4 ms·
> The limit is where does the train go on a Guilford to Croydon run - there is no room in Croydon for it to turn round - see London Overground neededing to crea
by vidarh 3y ago
> The limit is where does the train go on a Guilford to Croydon run - there is no room in Croydon for it to turn round - see London Overground neededing to create a third line in West Croydon.
Trains already follow the entire route, which is sufficient proof that this problem is solvable. Croydon doesn't need to be the first/final stop - that's entirely besides the point. Indeed, this specific journey doesn't need to be viable - that too is entirely besides the point.
> No you have misunderstood me - because the CJ->G journey is over straighter tracks it can run faster than on slow lines elsewhere and mis out stops. The main point is that time on a railway is not only determined by track miles but also type of track and other trains on the tracks.
That's fine but irrelevant. As I've pointed out, journey times for the individual legs of the route are fast enough to make it viable. And there is no need for it to be able to run faster to miss out stops. It'd be a nice bonus to be able to, but it's not needed for the argument I've made at all.
> I also think Croydon to Guildford would never be sustainable - there are many other places that need upgrading first.
It certainly isn't sustainable. That is exactly the point I was making: Planning based on what is sustainable is entirely backwards thinking when optimising transport. You need to plan based on what you can make sustainable as part of driving larger changes. And again, the specific journey is irrelevant. Not the point.
> Especially as the link is already reasonable - the speed up would not be sufficient.
... but this is just not true. The link is not reasonable. That was my starting point: The existing connection is enough of a hassle that it stopped my former boss moving his company to Guildford because half his staff would leave if he did. I was one of the one who would have quit over that. Had there been direct trains from Croydon that were were regular enough and direct I'd have been fine. Even without trains going any faster or skipping any stations based on existing travel times on existing trains between Croydon and Epsom and Epsom and Guildford.