.5% (before dilution!) seems to basically be a scam, where you're working 2x the amount for lower salaries than the market, 0.5% at an early stage with below market compensation, no refreshers with future rounds, negligible comp increase with future rounds, and below-market salary is indeed a scam. A lot of startups are happy to operate this way. On the other hand, getting 0.5% equity in addition to market rate salary (or adjusted to market rate as soon as funding comes in) with refreshers on each raise to offset dilution and reasonable work life balance can be a very good deal. I’ve worked for both types of startups. The first type quickly loses their best talent as they figure out they’re getting the short end of the stick. The second type can build a happy founding engineering team that grows with the company and wants to stay for the long term. Fortunately, the internet has made it harder for companies to get away with the bad deal, below market rate, terrible WLB arrangement that was so common at startups a decade ago. Some people still get trapped by bad deals. Usually when you look at those companies giving bad deals it’s a small group of older founders managing a group of early 20s college grads who don’t yet know better.
- danielvaughn 3y agoYeah that's wild. I was a founding engineer once, and got 15% via a sweat equity agreement. No way I'd be considered a co-founder for under 1%.
- robervin 3y agoI believe the parent comment is using founding engineer to mean early employee (not necessarily first, and differentiated from "founder"). 15% is certainly "founder" levels of equity, but it's all arbitrary.
- Aurornis 3y agoFounding engineer usually implies that you’re getting paid because the company has raised funds or has significant income. Getting 15% is only really possible as a cofounder or if you’re joining as the only engineer before they have money to pay anyone. I assume that’s why you said “sweat equity agreement”. There can only be 100% total, so giving everyone from cofounders and the engineering team 15% would max out at 6 parties total, assuming no investors and the remainder goes to a pittance of an option pool for new hires. Unless you never plan to grow the company the math just doesn’t work. If you joined pre-money and took pure equity as compensation while building the company from scratch then you’re more traditionally called a co-founder.
- brettproctor 3y agoThese folks just put up a long post trying to weigh the risk v reward at various startup stages. Mostly summarized into: "Joining at Series C may give you an ideal combination of risk and reward. Series C startups had the highest weighted growth in our analysis, followed by Series B and A." https://www.joinprospect.com/blog/which-stage-startup https://www.joinprospect.com/blog/which-stage-startup
- bllchmbrs 3y agoThere are 2 problems with the analysis in the article: 1. They choose startups from 2014-2015. Valuations were (a) more reasonable then and (b) we've just been through one of the biggest bull markets of tech stocks in the past decades. 2. That taking the "Mean Valuation Growth" over that time period is meaningless if (a) there hasn't been a liquidity event and (b) if the mean is weighted by outliers (which it always is). Portfolio / VC strategy is a bet on power laws. We, as employees, don't have that opportunity. That means we've got to be deliberate about who we join to try to hit a power law outcome. Am I crazy here?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- a945a9o5u9 3y agoAnd that is exactly why I left my last company. As person #4 I was offered 1% over four years, an extremely below-market-rate salary, and no benefits. I left after exactly one year and didn't bother to exercise my 0.25%. People #2 and #3 left a little while after that. Person #1 / CEO / CTO / Maker-Of-All-Decisions is still there, somehow, still funded by monthly donations from family members and now crowdfunding.
- eweise 3y agoBeen working at startups on and off for over 20 years. In total I've spent more money on stock options than I've made from them.
- latchkey 3y agoNailed it.
- saliagato 3y agoCare to elaborate?
- nick222226 3y agoPay to exercise options and pay for imputed taxes. In a year or two company folds and you get nothing.
- eweise 3y agoYep this ^^^ If they only give you 90 days to buy your options when you leave the company, don't bother working there. Its a scam.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoI’ve been at various startups for over 10 years. My stock options have a cumulative value of $0
- xctr94 3y agoI’m on the same boat, plus the startup I helped co-found later found a loophole to steal my 20% of equity. Startups are a scam.
- abrichr 3y agoSorry to hear that. What was the loophole?
- fatnoah 3y ago
- ditonal 3y agoOne thing people need to remember is the world runs on incentives. And on this topic, there is a HUGE incentive to mislead people. The facts are: 1) Tech startups usually need a bunch of good engineers 2) Investors and founders want these engineers for as little money as possible, as almost every owner-labor relationship in history has gone 3) Stock options have mystique from once-in-a-lifetime companies like Google but are overall very complex financial instruments 4) Many engineers are a combination of poorly informed about these complexities and easily impressionable to be “sold” that these options are a good idea. The end result is a massive amount of effort expended to hoodwink engineers on this topic. The existence of the term “founding engineer” is exhibit 1, they are an employee and could simply be called software engineer, the term was invented to add the mystique (and workload) of a founder to what’s just a regular employee without founder equity. Exhibit 2 is this idea that being a founding engineer is a path to being a founder , this gets repeated ad nauseum despite being easily disproven by 5 minutes on linked, a slim percentage of hot startup founders had previously been “founding engineers” . Of course some startup experience might be useful but just as often you’re the code monkey hired precisely so that the actual founders have more time to do the founder stuff you’re not doing and therefore not learning. YC is basically a VC firm so it’s like taking Exxon Mobiles PR about climate change risk at face value. There’s a huge potential for bias. And even by VC firm standards YC has been shown to be exceptionally employee- hostile in their communications to founders and the behavior of their portfolio companies. Once again, people ask “what would a union do” and once again, here’s an answer. It could hire lawyers with a collective budget to review startup option terms and make them less likely to screw over early employees. Because the lawyers that the VCs hire are working to protect the VCs, not you. And the blog posts they publish on employee equity are written to serve their interests, not yours.
- kamikaz1k 3y agoWhat makes YC, employee hostile? Have they said anything?
- satvikpendem 3y agoThis is a good article on the ergodicity argument for VCs: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37869760 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37869760 Basically, VCs optimize for many small bets, ie investing in many, many companies where only one needs to hit it big in order to recoup the investment cost, while startups focus only on their own success, so it's in the VCs' best interest to sell the dream of working on or at a startup, thereby increasing VCs' own success without necessarily materially affecting the success of the startup itself.
- lucb1e 3y ago> the YouTube video attached to the article Which article? The two sentences below the video pointing you to watch the episode, did I miss something?
- satvikpendem 3y agoYes, my mistake, I just meant the page itself when I said "article," not that there is any extra material information besides the couple of sentences.
- jjav 3y agoKeep in mind it's not just the percentage, but whether it will be possible to keep any of it. I've done five startups now and my conclusion is I'll only consider joining a startup at two points: In the beginning, when the share valuation is less than a penny. The valuation is low, do an early exercise of all shares up front and file an 83b. Now, as you vest, you actually own the shares. So you can leave the company in the future and keep all your so-far vested shares. Or, late in the startup cycle when the company is already well-known and very clearly on the IPO path. Anywhere between these points is not worth it. The valuation will be too high to early exercise so may lose everything but the probability of success will be too low to take the risk.
- Eridrus 3y agoHow do you feel about options that can be exercised for 7+ years after you leave? Does that change your calculus at all.
- jjav 3y agoYes, that would make mid-growth startups more attractive to join. I know a few startups have done that but I haven't encountered one yet. Also, wasn't there a scandal a few years ago of a startup that promised that and later canceled? So would have to see the contractual wording carefully.
- Eridrus 3y agoI didn't hear about this, nor could I find anything specific on Google. I did find that apparently some companies have pretty aggressive clawback clauses, which is a huge yikes from me. Anyway, I think if you ever do talk to a mid stage startup, you should tell them this is what it would take to convince you. More people demanding it will likely cause the market to move.
- golergka 3y agoFor a full picture, how much cash did he get and how much tc was he worth at other, more established companies at the time?
- satvikpendem 3y agoThey didn't say, you could ask them on the YouTube comment, but it is likely that their TC was below market compensation, by the way they stated their story; if they were really satisfied with their TC, it's likely they wouldn't have made such a comment.
- moribvndvs 3y agoNot exactly the same, but I worked 11 years at a start up, the third hire. These were my prime years, gone in the blink of an eye, where I missed so much, made many sacrifices, and ruined my body and mental health… and got $2000 at the end. The stress was unbelievable the entire time. I even quit once but stupidly came back, and they kept throwing Monopoly money at me which was going to make me a millionaire, supposedly. I believed them, sunk cost fallacy and all, but eventually the owner got sick of it, sold it, and my position was diluted almost into oblivion. Maybe a shrewder person would have seen it coming, but I worked with several very smart and successful people and we all got taken on it. If things are bad and they start throwing Hail Marys at you to keep you around, I dunno man, it’s probably not worth it.
- Eridrus 3y agoI think there is a clear mismatch between how founders and employees value equity. The advice on the internet is to always ignore the equity component, but founders are definitionally there because they think the thing they are building will be worth something, otherwise they should still be working somewhere else. I think the actual takeaway here is that people who go to work at startups should be far more discerning about the company they are working for than when they are getting paid in liquid stock. I think early employees should also be willing to bail early if it's not growing at a rate that justifies the stake they get. I wonder how sensitive the HN crowd is to the specific % number here. Do you think 1% is a meaningfully better amount of equity for employee #6 (assuming this is the first non-founder)? Does front-loading vesting (eg, 35, 35, 20, 10) change your thoughts at all?
- joncrocks 3y agoThe mismatch is not necessarily down to a pure % game, it's related to who's in the room when decisions are made. The founders are the ones that will be in the room when things like share dilution etc. are discussed. The employees (likely) will not. The people in the room decide: a) Who can cash out when b) Who gets diluted and by how much If you're not in the room, you get no say.
- Eridrus 3y agoI am unaware of any situations where employees have been diluted out but founders have not. There are cases where everyone gets diluted out because the company is doing poorly and needs to be recapitalized, but in those situation everyone's shares are basically worth nothing and founders are unlikely to be issues large stakes. Companies do generally want to disincentivize employees from cashing out for a while since it lets them maintain a very low 409a valuation for common stock so that they can issue options with low strike prices (which is good for employees), but generally secondary markets do exist for companies that are doing well. But yes, fundamentally, employees and other small shareholders do not get to make the decisions about company fundraising, either in startups or big companies. The lack of control doesn't make these companies bad investments.