9 ms·
Exact same experience in New York. I toured a building which had dozens of units sitting empty. I found one I liked and tried to negotiate, because the asking p
by paxys 3y ago
Exact same experience in New York. I toured a building which had dozens of units sitting empty. I found one I liked and tried to negotiate, because the asking price was too high, and the leasing agent simply went "sorry the numbers come out of our software and I'm not allowed to charge any less".
The whole "efficient markets" theory goes for a toss when large corporate landlords representing a disproportionate share of the market are all able and willing to just sit on empty units and take temporary losses while prices steadily go up.
- tempsy 3y agoWhat share of apartments in NYC are actually managed by corporate landlords? It actually seems like one of those markets where they are the minority.
- jpalawaga 3y agoI wouldn't be so sure. I lived in an old pre-war building that was owned (and changed ownership between) property management/private equity companies. If anything, the large buildings in nyc call for corporate landowners instead of every day people renting second homes.
- tempsy 3y agoThat’s not the same as say renting an Avalon apartment. When I think corporate manager I think of the publicly traded rental companies like Avalon and Equity Residential.
- UncleMeat 3y agoWhy is this meaningfully different? In both cases you are dealing with a corporation. In both cases that corporation is using whatever software to set rents. The inflection point is between "I can work with my landlord as an individual person" and "there is some fucking management company sitting between me and any sort of thing I need to get done." That inflection point is long before you have 10,000 doors.
- jpalawaga 3y agothe company who owned my apartment, Rose Associates, used the software in TFA. I got the "sorry software says no" response from the leasing agent. So... I don't think they're as different as you think.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paxys 3y agoIn my experience close to 100% have brokers and large property management companies handling at least the leasing process, so the end result is the same.
- l3mure 3y ago> As of October 2022, according to New York real estate data tracker JustFix, landlords with ten or fewer units own only 13.2 percent of the city’s total stock and only 1.2 percent of all rent-stabilized apartments. By contrast, the top 5 percent of New York City landlords control nearly 65 percent of units and 87 percent of rent-stabilized ones. Staggeringly, the top 0.3 percent of landlords, whose portfolios exceed one thousand units, hoard almost 44 percent of the city’s rental units, and a whopping 56 percent of those protected by rent-stabilization. https://thebaffler.com/latest/pity-the-landlord-dulik https://thebaffler.com/latest/pity-the-landlord-dulik
- tempsy 3y agoI guess I distinguish between large landlords and “corporate landlords”. When I think of corporate landlords I think of publicly traded apartment managers like Avalon. Those exist in NYC but it’s not the most common type of rental at all.
- shin_lao 3y agoIt's mostly luxury rental buildings but it's enough to create distortion.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoWouldn't have to be "corporate landlords". Realpage and the others (Yardi, MRI, Entrata, Appfolio) also have single-family modules or software products. It's not all just multi-family. Hell, I think Realpage actually has several different single-family software titles (they tend to do lots of acquisitions). This isn't 1982, no one wants to manage this crap on paper, or in some craptastic Excel spreadsheet.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> The whole "efficient markets" theory goes for a toss when large corporate landlords representing a disproportionate share of the market are all able and willing to just sit on empty units and take temporary losses while prices steadily go A sufficiently high property tax would fix incentives very quickly.
- shin_lao 3y agoProperty tax in NY is very high. Don't understand your logic.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoObviously not high enough if the ROI for empty housing is more than occupied housing.
- nerpderp82 3y agoThere should be a higher tax on unoccupied units, and they shouldn't be able to write down the unit as a loss (I don't know if this is even possible, a whole building but they shouldn't be able to structure their revenue like that).
- randomdata 3y agoOr too high, compelling landlords to hold out for a higher bidder on rent to cover the cost of the taxes. Once you accept a tenant, you are effetely stuck with them, so one has to be careful to choose wisely. Imagine a hypothetical scenario where tax is $1,000 per month, the cost of hosting a tenant is $500 per month, and prevailing rents are $1,500. –– You can accept a tenant right away and break even. Or you can wait a couple of years until someone agrees to pay $2,000 per month. Which do you choose? Spend $18,000 to wait and then make $120,000 in the following 20 years, or spend nothing now and make $0 in the following 20 years? On the flip side, if the tax were only $500 per month then you could accept the tenant willing to pay $1,500 right away.
- 3y ago
- wbl 3y agoThe optimal duration to hold out in hopes of getting a renter who will pay the asked price is not zero. The main contributor to rising prices is politicians helping prevent development.
- cudgy 3y agoAnd then the next day, they lower the price 20% because the software said to do it only hours after a customer was willing to lease it for a negotiated 10% discount. The coordination of the human and software workflows is atrocious, based on what I observed when leasing a house from a big landlord/investment firm. The roles of human leasing agents has to have changed greatly at these companies; my guess is they are more administrative now, with much less interaction with the tenants.