4 ms·
They could still show ads without all the invasiveness. For example: advertisers could pay to place ads in specific Facebook groups and they would show to peopl
by latexr 3y ago
They could still show ads without all the invasiveness. For example: advertisers could pay to place ads in specific Facebook groups and they would show to people visiting those pages. Like it has been done for decades in magazines and other physical media. The internet did not invent advertising.
- geek_at 3y agoexactly and even if they didn't take "personalized data" into account, they can still serve you ads based on pages/profiles you liked
- Zanni 3y agoThat's exactly what's being banned. Pages and profiles you like (along with other personal data) is what drives "behavioral advertising."
- adrr 3y agoThey don't work effectively if they aren't targeted on who you are. It would be like TV ads. Biggest example is the IOS privacy which has hit whole industry in terms of marketing effectiveness and cost.
- fsflover 3y agoAny reference proving this?
- adrr 3y agoFB earnings or any earnings from any company that is heavily dependent on performance marketing. And for small businesses. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/08/small-businesses-count-cost-of-apples-privacy-changes/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/08/small-businesses-cou...
- fsflover 3y agoBut did they compare their earning to those with non-tracking, contextual ads?
- justapassenger 3y agoThere’s a reason why magazines ads are dying and being replaced by personalized ads. Advertising like that is widely inefficient. It’s easy to show ads. Not that easy to make money from doing so. It’s as valid alternative as telling people to use horses instead of cars to reduce CO2 emissions. They both get from point A to B, right?
- polygamous_bat 3y ago> There’s a reason why magazines ads are dying and being replaced by personalized ads. Advertising like that is widely inefficient. Too bad, if your business model can’t make money without breaking laws and harming people’s rights, do you really deserve to stay in business? > It’s as valid alternative as telling people to use horses instead of cars to reduce CO2 emissions. They both get from point A to B, right? More like banning formula 1 cars from suburbs. People survived before without personalized ads, what will not survive is making 10-digits of profit every quarter and the associated butchery of our life and institutions in the pursuit of profit.
- foota 3y agoWhen you're debating the merits of the law in question, it doesn't seem like a valid defense to say "if they can't do business under the law then that's their fault". If I say "car dealers can't sell cars that go faster than 10mph and if they go out of business then they shouldn't exist", it's clearly fallacious, and I don't see how this is any different.
- kaftoy 3y agoIt is different. Rules and laws are supposed to make sense, but the one with 10 mph is not. There are limita to 250 kph in Europe and I dont see car dealers going down. Also, for years there are emissions regulators that make life hard for auto makers, but they obey and still sell cars.
- shaftway 3y ago
- elorant 3y agoMagazines have context though. You buy an art magazine, you'll see a Mercedes ad because it's likely that people who're interested in art make more than average. Facebook without tracking has no context whatsoever, aside from Groups and that's debatable.
- thepangolino 3y ago[dead]