3 ms·
As someone who uses Mint heavily, it's incredibly unclear whether this is going to negatively impact me or not. Because: > [Credit Karma] “offers a simplified
by crazygringo 3y ago
As someone who uses Mint heavily, it's incredibly unclear whether this is going to negatively impact me or not. Because:
> [Credit Karma] “offers a simplified way for you to build awareness of your spending, and track your savings.” Intuit says it still plans on adding ways to view transactions, track spending, and aggregate financial accounts.
> Earlier this year, Credit Karma added one of Mint’s key features: the ability for users to track their net worth. Intuit says Mint users can transfer their accounts by logging into Credit Karma from the Mint app.
In my Mint usage, I've never cared about budgeting or categorization (their auto-categorization was never accurate anyways). I just want to aggregate all my accounts, track my monthly spending, and track my overall net worth.
So this might be... fine? Or it might not be? It's just truly bizarre that:
1) They're forcing the transition to a ludicrously short 2 month period (why not give 6 months or a year to migrate?)
2) They're doing a horrible job at conveying whether Credit Karma is a good replacement or not (how about a simple comparison chart of features?)
3) They're destroying the Mint brand, which is valuable and consumer-friendly. Meanwhile "Credit Karma" just sounds like a scam
If Intuit wants to better monetize Mint, it seems like it would be vastly better to port the profitable Credit Karma features over to Mint, rather than migrate Mint users to Credit Karma.
What Intuit is doiung is utterly baffling to me, and smells like internal politics over at Intuit is taking precedence over good/profitable product decisions, which does not give me faith in the overall management at the company. Shutting down Mint to replace it with Credit Karma has very strong vibes of shutting down Digg v3 to replace it with Digg v4.
I hope this turns out well in the end, but given what an atrocious job they're doing in communicating it, I'm not holding my breath.
- alsodumb 3y agoTo be honest I don’t think their decisions are that baffling once you start thinking in terms of money. 1. Credit karma doesn’t have all the features that mint does. I suspect they don’t plan on adding them either. But if you say that no one’s gonna sign up on credit karma. Might as well keep it vague and hint the new app can do that and hopefully some people end up signing up on credit karma. 2. I don’t think the care about mint brand. It’s pretty clear that mint wasn’t making enough money and they decided the effort needed to manage it isn’t worth it. On the other hand, credit karma is probably making a lot more money and much much easier to maintain - all it does is pull data from credit agencies. Credit karma recommends cards/loans etc. which I suspect is how they’re making good bucks. Either way, it sucks for us. I suspect mint did some user surveys to see if they could make a paid version of mint work and realized not a lot of people are gonna pay for it. Sucks for us.