3 ms·
You have a point. A good example is the Additional Buyer's Stamp Duty (ABSD) in Singapore. It's an additional tax on foreigners or Singaporeans who buy multip
by refurb 3y ago
You have a point.
A good example is the Additional Buyer's Stamp Duty (ABSD) in Singapore. It's an additional tax on foreigners or Singaporeans who buy multiple homes. There is a normal stamp duty when you buy a home, which is 5%.
In order to "tamp down" the housing market, the ABSD in Singapore is now 60% for foreigners. Yeah, the tax on a home is 60% of the purchase price. So a $1M home would have a $650,000 tax when you purchase it ($50,000 BSD + $600,000 ABSD).
Does that stop rich foreigners from buying multi-million dollar properties as investments? Nope. In fact, one wealthy Chinese guy bought a whole building for $293M and had to pay $60M in ASSD (it was only 20% back then).
https://coconuts.co/singapore/news/mystery-chinese-family-drops-s300m-to-buy-entire-orchard-condo-building/ https://coconuts.co/singapore/news/mystery-chinese-family-dr...
So the argument that a Georgist land tax will magically fix the "unproductive land" problem is a bit naive.
- fragmede 3y agoSay, how does housing get built in Singapore? Do they have weird taxes and just hope that developers deign to build housing, or does the government there do something more direct, in order to get housing built?
- refurb 3y agoThe government auctions off land for development. All on 99 year leases, so the government gets it back in the end for further development. There is enough demand for housing that developers keep building.