7 ms·
How “blue” and “green” appeared in a language that didn’t have words for them
- turminal 3y agoRelated, one of my favorite in-depth stack overflow answers: https://stackoverflow.com/a/33206814 https://stackoverflow.com/a/33206814
- chatmasta 3y agoHere's a useful one-liner to print the code for each of the 256 colors in their respective color, so that you can quickly see which one you want: for i in {0..255}; do printf "\x1b[38;5;${i}mcolor%-5i\x1b[0m" $i ; if ! (( ($i + 1 ) % 8 )); then echo ; fi ; done
- WalterBright 3y agoYou can make any program in a ; language a one liner.
- olddustytrail 3y agoWell sure, but I think everyone would understand a one liner as something that fits in a single loop. And you know that. Why are you arguing about this?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- o11c 3y agoIf we're doing one-liners, there are several advantages to: for i in {0..255}; do printf '\e[48;5;%dm%-10s' "$i" "color$i"; if (( (i >= 16 && i < 232) ? (i%6 == 3) : (i%8 == 7) )); then printf '\e[m\n'; fi; done There are several more-complete versions floating around on the internet; I have personalized 2 myself ... hmm, I don't seem to have the one I remember that does contrast automatically ...
- kens 3y agoFor more on why languages start with words for "dark" and "light", then add red, blue and other colors in order, see my Journal of Irreproducible Results paper "Laundry and the origin of basic color terms": https://righto.com/papers/laundry.pdf https://righto.com/papers/laundry.pdf
- fsckboy 3y agoit's a serious paper on a light hearted topic? or absolute nonsense but funny? I'm not certain if the Journal of Irreproducible Results has any standards about these things.
- arketyp 3y agoThe introduction was interesting and thankfully the reference checks out as serious: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Color_Terms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Color_Terms
- fsckboy 3y agoit's funny one of the links on that wiki page I had already visited, "Tinctures in heraldry"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kens 3y agoTo clarify, the Journal of Irreproducible Results was a magazine of scientific humor. The article is a plausible but absurd explanation for a real linguistic phenomenon, Basic Color Terms.
- reppelle 3y agoRule 4 appears non-universal to me. Japanese historically developed ao (blue) before midori (green) which is still considered a shade of ao. I guess you could argue since the Japanese conception of ao includes both blues and greens that it fits, but it seems odd to me.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoIt’s not just about different languages. I bet a graphic artist sees distinctions in colors that most people would group together. At the extreme end, Pantone has made a massive business of precisely dividing shades of colors.
- finite_depth 3y agoThe idea here is not what words a language has names for, but what words a language considers "primary". "Azure" is an English color-word, but an English speaker recognizes "azure" as a kind of "blue". But "blue" is not a kind of "green" or a kind of "purple" or a kind of anything else. Hence, "blue" is a basic English color-word. Typical English dialects have eleven basic color words: white, gray, black, brown, pink, red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and purple. Other color-words in English are considered variants of one of these eleven terms. That wasn't always true ("pink" is the most recent addition, dating to the early 1700s), but it's pretty well-established by modern English speakers. Other languages may make fewer distinctions (e.g. until about the last century Japanese used ao(i) as a basic color word that encompassed both blue and green, so e.g. a traffic light is aoi by tradition even though the modern word for green is midori) or more (e.g. Russian distinguishes light blue goluboi and dark blue sinii similarly to how English distinguishes red and pink). To an old Japanese speaker, blue and green were both shades of ao, and to a modern Russian speaker, goluboi is as distinct from sinii as "red" is from "pink" in English (they are not both "shades of blue" any more than pink and red are "shades of reddish" in English).
- Turing_Machine 3y agoInteresting. Sometimes people use "pink" or "purple" to describe magenta, but (to me) magenta isn't either of those colors. Purple is the color that in technical contexts is known as violet, and pink is absolutely a type of red to me, specifically a desaturated red.
- BrandoElFollito 3y ago> an English speaker recognizes "azure" as a kind of "blue" at least in French, azur is a kind of blue (washed out dark blue, I would say). I guess it came to us from Spain.
- hardlianotion 3y agoHow is one supposed to read “Tsimane’”?
- finite_depth 3y agoRoughly, (t)see-ma-nay or chi-ma-nay. The first sound is an affricate consonant, similar to the sounds spelled ch or j in English (e.g. the final sound of "catch" in General American). The last sound should properly be spelled é, not just e, and is similar to the sound spelled with that letter in French or the sound spelled "ay" in English words like "pray" (also in General American).
- hardlianotion 3y agoThanks. It’s spelled with e’ in the article which just seemed mysterious.
- fsckboy 3y agothe other key to pronouncing japanese as an American, starter pack, is to NOT put stress on syllables the way we do. Japanese green horseradish (like with sushi) is not waSAAbi the way we want to pronounce it, it's something like three equal syllables pronounced distinctly wa. sa. bi. then put them together and pronounce them fast wa.sa.bi. UK English has the same stress patterns as American English (Shakespeare, iambic pentameter) but I just haven't given any thought to whether my advice would be any different I said "starter pack" because imho the first step is to stop pronouncing things American. Japanese does have some stress patterns, but you're not going to learn them easily. So just learn to flatten out the American stress and you are 80/20 there. Because you are so used to American stress, to your ear it will sound like you are saying WAAsabi, which is closer to your goal, but don't do that on purpose, and not long syllables, not waaaa saaaa biiii, clip them short and just flatten them out, wasabi and you'll be fine. ka-ra-o-k. sy-a-na-ra.
- Izkata 3y ago> The last sound should properly be spelled é, not just e Assuming this is a Japanese word as the other response uses (the article doesn't really make it clear), there's at least two different transliteration styles for that sound, one of which is "é", the other of which is "e". I'd argue over the past decade or two the second one has become more common due to simplicity, direct transliteration of individual hiragana, and IME inputs. Names still seem to use the older style though. Though here the author did seem to be going for "é", but didn't have a way to type it so they approximated it by adding a ' afterwards.
- NeoTar 3y agoI have wondered with colour words if the increasing prevalence of computers and their related vocabulary is influencing English speakers use of colour words. For instance, as mentioned in the article English speakers have historically divided the range of colours into: Black, White, Red, Green, Blue, Yellow, Purple, Brown, Orange and Grey. South American Spanish, along with Italian and Russian add a distinction between light-blue and dark-blue (maybe like the distinction between Red and Pink). In computers the most natural set of colours is more like: Black, White, Red, Green, Blue, Cyan, Magenta and Yellow. Has this influenced English speakers to draw incorporate new colour terms into their common vocabulary - Magenta 'feels' too close to pink to be a new colour for me, but Cyan (or equivalently Turquoise or Azure) feels different enough to be a new and distinct colour.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BrandoElFollito 3y agoIn France purple is not in the set. We have blue, white, red (obviously), black, yellow, green, gray. No orange, no purple, no brown - we of course know these colors but we would not use them when "dividing" colors into sets.
- solardev 3y agoWhat color is the soil?
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoThe color of the soil. All of the languages with a paucity of dedicated color words can readily describe colors by reference. Orange, pink, and violet are not actual color words either. They've been imported to perform dual duty from their original meaning because they were used frequently enough to describe the color of oranges, pinks, and violets.
- 3y ago
- dukoolio 3y agoHave to mention the related post from 2012 that made me fall in love with HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4956037 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4956037
- jkleiser 3y agoI can recommend this book by Guy Deutscher: "Through the Language Glass: Why the World Looks Different in Other Languages"
- samtho 3y agoThis is not unique to Amazonian languages, in fact, it’s observed so much in other languages that I wonder how strange “western” languages are to make this distinction. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue%E2%80%93green_distinction_in_language https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue%E2%80%93green_distincti...
- whatshisface 3y agoWhy wouldn't they just say "leaf color?"
- latchkey 3y agoIn Vietnamese, it is basically the same word and they say "sky blue" for "blue" or "green grass". As a result, my partner always gets green/blue in English mixed up.
- vesinisa 3y agoMy 2.5 year old son has trouble telling apart blue and green eventhough our language considers them strictly separate colors, like English. Apparently it takes practice to learn them apart, and maybe it's even impossible if you need to learn it as an adult.
- 1-6 3y agoYup, same in Korean. You’ll hear lots of adults say the blue grass or blue light (for traffic signals).
- dehrmann 3y agoAs an English speaker, this is just bizarre because we have so many words for colors. Of course we have both periwinkle and lavender.
- canjobear 3y agoThere is a fairly involved definition of "basic color word" that goes into this research. Basically, most English speakers would agree that periwinkle is a shade of purple, but would certainly not say that green is a shade of blue. In this sense purple, green, and blue are basic color words but periwinkle is not.
- ars 3y agoBut pink is just light red, and it's on that list.
- cryptonector 3y ago> As an English speaker, this is just bizarre because we have so many words TFIFY. English has imported so many words...
- asimpleusecase 3y agoI taught English in Mongolia years ago. My students did not make a distinction between orange and yellow. But they had distinct words for shades of blue that came across as primary. It was not a research project, just working interactions.
- sophacles 3y agoHonestly I see a lot of native english speakers struggle with the difference quite often. I drove an old constructio pickup for a while - very much yellow (even according to ford). Yet a very large number of people talked about my big orange truck.
- cjohnson318 3y agoOrange as a concept didn't arrive in Northern Europe until oranges, the fruit, were imported through (Moorish?) Spain. Chromatically, the space between red and yellow is a lot tighter than the space between yellow and blue. We don't really need a separate color name there, but we have one; it's a distinction that English speakers agree on. If you look at the Munsel color system, one of the first scientific, equidistant color systems, it goes from green, blue, purple, red, yellow, "skipping" orange as a distinct, named color.
- Tagbert 3y agoFor English speakers, do you think that you have a limitation in your ability to see and distinguish variations of blue because you have a single word, "blue" that covers a range of colors? In Russian there are two colors for blue, "goluboy" and "siniy". "goluboy" if for lighter blues, and "siniy" is for darker blues. Does this mean that Russians are more attuned to difference in the concept of blue or just that they have discrete names that are more convenient when talking about some kinds of blue?
- Pigalowda 3y agoMaybe, although we use extra adjectives like Royal blue, sky blue, powder blue, navy blue, etc That may get the color differentiation down well enough for regular people to use. Maybe not for blue experts though.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoNo. You can still see. I used to spend time in a chat room where you could configure the background and foreground color of your text; I used blue on cyan.
- aeonik 3y agoYou can still see it, but you pay less attention to it, in some cases if the color has no meaning to you, then it you become attention blind to it. I used to not pay any attention to colors, but I heard men have high rates of color blindness, and I also heard about tetrachromats. I took a bunch of tests, I'm not color blind, nor am I a tetrachromat, but after those tests I take my color vision more seriously and try to distinguish more colors.
- unclenoriega 3y agoResearch shows that the way your native language divides colors does affect your ability to distinguish them. For example, a Russian speaker would more quickly and easily distinguish two similar shades if one is goluboy and one is siniy. However, with training, anyone with adequate color vision can learn to be as or more proficient.
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoI wonder what would this study would say about the greeks and the Egyptians. Ancient Greeks did not have blue in their language. Egyptians did. They intermingled pretty famously, too
- mikhailfranco 3y agoHomer: the bronze sky and the wine-dark sea... The Wine-dark Sea and Perception in the Ancient World https://clarkesworldmagazine.com/hoffman_01_13/ https://clarkesworldmagazine.com/hoffman_01_13/
- crabbone 3y agoI think that the main point the article tries to make isn't specific to colors. It's about language influencing how our minds process "raw" information. And, to anyone who speaks more than one language well this is nothing new. Sometimes we don't have a "good" translation for a concept in one language, but because it's accessible to us in another language, we'd invent a way to adapt that concept using the lacking language. This is especially common when translating from a "bigger" language into a smaller one. For example, early modern Hebrew speakers loaned a lot of concepts from Russian (beside other languages), but because Russian and Hebrew are very different, they had to put some serious effort into adaptation. Ukrainian language underwent a process where a lot of terminology had to be invented or translated from other languages because for years it wasn't used in academia or industry. Computer-related jargon is full of instances where concepts were borrowed from English but had to be adapted to the loaning language. In Hebrew, it's a subject of many jokes, because early attempts at adaptation tried to rely on Hebrew roots instead of borrowing words / concepts phonetically, but now very few people know what was meant by that (eg. "tsag" -- the early version of translation of "monitor").